Can Patents Prohibit Research? On the Social Epistemology of Patenting and Licensing in Science (2014)
Keywords Intellectual property rights in science; Genetically modified (GM) seeds; Commercialization of science; Iteration; Science and values; Agnotology A topic of growing importance within philosophy of science is the epistemic implications of the organization of research. This paper identifies a promising approach to social epistemology---nonideal systems design---and uses it to examine one important aspect of the organization of research, namely the system of patenting and licensing and its role in structuring the production and dissemination of knowledge. The primary justification of patenting in science and technology is consequentialist in nature. Patenting should incentivize research and thereby promote the development of knowledge, which in turn facilitates social progress. Some have disputed this argument, maintaining that patenting actually inhibits knowledge production. In this paper, I make a stronger argument; in some areas of research in the US---in particular, research on GM seeds---patents and patent licenses can be, and are in fact being, used to prohibit some research. I discuss three potential solutions to this problem: voluntary agreements, eliminating patents, and a research exemption. I argue against eliminating patents, and I show that while voluntary agreements and a research exemption could be helpful, they do not sufficiently address the problems of access that are discussed here. More extensive changes in the organization of research are necessary.
...MoreDescription On patents and patent licenses regarding research on GM seeds.
Similar Citations
Article
Baldini, Nicola;
Fini, Riccardo;
Grimaldi, Rosa;
Sobrero, Maurizio;
(2014)
Organisational Change and the Institutionalisation of University Patenting Activity in Italy
(/isis/citation/CBB001420874/)
Article
Charnley, Berris;
(2013)
Seeds Without Patents: Science and Morality in British Plant Breeding in the Long Nineteenth-Century
(/isis/citation/CBB001320687/)
Article
Christoff, Peter;
(2013)
Climate Discourse Complexes, National Climate Regimes and Australian Climate Policy
(/isis/citation/CBB001320850/)
Article
Kelly Joslin Holloway;
(September 2015)
Normalizing Complaint: Scientists and the Challenge of Commercialization
(/isis/citation/CBB582502078/)
Article
Adi Sapir;
Amalya L. Oliver;
(February 2017)
From academic laboratory to the market: Disclosed and undisclosed narratives of commercialization
(/isis/citation/CBB802340812/)
Article
Helen Anne Curry;
(2022)
Hybrid Seeds in History and Historiography
(/isis/citation/CBB907533787/)
Book
Dudley, Leonard;
(2012)
Mothers of Innovation: How Expanding Social Networks Gave Birth to the Industrial Revolution
(/isis/citation/CBB001201315/)
Book
Hans Radder;
(2019)
From Commodification to the Common Good: Reconstructing Science, Technology, and Society
(/isis/citation/CBB983107822/)
Thesis
Xan Sarah Chacko;
(2018)
Moving, Making, and Saving Botanic Futures: The History and Practices of Seed Banking
(/isis/citation/CBB692555133/)
Article
Phillips, William H.;
(2010)
The Democratization of Invention in the American South: Antebellum and Postbellum Technology Markets in the United States
(/isis/citation/CBB001211701/)
Article
Khan, B. Zorina;
(2013)
Going for Gold: Industrial Fairs and Innovation in the Nineteenth-Century United States
(/isis/citation/CBB001320689/)
Article
Schauz, Désirée;
(2014)
What is Basic Research? Insights from Historical Semantics
(/isis/citation/CBB001420878/)
Article
Plomer, Aurora;
(2013)
The Human Rights Paradox: Intellectual Property Rights and Rights of Access to Science
(/isis/citation/CBB001320070/)
Article
Mario Biagioli;
Alain Pottage;
(2021)
Patenting Personalized Medicine: Molecules, Information, and the Body
(/isis/citation/CBB302669888/)
Book
Katerina Sideri;
(2016)
Bioproperty, Biomedicine and Deliberative Governance: Patents as Discourse on Life
(/isis/citation/CBB016823973/)
Article
Shimizu, Hiroshi;
Kudo, Satoshi;
(2011)
How Well Does Knowledge Travel? The Transition from Energy to Commercial Application of Laser Diode Fabrication Technology
(/isis/citation/CBB001211695/)
Book
B. Zorina Khan;
(2020)
Inventing ideas : patents, prizes, and the knowledge economy
(/isis/citation/CBB655098948/)
Book
Con Díaz Gerardo;
(2019)
Software Rights: How Patent Law Transformed Software Development in America
(/isis/citation/CBB992270814/)
Chapter
Samuelson, Pamela;
(2011)
The Strange Odyssey of Software Interfaces as Intellectual Property
(/isis/citation/CBB001221563/)
Chapter
Whitley, Richard;
(2010)
The Impact of Governance Changes on Authority and Innovation in Public Science Systems
(/isis/citation/CBB001420855/)
Be the first to comment!