Contrasting Approaches to a Biological Problem: Paul Boyer, Peter Mitchell and the Mechanism of the ATP Synthase, 1961--1985 (2013)
Attempts to solve the puzzling problem of oxidative phosphorylation led to four very different hypotheses each of which suggested a different view of the ATP synthase, the phosphorylating enzyme. During the 1960s and 1970s evidence began to accumulate which rendered Peter Mitchell's chemiosmotic hypothesis, the novel part of which was the proton translocating ATP synthase (ATPase), a plausible explanation. The conformational hypothesis of Paul Boyer implied an enzyme where ATP synthesis was driven by the energy of conformational changes in the respiratory proteins. This was finally abandoned as an explanation of the overall process. Nevertheless the conformational understanding of the enzyme became an acceptable proposal during the early 1970s and eventually led Boyer to a view of the enzyme that incorporated both hypotheses. The correspondence between Mitchell and Boyer, both Nobel laureates, exposes their different approaches to both this enzyme and to the hypotheses of oxidative phosphorylation and illuminates a key step in the development of bioenergetics. In particular Boyer was suspicious of proton gradients, because he could not envisage a chemical mechanism for the synthesis of ATP, while Mitchell distrusted conformational arguments because he believed the proton must act vectorially at the active site of the enzyme. This resulted in two different views of the mechanisms operating in this enzyme. Ultimately while Boyer was able to marry the two approaches, Mitchell retained his insistence on the role of the proton at the active site and was thus unable to give significance to Boyer's conformational ideas. The underlying issues in this debate are discussed particularly with reference to the differing styles of Boyer and Mitchell and the influence of molecular biology, especially the development of protein technology.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Weber, Bruce H.;
Prebble, John N.;
(2006)
An Issue of Originality and Priority: The Correspondence and Theories of Oxidative Phosphorylation of Peter Mitchell and Robert J.P. Williams, 1961--1980
(/isis/citation/CBB000670095/)
Article
Morange, Michel;
(2008)
Fifty Years of Central Dogma
(/isis/citation/CBB001034015/)
Book
Witkowski, Jan;
(2005)
The Inside Story: DNA to RNA to Protein
(/isis/citation/CBB000610125/)
Article
Yi, Doogab;
(2009)
The Scientific Commons in the Marketplace: The Industrialization of Biomedical Materials at the New England Enzyme Center, 1963--1980
(/isis/citation/CBB000931983/)
Book
John N. Prebble;
(2019)
Searching for a Mechanism: A History of Cell Bioenergetics
(/isis/citation/CBB125294968/)
Article
Loison, Laurent;
(2013)
Monod before Monod: Enzymatic Adaptation, Lwoff, and the Legacy of General Biology
(/isis/citation/CBB001320175/)
Article
Kim, Eun-Sung;
(2008)
Directed Evolution: A Historical Exploration into an Evolutionary Experimental System of Nanobiotechnology, 1965--2006
(/isis/citation/CBB000932240/)
Article
Santesmases, María Jesús;
(2002)
Enzymology at the Core: Primers and Templates in Severo Ochoa's Transition from Biochemistry to Molecular Biology
(/isis/citation/CBB000501151/)
Article
Grote, Mathias;
(2010)
Surfaces of Action: Cells and Membranes in Electrochemistry and the Life Sciences
(/isis/citation/CBB001023958/)
Book
Xiong, Weimin;
Wang, Kedi;
(2005)
He cheng yi ge dan bai zhi: jie jing niu yi dao su de ren gong quan he cheng
(/isis/citation/CBB000775230/)
Article
Gaudillière, Jean-Paul;
(2002)
Paris--New York Roundtrip: Transatlantic Crossings and the Reconstruction of the Biological Sciences in Post-War France
(/isis/citation/CBB000770637/)
Book
Mathias Grote;
(2019)
Membranes to Molecular Machines: Active Matter and the Remaking of Life
(/isis/citation/CBB578630199/)
Book
Watson, James D.;
(2002)
Genes, Girls, and Gamow: After the Double Helix
(/isis/citation/CBB000201963/)
Article
Karl S. Matlin;
(2016)
The Heuristic of Form: Mitochondrial Morphology and the Explanation of Oxidative Phosphorylation
(/isis/citation/CBB047658626/)
Chapter
Rheinberger, Hans-Jörg;
(2010)
The Art of Exploring the Unknown: Views on Contemporary Research in the Life Sciences
(/isis/citation/CBB001023236/)
Article
Šustar, Predrag;
(2007)
Crick's Notion of Genetic Information and the “Central Dogma” of Molecular Biology
(/isis/citation/CBB000831432/)
Article
Brauckmann, Sabine;
(2006)
A Network of Tissue Cultures and Cells: The American Society of Cell Biology
(/isis/citation/CBB000771794/)
Article
Helvoort, Ton van;
(2002)
Institutionalizing Biochemistry: The Enzyme Institute at the University of Wisconsin
(/isis/citation/CBB000301178/)
Article
Allchin, Douglas;
(2002)
To Err and Win a Nobel Prize: Paul Boyer, ATP Synthase and the Emergence of Bioenergetics
(/isis/citation/CBB000200362/)
Article
Santesmases, María Jesús;
(2000)
From Intestine Transport to Enzymatic Regulation: The Works of the Spanish Biochemist Alberto Sols (1917--1989)
(/isis/citation/CBB000770656/)
Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C: Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences
History and Philosophy of the Life Sciences
Archives Internationales d'Histoire des Sciences
British Journal for the Philosophy of Science
History and Technology
Be the first to comment!