This paper examines the origin, range and meaning of the Principle of Action and Reaction in Kant's mechanics. On the received view, it is a version of Newton's Third Law. I argue that Kant meant his principle as foundation for a Leibnizian mechanics. To find a `Newtonian' law of action and reaction, we must look to Kant's `dynamics,' or theory of matter. I begin, in part I, by noting marked differences between Newton's and Kant's laws of action and reaction. I argue that these are explainable by Kant's allegiance to a Leibnizian mechanics. I show (in part II) that Leibniz too had a model of action and reaction, at odds with Newton's. Then I reconstruct how Jakob Hermann and Christian Wolff received Leibniz's model. I present (in Part III) Kant's early law of action and reaction for mechanics. I show that he devised it so as to solve extant problems in the Hermann-Wolff account. I reconstruct Kant's views on `mechanical' action and reaction in the 1780s, and highlight strong continuities with his earlier, pre-Critical stance. I use these continuities, and Kant's earlier engagement with post-Leibnizians, to explain the un-Newtonian features of his law of action and reaction.
...MoreArticle Massimi, Michela (2013) Philosophy of Natural Science from Newton to Kant. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science (p. 393).
Similar Citations
Book
Janiak, Andrew;
Schliesser, Erick;
(2012)
Interpreting Newton: Critical Essays
(/isis/citation/CBB001500334/)
Book
Arianrhod, Robyn;
(2012)
Seduced by Logic: Émilie Du Châtelet, Mary Somerville, and the Newtonian Revolution
(/isis/citation/CBB001421137/)
Article
DiSalle, Robert;
(2013)
The Transcendental Method from Newton to Kant
(/isis/citation/CBB001320267/)
Article
Massimi, Michela;
(2011)
Kant's Dynamical Theory of Matter in 1755, and Its Debt to Speculative Newtonian Experimentalism
(/isis/citation/CBB001230565/)
Article
Hartmut Hecht;
(2016)
Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz and the Origin of the Principle of Least Action – a Never Ending Story
(/isis/citation/CBB198666566/)
Article
Stephen Howard;
(2017)
Why Did Leibniz Fail to Complete His Dynamics?
(/isis/citation/CBB448929987/)
Article
Daniel Garber;
(2019)
La dynamique de Leibniz est-elle compatible avec sa monadologie ?
(/isis/citation/CBB392397811/)
Article
Hoquet, Thierry;
(2014)
Laws of Variation: Darwin's Failed Newtonian Program?
(/isis/citation/CBB001500028/)
Article
Dunlop, Katherine;
(2013)
Mathematical Method and Newtonian Science in the Philosophy of Christian Wolff
(/isis/citation/CBB001320268/)
Article
Korolev, Alexandre;
(2007)
Indeterminism, Asymptotic Reasoning, and Time Irreversibility in Classical Physics
(/isis/citation/CBB001230100/)
Article
Massimi, Michela;
Bianchi, Silvia De;
(2013)
Cartesian Echoes in Kant's Philosophy of Nature
(/isis/citation/CBB001320269/)
Thesis
Gerald Charles Lawrence;
(1968)
The Assimilation of Newtonian Mechanics, 1687-1736
(/isis/citation/CBB617132624/)
Article
Shank, J. B.;
(2004)
“There Was No Such Thing as the “Newtonian Revolution” and the French Initiated It”: Eighteenth-century Mechanics in France before Maupertuis
(/isis/citation/CBB000550336/)
Book
J. B. Shank;
(2018)
Before Voltaire: The French Origins of “Newtonian” Mechanics, 1680-1715
(/isis/citation/CBB213401894/)
Book
Pulte, Helmut;
(2005)
Axiomatik und Empirie: Eine wissenschaftstheoriegeschichtliche Untersuchung zur Mathematischen Naturphilosophie von Newton bis Neumann
(/isis/citation/CBB000740068/)
Article
Oliver, Simon;
(2001)
Motion According to Aquinas and Newton
(/isis/citation/CBB000410604/)
Article
Hoskin, Michael;
(2008)
Gravity and Light in the Newtonian Universe of Stars
(/isis/citation/CBB000930128/)
Book
Joly, Bernard;
(2011)
Descartes et la chimie
(/isis/citation/CBB001320157/)
Chapter
Marius Stan;
Anna Marie Roos;
Gideon Manning;
(2023)
Newtonianism and the Physics of Du Châtelet’s Institutions de Physique
(/isis/citation/CBB246406765/)
Article
Marko Uršič;
(2015)
Boscovich’s Distinction between the Potential and the Actual Space from the Standpoint of Modern Search for the Union of Mind and Nature
(/isis/citation/CBB056648170/)
Be the first to comment!