The Rules of the Game: Forensic Medicine and the Language of Science in the Structuring of Modern Ritual Murder Trials (2012)
When ritual murder trials reappeared in central Europe in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, they could not be articulated in pre-Reformation language and symbols. Prosecutors, magistrates, trial judges, and police investigators shared an implicit understanding that a new universe of knowledge was in place in which academic experts and practitioners of science defined the boundaries---linguistic and conceptual---of plausible argument and were to be accorded deference. This does not mean that popular beliefs and understandings of Jewish ritual murder suddenly ceased to be disseminated or no longer influenced courtroom proceedings, or that zealous investigators and prosecutors did not pursue their cases armed with a priori assumptions about likely perpetrators and their motives. But cultural material, psychological predispositions, and even narrative accounts built upon eyewitness testimony could never suffice to move either the state to indict or a jury, or a panel of judges, to convict. Whatever nonrational thinking or prejudices may have accompanied it, the modern ritual murder trial was structured by powerful, if implicit, rules of expression and authority: it could only be articulated through the epistemological categories and idioms of a culture that understood itself to be both rational and scientific. What commands our attention, then, in the Tiszaeszlár, Xanten, and other modern ritual murder trials are the processes whereby ritual murder discourse bent---as it were---to the discipline of modernity, as exemplified by the structures and rules of legal procedure, parliamentary politics, mass-circulation journalism, criminology, medicine, and forensic science.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Book
Alison Adam;
(2016)
A History of Forensic Science: British Beginnings in the Twentieth Century
(/isis/citation/CBB610315011/)
Article
Mülberger, Annette;
(2009)
Teaching Psychology to Jurists: Initiatives and Reactions Prior to World War I
(/isis/citation/CBB000931968/)
Article
Burney, Ian;
(2013)
Our Environment in Miniature: Dust and the Early Twentieth-Century Forensic Imagination
(/isis/citation/CBB001320021/)
Book
Saumitra Basu;
(2021)
The History of Forensic Science in India
(/isis/citation/CBB589250648/)
Article
Karallus, Christine;
(2005)
Zwischen Kriminalistik und Justiz. Zur Konjunktur der Fotografie als Evindenzstrategie
(/isis/citation/CBB000670819/)
Article
Francesco Ventura;
Rosagemma Ciliberti;
(2019)
Mummified Remains in the Field of Forensics. The Comparison of a 19th Century Case Report with Current Cases
(/isis/citation/CBB926134651/)
Book
Starr, Douglas P.;
(2010)
The Killer of Little Shepherds: A True Crime Story and the Birth of Forensic Science
(/isis/citation/CBB001033742/)
Book
Essig, Mark Regan;
(2003)
Edison and the Electric Chair: A Story of Light and Death
(/isis/citation/CBB000450004/)
Article
Jermyn, Deborah;
(2013)
Labs and Slabs: Television Crime Drama and the Quest for Forensic Realism
(/isis/citation/CBB001213342/)
Article
Aronson, Jay D.;
(2005)
DNA Fingerprinting on Trial: The Dramatic Early History of a New Forensic Technique
(/isis/citation/CBB000630821/)
Article
Prainsack, Barbara;
Kitzberger, Martin;
(2009)
DNA Behind Bars: Other Ways of Knowing Forensic DNA Technologies
(/isis/citation/CBB000953532/)
Book
Sara M. Butler;
(2015)
Forensic Medicine and Death Investigation in Medieval England
(/isis/citation/CBB292678695/)
Article
M'charek, Amade;
Hagendijk, Rob;
Vries, Wiebe de;
(2013)
Equal before the Law: On the Machinery of Sameness in Forensic DNA Practice
(/isis/citation/CBB001320664/)
Chapter
Diego Carnevale;
(2020)
Visum et Repertum: Medical Doctrine and Criminal Procedures in France and Naples (17th–18th Centuries)
(/isis/citation/CBB884894838/)
Article
Mazevet, Michel;
Stagnara, Denise;
Fischer, Louis-Paul;
(2007)
Le Dr. Edmond Locard (1877--1966), le Sherlock Holmes lyonnais
(/isis/citation/CBB000931843/)
Article
Rodriguez, Julia;
(2004)
South Atlantic Crossings: Fingerprints, Science, and the State in Turn-of-the-Century Argentina
(/isis/citation/CBB000411169/)
Book
Becker, Peter;
Wetzell, Richard F.;
(2006)
Criminals and Their Scientists: The History of Criminology in International Perspective
(/isis/citation/CBB000772059/)
Article
Cole, S. A.;
(2000)
From the sexual psychopath statute to “Megan's Law”: Psychiatric knowledge in the diagnosis, treatment, and adjudication of sex criminals in New Jersey, 1949-1999
(/isis/citation/CBB000111940/)
Thesis
Jentzen, Jeffrey M.;
(2007)
Death Investigation in America: Coroners, Medical Examiners, and the Pursuitof Medical Certainty
(/isis/citation/CBB001560986/)
Article
Nicholas Duvall;
(2017)
‘If experts differ, what are we to do in the matter?’ The Medico-legal Investigation of Gunshot Wounds in a 1927 Scottish Murder Trial
(/isis/citation/CBB537944644/)
Be the first to comment!