Chomsky's principle of epistemological tolerance says that in theoretical linguistics contradictions between the data and the hypotheses may be temporarily tolerated in order to protect the explanatory power of the theory. The paper raises the following problem: What kinds of contradictions may be tolerated between the data and the hypotheses in theoretical linguistics? First a model of paraconsistent logic is introduced which differentiates between week and strong contradiction. As a second step, a case study is carried out which exemplifies that the principle of epistemological tolerance may be interpreted as the tolerance of week contradiction. The third step of the argumentation focuses on another case study which exemplifies that the principle of epistemological tolerance must not be interpreted as the tolerance of strong contradiction. The reason for the latter insight is the unreliability and the uncertainty of introspective data. From this finding the author draws the conclusion that it is the integration of different data types that may lead to the improvement of current theoretical linguistics and that the integration of different data types requires a novel methodology which, for the time being, is not available.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Collins, John;
(2007)
Meta-Scientific Eliminativism: A Reconsideration of Chomsky's Review of Skinner's Verbal Behavior
(/isis/citation/CBB000831447/)
Article
Gingras, Yves;
Guay, Alexandre;
(2011)
The Uses of Analogies in Seventeenth- and Eighteenth-Century Science
(/isis/citation/CBB001034590/)
Article
Gregory Radick;
(2016)
The Unmaking of a Modern Synthesis: Noam Chomsky, Charles Hockett, and the Politics of Behaviorism, 1955–1965
(/isis/citation/CBB134415153/)
Chapter
Lenci, Alessandro;
Sandu, Gabriel;
(2009)
Logic and Linguistics in the Twentieth Century
(/isis/citation/CBB001210357/)
Article
Rheinberger, Hans-Jörg;
(2013)
My Road to History of Science
(/isis/citation/CBB001420391/)
Thesis
Henry M. Cowles;
(2015)
A Method Only: The Evolving Meaning of Science in the United States, 1830–1910
(/isis/citation/CBB906014347/)
Book
Noam Chomsky;
Andrea Moro;
(2022)
The Secrets of Words
(/isis/citation/CBB085410471/)
Book
Giosuè Baggio;
(2022)
Neurolinguistics
(/isis/citation/CBB647051163/)
Book
Kibbee, Douglas A.;
(2010)
Chomskyan (R)evolutions
(/isis/citation/CBB001211554/)
Book
Monika Wegmann;
(2016)
Language in Space: The Cartographic Representation of Dialects
(/isis/citation/CBB780577388/)
Book
Chris Knight;
(2018)
Decoding Chomsky: Science and Revolutionary Politics
(/isis/citation/CBB679627884/)
Article
Emmott, James;
(2011)
Parameters of Vibration, Technologies of Capture, and the Layering of Voices and Faces in the Nineteenth Century
(/isis/citation/CBB001035035/)
Article
Strasser, Bruno J.;
(2012)
Collecting Nature: Practices, Styles, and Narratives
(/isis/citation/CBB001252948/)
Book
Karim Bschir;
Jamie Shaw;
(2021)
Interpreting Feyerabend: Critical Essays
(/isis/citation/CBB049878067/)
Chapter
Francesco Aqueci;
(2000)
Il fondamento linguistico della scienza in Vailati
(/isis/citation/CBB223517193/)
Article
Viola, Enrico;
(2013)
The Specificity of Logical Empiricism in the Twentieth-Century History of Scientific Philosophy
(/isis/citation/CBB001320794/)
Article
Atkins, Richard Kenneth;
(2006)
Restructuring the Sciences: Peirce's Categories and His Classifications of the Sciences
(/isis/citation/CBB001023423/)
Chapter
Heck, Richard;
(2010)
Frege and Semantics
(/isis/citation/CBB001211655/)
Article
Lähteenmäki, Mika;
(2012)
Contextualising Baxtin's Linguistic Ideas: The Case of Metalinguistics
(/isis/citation/CBB001211609/)
Article
Velleman, Barry L.;
(2008)
The “Scientific Linguist” Goes to War: The United States A.S.T. Program in Foreign Languages
(/isis/citation/CBB001211635/)
Be the first to comment!