Mrs. Killer and Dr. Crook: Birth Attendants and Birth Outcomes in Early Twentieth-Century Derbyshire (2012)
After the passing of the 1902 Midwives Act, a growing proportion of women were delivered by trained and supervised midwives. Standards of midwifery should therefore have improved over the first three decades of the twentieth century, yet nationally this was not reflected in the main outcome measures (stillbirths, early neonatal mortality and maternal death). This paper shows that there was a difference in the risks associated with delivery by the different attendants, with qualified midwives having the best outcome, then bona-fide (untrained) midwives and lastly doctors, even when account is taken of the fact that doctors were called in cases of medical need and may have been booked where a problematic delivery was expected. The paper argues that the lack of improvement in outcome measures could be consistent with improving standards of care among both trained and bona-fide midwives, because increased attention to the rules stipulating when midwives called for medical help meant that a doctor was called into an increasing number of deliveries (including less complicated ones), raising the chance of unnecessary and dangerous interventions.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Williams, Samantha;
(2011)
The Experience of Pregnancy and Childbirth for Unmarried Mothers in London, 1760--1866
Article
Croxson, Bronwyn;
(2001)
The Foundation and Evolution of the Middlesex Hospital's Lying-In Service, 1745--86
Thesis
Nichols, Marcia D.;
(2010)
The Man-Midwife's Tale: Re-Reading Male-Authored Midwifery Guides in Britain and America, 1750--1820
Article
Dale, Pamela;
Fisher, Kate;
(2009)
Implementing the 1902 Midwives Act: Assessing Problems, Developing Services and Creating a New Role for a Variety of Female Practitioners
Article
Howse, Carrie;
(2006)
From Lady Bountiful to Lady Administrator: Women and the Administration of Rural District Nursing in England, 1880--1925
Thesis
Phillips, Tina;
(2006)
Building the Nation through Women's Health: Modern Midwifery in Early Twentieth-Century China
Article
Homei, Aya;
(2006)
Birth Attendants in Meiji Japan: The Rise of a Medical Birth Model and the New Division of Labour
Article
Woods, Robert;
(2007)
Medical and Demographic History: Inseparable?
Article
Schlumbohm, Jürgen;
(2007)
The Practice of Practical Education: Male Students and Female Apprentices in the Lying-In Hospital of Göttingen University, 1792--1815
Article
Schlumbohm, Jürgen;
(2001)
“The Pregnant Women Are Here for the Sake of the Teaching Institution”: The Lying-In Hospital of Göttingen University, 1751 to c. 1830
Article
Barreto, Maria Renilda Nery;
(2008)
Assistência ao nascimento na Bahia oitocentista
Article
Lallouette, Anne-Laure;
(2009)
Regards des médecins médiévaux sur la naissance
Article
Gelis, Jacques;
(2009)
Louise Bourgeois (1563--1636): Une sage-femme entre deux mondes
Chapter
Martorelli Vico, Romana;
(2011)
Madri, levatrici, balie e padri: Michele Savonarola, l'embriologia e la cura dei piccoli
Book
Schlumbohm, Jürgen;
(2012)
Lebendige Phantome: ein Entbindungshospital und seine Patientinnen 1751--1830
Article
Cormack, Margaret;
(2012)
Introduction: Approaches to Childbirth in the Middle Ages
Book
Banks, Amanda Carson;
(1999)
Birth chairs, midwives, and medicine
Chapter
Keller, Hildegard Elisabeth;
Steinke, Hubert;
(2008)
Jakob Ruf's Trostbüchlein and De Conceptu (Zurich 1554): A Textbook for Midwives and Physicians
Article
Tunc, Tanfer Emin;
(2010)
The Mistress, the Midwife, and the Medical Doctor: Pregnancy and Childbirth on the Plantations of the Antebellum American South, 1800--1860
Chapter
Keller, Eve;
(2003)
The Subject of Touch: Medical Authority in Early Modern Midwifery
Be the first to comment!