Le penchant biologique de la sociologie comtienne: La question de l'égalité des sexes (2012)
The biological underpinnings of Comte's sociology : The question of sexual equality To those who have been puzzled by the globally positive assessment Auguste Comte made of phrenology, historians and philosophers of science have responded by offering convincing epistemological and methodological arguments, which enable one to suggest a rationale for his interest in what is nowadays generally considered a hopelessly pseudo-scientific endeavor. Yet, there exist other motivations, political or -- as Comte himself would put it -- sociological in nature, which seem to explain this interest but which have not so far received the same share of attention. Physiological phrenology indeed provides Comte's system with an original theory of human nature on the basis of which the organization or reorganization of Western societies is to be conceived. But this crucial role ascribed to phrenology is just an illustration of an even broader specificity of the Comtean system, namely the special relation that links biology and sociology. Now, in order to grasp the very difficulty inherent in this special relation in Comte, it is enlightening to consider the manner in which it is elaborated in the context of the issue of sexual equality. What we would like to show here, drawing more specifically on the correspondence between Auguste Comte and John Stuart Mill when it is read in conjunction with the Cours de philosophie positive, is the way biology, and more particularly phrenology, suffuses Comte's sociological argument in favor of the subjection of women and the potential consequences of this biological contamination .
...MoreSimilar Citations
Book
Guillin, Vincent;
(2009)
Auguste Comte and John Stuart Mill on Sexual Equality: Historical, Methodological and Philosophical Issues
(/isis/citation/CBB000952137/)
Article
Kilborne, Benjamin;
(1992)
Positivism and its vicissitudes: The role of faith in the social sciences
(/isis/citation/CBB000057656/)
Article
Tresch, John;
(2010)
The Order of the Prophets: Series in Early French Social Science and Socialism
(/isis/citation/CBB001023530/)
Thesis
Sullivan, Charles R.;
(1992)
The education of Auguste Comte: Social science, political economy, and secular religion in early 19th-century France
(/isis/citation/CBB001564954/)
Article
Reedy, W. Jay;
(1994)
The historical imaginary of social science in post-Revolutionary France: Bonald, Saint-Simon, Comte
(/isis/citation/CBB000056541/)
Article
Erica Lilleleht;
(2015)
“Assuming the Privilege” of Bridging Divides: Abigail Fowler-Chumos, Practical Phrenology, and America’s Gilded Age.
(/isis/citation/CBB355028340/)
Book
Staum, Martin S.;
(2011)
Nature and Nurture in French Social Sciences, 1859--1914 and Beyond
(/isis/citation/CBB001251424/)
Article
Brown, Robert;
(1997)
Artificial experiments on society: Comte, G.C. Lewis and Mill
(/isis/citation/CBB000072597/)
Article
Wilson, Fred;
(1991)
Mill and Comte on the method of introspection
(/isis/citation/CBB000035367/)
Article
Rouch, Hélène;
(2006)
Die Geschlechterdifferenz bei Adrienne Sahuqué und Simone de Beauvoir. Ihre Lektüre biologischer und medizinischer Diskurse
(/isis/citation/CBB001022229/)
Article
Scharff, Robert C.;
(1989)
Positivism, philosophy of science, and self-understanding in Comte and Mill
(/isis/citation/CBB000044165/)
Article
Corr, John;
(2014)
The Enlightenment Surfaces in Nineteenth-Century Mexico: Scientific Thinking Attempts to Deliver Order and Progress
(/isis/citation/CBB001420241/)
Article
Robert, Olivier;
(2002)
La tentation comtienne de John Stuart Mill: une “disciple indiscipliné”
(/isis/citation/CBB000751025/)
Article
Scharff, Robert C.;
(1989)
Mill's misreading of Comte on “interior observation”
(/isis/citation/CBB000042923/)
Article
Thomas, Marion;
(2014)
Are Women Naturally Devoted Mothers? Fabre, Perrier, and Giard on Maternal Instinct in France under the Third Republic
(/isis/citation/CBB001420019/)
Article
van Wyhe, John;
(2004)
Was Phrenology a Reform Science? Towards a New Generalization for Phrenology
(/isis/citation/CBB000774059/)
Article
Cornel, Tabea;
(2014)
Matters of Sex and Gender in F. J. Gall's Organology: A Primary Approach
(/isis/citation/CBB001551835/)
Article
Carstens, Lisa;
(2010)
Unbecoming Women: Sex Reversal in the Scientific Discourse on Female Deviance in Britain, 1880--1920
(/isis/citation/CBB001231392/)
Book
Sengoopta, Chandak;
(2000)
Otto Weininger: Sex, Science, and Self in Imperial Vienna
(/isis/citation/CBB000110686/)
Thesis
Stein, Melissa Norelle;
(2008)
Embodying Race: Gender, Sex, and the Sciences of Difference, 1830--1934
(/isis/citation/CBB001561139/)
Be the first to comment!