Falk, Raphael (Author)
Lazcano, Antonio (Author)
History and Philosophy of the Life Sciences
Volume: 34, no. 3
Issue: 3
Pages: 373-390
The debate between A.I. Oparin's heterotrophic proposal of the origin of life and H.J. Muller's suggestion that what may be considered a posteriori the beginning of life, was an autocatalytic, replicative gene, is analyzed. Although both recognized that what was needed was an interacting system contiguous in space and time, it is now rarely mentioned that this scientific confrontation went on for several decades against the background of intense ideological issues, political tensions, and scientific developments that include the rise and demise of Lysenkoism, on the one hand, and, on the other, the establishment of neoDarwinism and the birth of molecular biology. Whereas for Oparin life was the outcome of the step-wise slow process of precellular evolution in which membrane-bounded polymolecular systems played a key role, Muller argued that life started with the appearance of the first nucleic-acid (DNA) molecule in the primitive oceans. Oparin and Muller came from different scientific backgrounds and almost opposite intellectual traditions, so their common interest in the origin of life did nothing to assuage their opposing views, which as argued soon became part of the debates that took place within the framework of intense ideological confrontations.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Nenad Raos;
(2017)
Carbide Chemistry and Oparin's Theory on the Origin of Life
Article
Aragón de la Cruz, Francisco;
(2003)
El origen de la vida en la tierra
Article
Etkind, Alexander;
(2008)
Beyond Eugenics: The Forgotten Scandal of Hybridizing Humans and Apes
Article
Wolfe, Audra J.;
(2010)
What Does It Mean to Go Public? The American Response to Lysenkoism, Reconsidered
Article
Ivano Mocavini;
(2021)
Oparin's legacy: The methodological breakthrough in the research of life's origin
Article
Fry, Iris;
(2006)
The Origins of Research into the Origins of Life
Article
Nenad Raos;
(2019)
Oparin's theory of biogenesis: Biocolloidal or biomolecular?
Book
Raynaud, Dominique;
(2015)
Scientific Controversies: A Socio-Historical Perspective on the Advancement of Science
Book
Michael Marshall;
(2020)
The Genesis Quest: The Geniuses and Eccentrics on a Journey to Uncover the Origin of Life on Earth
Book
Bastian, Henry Charlton;
Strick, James;
(2001)
Evolution and the Spontaneous Generation Debate. Vol 1-6
Article
Hirai, Hiro;
(2007)
Interprétation chymique de la création et origine corpusculaire de la vie chez Athanasius Kircher
Thesis
Green, Lisa Anne;
(2012)
Science for Survival: The Modern Synthesis of Evolution and the Biological Sciences Curriculum Study
Book
Hecht, Gabrielle;
(2011)
Entangled Geographies: Empire and Technopolitics in the Global Cold War
Article
Martín Orensanz;
(2019)
Internalism, Externalism and Life-Cyclism in the History of Helminthology
Book
Strick, James;
(2000)
Sparks of Life: Darwinism and the Victorian Debates over Spontaneous Generation
Chapter
Fan, Fa-ti;
(2014)
The Controversy over Spontaneous Generation in Republican China: Science, Authority, and the Public
Article
Nils Roll-Hansen;
(2018)
Revisiting the Pouchet–Pasteur Controversy Over Spontaneous Generation: Understanding Experimental Method
Article
Deichmann, Ute;
(2012)
Origin of Life: The Role of Experiments, Basic Beliefs, and Social Authorities in the Controversies about the Spontaneous Generation of Life and the Subsequent Debates about Synthesizing Life in the Laboratory
Article
Yao, Yu;
(2011)
Scientific Disputes Surrounding Hevea Brailiensis Cultivation in the Early People's Republic of China
Thesis
Matthew Schantz;
(2023)
Evolution and Fantasy in the Stalinist Scientific Imagination
Be the first to comment!