Article ID: CBB001250835

Predicting the Past: Ancient Eclipses and Airy, Newcomb, and Huxley on the Authority of Science (2012)


Greek historical accounts of ancient eclipses were an important, if peculiar, focus of scientific attention in the nineteenth century. Victorian-era astronomers tried to correct the classical histories using scientific methods, then used those histories as data with which to calibrate their lunar theories, then rejected the histories as having any relevance at all. The specific dating of these eclipses---apparently a simple exercise in celestial mechanics---became bound up with tensions between scientific and humanistic approaches to the past as well as with wider social debates over the power and authority of science in general. The major figures discussed here, including G. B. Airy, Simon Newcomb, and T. H. Huxley, argued that the critical question was whether science could speak authoritatively about the past. To them, the ability of science to talk about the past indicated its power to talk about the future; it was also the fulcrum of fierce boundary disputes among science, history, and religion.

Citation URI

Similar Citations

Article Cliver, Edward W.; Keer, Norman C.; (2012)
Richard Christopher Carrington: Briefly Among the Great Scientists of His Time (/isis/citation/CBB001451826/)

Chapter Elwick, James; (2014)
Economies of Scales: Evolutionary Naturalists and the Victorian Examination System (/isis/citation/CBB001422049/)

Book Carter, Bill; Carter, Merri Sue; (2006)
Simon Newcomb: America's Unofficial Astronomer Royal (/isis/citation/CBB000641818/)

Book White, Paul; (2002)
Thomas Huxley: Making the “Man of Science” (/isis/citation/CBB000201584/)

Article Kollerstrom, Nicholas; (2006)
An Hiatus in History: The British Claim for Neptune's Co-prediction, 1845--1846: Part 2 (/isis/citation/CBB000671289/)

Book Ruth Barton; (2018)
The X Club: Power and Authority in Victorian Science (/isis/citation/CBB960742427/)

Article Lightman, Bernard; (2011)
Periodicals and Controversy (/isis/citation/CBB001220691/)

Book Chauvin, Michael; (2004)
Hōkūloa: The British 1874 Transit of Venus Expedition to Hawai'i (/isis/citation/CBB000501463/)

Book Ratcliff, Jessica; (2008)
The Transit of Venus Enterprise in Victorian Britain (/isis/citation/CBB000773748/)

Thesis Azadeh Achbari; (2017)
Rulers of the Winds: How Academics Came to Dominate the Science of the Weather, 1830-1870 (/isis/citation/CBB183281724/)

Article Sheynin, Oscar; (2002)
Simon Newcomb as a Statistician (/isis/citation/CBB000330346/)

Article Stephen Courtney; (2018)
The Historical Meridian: Antiquity and Scripture in the Public Work of George Biddell Airy (/isis/citation/CBB237401119/)

Article Ishibashi, Yuto; (2014)
In Pursuit of Accurate Timekeeping: Liverpool and Victorian Electrical Horology (/isis/citation/CBB001451566/)

Article Daniel Belteki; (2020)
Trust in Glass: Negotiating the Purchase of the Object Glass for the Airy Transit Circle (/isis/citation/CBB805527244/)

Authors & Contributors
Belteki, Daniel
Ishibashi, Yuto
Barton, William M.
Gillin, Edward J.
Achbari, Azadeh
Keer, Norman C.
Journal for the History of Astronomy
History of Science
Spontaneous Generations
Solar Physics
Science in Context
Perspectives on Science
Liveright Publishing Corporation A Division of W.W. Norton and Company
University of Chicago Press
Pickering & Chatto
Bishop Museum Press
Cambridge University Press
Authority of science
Eclipses; transits; occultations; conjunctions
Science and society
Science and government
Airy, George Biddell
Huxley, Thomas Henry
Newcomb, Simon
Merz, Georg
Tyndall, John
Spencer, Herbert
Time Periods
19th century
20th century, early
17th century
Great Britain
United States
Atlantic Ocean
Hawaii (U.S.)
Royal Observatory Greenwich

Be the first to comment!

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}

Log in or register to comment