IsisCB Explore

Article ID: CBB001220960

A Web of Controversies: Complexity in the Burgess Shale Debate (2011)

Baron, Christian (Author)

Journal of the History of Biology
Volume: 44
Pages: 745--780

Outside Links

WorldCat

Google Scholar

JSTOR

Academia.edu

Evolution Fossils Epistemology Burgess shale (British Columbia) Contingency (philosophy) Paleontology Controversies and disputes 20th century, late 21st century

Using the Burgess Shale controversies as a case-study, this paper argues that controversies within different domains may interact as to create a situation of com- plicated intricacies, where the practicing scientist has to navigate through a context of multiple thought collectives. To some extent each of these collectives has its own dynamic complete with fairly negotiated standards for investigation and explanation, theoretical background assumptions and certain peculiarities of practice. But the intellectual development in one of these collectives may spill over having far reaching consequences for the treatment of apparently independent epistemic problems that are subject of investigation in other thought collectives. For the practicing scientist it is necessary to take this complex web of interactions into account in order to be able to navigate in such a situation. So far most studies of academic science have had a tendency to treat the practicing scientist as members of a single (enclosed) thought collective that stands intellectually isolated from other similar entities unless the discipline was in a state of crisis of paradigmatic proportions. The richness and complexity of Burgess Shale debate shows that this encapsulated kind of analysis is not enough.

...More

Citation URI

https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB001220960/

Citations Indexes

Similar Citations

Book Chambers, Paul; (2002)
Bones of Contention: The Archaeopteryx Scandals (/isis/citation/CBB000502449/)

Article Sepkoski, David; (2014)
Paleontology at the “High Table”? Popularization and Disciplinary Status in Recent Paleontology (/isis/citation/CBB001420096/)

Article Zachary D. Blount; (2016)
A case study in evolutionary contingency (/isis/citation/CBB801728986/)

Article Brysse, Keynyn; (2008)
From Weird Wonders to Stem Lineages: The Second Reclassification of theBurgess Shale Fauna (/isis/citation/CBB000831712/)

Article Smith, Kerri; (2012)
China's Dinosaur Hunter: The Ground Breaker (/isis/citation/CBB001320439/)

Article David Sepkoski; (2016)
“Replaying Life's Tape”: Simulations, metaphors, and historicity in Stephen Jay Gould's view of life (/isis/citation/CBB998505163/)

Article Honenberger, Phillip; (2015)
Grene and Hull on Types and Typological Thinking in Biology (/isis/citation/CBB001422118/)

Article Paige Madison; (2019)
All Things Bleak and Bare Beneath a Brazen Sky: Practice and Place in the Analysis of Australopithecus (/isis/citation/CBB654252561/)

Article Chris Manias; (2017)
Progress in life's history: Linking Darwinism and palaeontology in Britain, 1860–1914 (/isis/citation/CBB426710736/)

Book Sepkoski, David; (2012)
Rereading the Fossil Record: The Growth of Paleobiology as an Evolutionary Discipline (/isis/citation/CBB001210043/)

Article Hans-Jörg Rheinberger; (2020)
Two Books that Marked their Epoch – A Personal Encounter (/isis/citation/CBB766439626/)

Article Marco Tamborini; (2020)
Technoscientific approaches to deep time (/isis/citation/CBB800223742/)

Article Lindsay, Debra; (2005)
Prototaxites Dawson, 1859 or Nematophycus Carruthers, 1872: Geologists v. Botanists in the Formative Period of Paleobotany (/isis/citation/CBB000630867/)

Article Claudine Cohen; (2017)
“How nationality influences Opinion”: Darwinism and palaeontology in France (1859–1914) (/isis/citation/CBB709081900/)

Article Kyla Schuller; (2016)
The Fossil and the Photograph: Red Cloud, Prehistoric Media, and Dispossession in Perpetuity (/isis/citation/CBB663391807/)

Chapter Gwen S. Antell; (2018)
Digitization reveals and remediates challenges to research on dispersed museum collections from Florissant fossil beds, Colorado (/isis/citation/CBB854174352/)

Chapter Bruce S. Lieberman; Julien Kimmig; (2018)
Museums, paleontology, and a biodiversity science–based approach (/isis/citation/CBB045609940/)

Article Donald Prothero; (2009)
Stephen Jay Gould: Did He Bring Paleontology to the “High Table”? (/isis/citation/CBB823532878/)

Thesis Christopher W. Howell; (2021)
Designer Science: A History of Intelligent Design in America (/isis/citation/CBB325390187/)

Book Aczel, Amir D.; (2007)
Jesuit and the Skull: Teilhard de Chardin, Evolution and the Search for Peking Man (/isis/citation/CBB000830479/)

Comments

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}