Existing scholarship on the experiments performed in concentration camps beginning in 1942 on the value of sulfonamides in treatment of wound infections, in which inmates were used as experimental subjects, maintains that not only were the experiments ethically and legally completely reprehensible and unacceptable, but that they were also bad science in the sense that they were investigating questions that had already been resolved by valid medical research. In contrast to this, the paper argues on the basis of contemporary publications that the value of sulfonamides in the treatment of wound infections, including gas gangrene infections, was not yet established, that is, that the questions pursued by the experiments had not been resolved. It also argues that regarding their "design" and methodical principles, the experiments directly followed the rationality of contemporary clinical trials and animal experiments. However, for the step from animal to the human experiment, the experimental "objects" were only in regard to their body, but not to their individuality and subjectivity regarded as "human". In a concluding section, the paper lines out some implications for an adequate historical reconstruction of medical research on humans, in particular the importance of a combined focus on the scientific rationality as well as explicit or implicit value hierarchies. Further, the article points to the potential impact of such a revised image of the sulfonamide experiments for present day debates on the ethics of medical research.
...More
Chapter
Caplan, Arthur L.;
(2007)
The Ethics of Evil: The Challenge and the Lessons of Nazi Medical Experiments
(/isis/citation/CBB000760182/)
Book
Weindling, Paul;
(2004)
Nazi Medicine and the Nuremberg Trials: From Medical War Crimes to Informed Consent
(/isis/citation/CBB000610242/)
Book
Freyhofer, Horst H.;
(2004)
The Nuremberg Medical Trial: The Holocaust and the Origin of the Nuremberg Medical Code
(/isis/citation/CBB000741343/)
Book
Eckart, Wolfgang Uw;
(2006)
Man, Medicine, and the State: The Human Body as an Object of Government Sponsored Medical Research in the 20th Century
(/isis/citation/CBB001033855/)
Book
Bruns, Florian;
(2009)
Medizinethik im Nationalsozialismus: Entwicklungen und Protagonisten in Berlin (1939--1945)
(/isis/citation/CBB001021026/)
Chapter
Schleiermacher, Sabine;
Schagen, Udo;
(2008)
Medizinische Forschung als Pseudowissenschaft. Selbstreinigungsrituale der Medizin nach dem Nürnberger Ärzteprozess
(/isis/citation/CBB001023679/)
Book
Oppitz, Ulrich-Dieter;
Uexküll, Thure von;
(1999)
Medizinverbrechen vor Gericht: das Urteil im Nürnberger Ärzteprozess gegen Karl Brandt und andere sowie aus dem Prozess gegen Generalfeldmarschall Milch
(/isis/citation/CBB000502943/)
Book
Wolters, Christine;
(2011)
Tuberkulose und Menschenversuche im Nationalsozialismus: Das Netzwerk hinter den Tbc-Experimenten im Konzentrationslager Sachsenhausen
(/isis/citation/CBB001202027/)
Book
Schmidt, Ulf;
(2007)
Karl Brandt: The Nazi Doctor, Medicine, and Power in the Third Reich
(/isis/citation/CBB001230892/)
Article
Hedfors, Eva;
(2007)
Medical Ethics in the Wake of the Holocaust: Departing from a Postwar Paper by Ludwik Fleck
(/isis/citation/CBB000830398/)
Article
James Mills;
(2020)
Pandora's box closed: The Royal Air Force Institute of Aviation Medicine and Nazi medical experiments on human beings during World War II
(/isis/citation/CBB421393123/)
Book
Sachse, Carola;
(2003)
Die Verbindung nach Auschwitz: Biowissenschaften und Menschenversuche an Kaiser-Wilhelm-Instituten
(/isis/citation/CBB000471260/)
Article
Jueyeon Lee;
Youngsoo Cho;
(2017)
The Study on the Lives and Health Conditions of Internees in Santo Thomas Camp of Philippines - Based on McAnlis’s The War in Manila (1941-1945)
(/isis/citation/CBB381478379/)
Article
Weindling, Paul;
(2013)
From Scientific Object to Commemorated Victim: The Children of the Spiegelgrund
(/isis/citation/CBB001420755/)
Book
Rubenfeld, Sheldon;
(2010)
Medicine after the Holocaust: From The Master Race to the Human Genome and Beyond
(/isis/citation/CBB001031272/)
Book
Nicosia, Francis R.;
Huener, Jonathan;
(2002)
Medicine and Medical Ethics in Nazi Germany: Origins, Practices, Legacies
(/isis/citation/CBB000201239/)
Article
Heinz Wässle;
(2017)
A Collection of Brain Sections of “Euthanasia” Victims: The Series H of Julius Hallervorden
(/isis/citation/CBB773503936/)
Book
Spitz, Vivien;
(2005)
Doctors from Hell: The Horrific Account of Nazi Experiments on Humans
(/isis/citation/CBB000550040/)
Chapter
Tsuneishi, Kei-ichi;
(2007)
Unit 731 and the Human Skulls Discovered in 1989: Physicians Carrying Out Organized Crimes
(/isis/citation/CBB000760183/)
Book
LaFleur, William R.;
Böhme, Gernot;
Shimazono, Susumu;
(2007)
Dark Medicine: Rationalizing Unethical Medical Research
(/isis/citation/CBB000831301/)
Be the first to comment!