IsisCB Explore

Article ID: CBB001214554

From Formation to Ecosystem: Tansley's Response to Clements' Climax (2014)

van der Valk, Arnold G. (Author)

Journal of the History of Biology
Volume: 47, no. 2
Issue: 2
Pages: 293-321

Outside Links

WorldCat

Google Scholar

JSTOR

Academia.edu

Climate and climatology Environment Biology Biological diversity; biodiversity Ecosystem 20th century, early Tansley, Arthur George Clements, Frederic Edward

Arthur G. Tansley never accepted Frederic E. Clements' view that succession is a developmental process whose final stage, the climax formation, is determined primarily by regional climate and that all other types of vegetation are some kind of successional stage or arrested successional stage. Tansley was convinced that in a given region a variety of environmental factors could produce different kinds of climax formations. At the heart of their dispute was Clements' organicist view of succession, i.e., the formation was a complex organism with an ontogeny and phylogeny. As early as 1905, Tansley offered an alternative to Clements' complex organism, the quasi-organism, but Clements in private and public rejected this compromise. Tansley and other plant ecologists continued to criticize Clements' theories for the next 20 years, but with no impact on Clements. John Phillips, a South African plant ecologist who was a follower of Clements, published a series of papers in 1934 and 1935 defending Clementsian ecology. These papers were triggered by the publication of a letter by another ecologist working in Africa who claimed that there was a strong correlation between soils and various kinds of climax vegetation, which was contrary to what was predicted by Phillips and Clements. In 1935, Tansley published an attack on Phillips and Clements and their developmental theory of succession. In it, he proposed the concept of the ecosystem as a way to get around Clements' monoclimax theory by making the physical environment (e.g., soil chemistry, soil texture, soil moisture) as important a factor as climate, plants and other organisms in determining the composition and characteristics of ecological entities, i.e., ecosystems. Tansley's ecosystem concept quickly replaced Clements' monoclimax theory as a dominant paradigm in ecology.

...More

Citation URI

https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB001214554/

Citations Indexes

Similar Citations

Book Ayres, Peter G.; (2012)
Shaping Ecology: The Life of Arthur Tansley (/isis/citation/CBB001201053/)

Article Masutti, Christophe; (2006)
Frederic Clements, Climatology, and Conservation in the 1930s (/isis/citation/CBB000700670/)

Article Antoine C. Dussault; (2018)
Functional ecology's non-selectionist understanding of function (/isis/citation/CBB371845560/)

Book Keller, David R.; Golley, Frank B.; (2000)
Philosophy of Ecology: From Science to Synthesis (/isis/citation/CBB000101689/)

Book Pearson, Chris; (2012)
Mobilizing Nature: The Environmental History of War and Militarization in Modern France (/isis/citation/CBB001201432/)

Book Ayres, P.G.; (2012)
Shaping Ecology: The Life of Arthur Tansley (/isis/citation/CBB001421420/)

Article Ayelet Shavit; James R. Griesemer; (2018)
Science and Sentiment: Grinnell’s Fact-Based Philosophy of Biodiversity Conservation (/isis/citation/CBB589271103/)

Article Christophe Bonneuil; (2019)
Seeing nature as a ‘universal store of genes’: How biological diversity became ‘genetic resources’, 1890–1940 (/isis/citation/CBB784934864/)

Article Reuss, Martin; Bernhardtb, Emily; Bunna, Stuart E.; Hartc, David D.; Björn Malmqvistd, Timo Muotkae; Naimanf, Robert J.; Pringleg, Catherine; Wilgeni, Brian van; (2006)
Perspective: The Challenge of Ecologically Sustainable Water Management (/isis/citation/CBB001180773/)

Article Palomares, Maria Lourdes D.; Heymans, Johanna J.; Pauly, Daniel; (2007)
Historical Ecology of the Raja Ampat Archipelago, Papua Province, Indonesia (/isis/citation/CBB000831351/)

Book Trevor Pearce; (2020)
Pragmatism’s Evolution: Organism and Environment in American Philosophy (/isis/citation/CBB241104150/)

Book Cristina Baldacci; Shaul Bassi; Lucio De Capitani; Pietro Daniel Omodeo; (2022)
Venice and the Anthropocene: An Ecocritical Guide (/isis/citation/CBB968298285/)

Thesis Josh England; (2021)
Olives in the Mountains: A Case Study of the Roman City of Sagalassos (/isis/citation/CBB215221359/)

Book Carl Death; (2016)
The Green State in Africa (/isis/citation/CBB850595474/)

Article Céline Granjou; Isabelle Arpin; (November 2015)
Epistemic Commitments: Making Relevant Science in Biodiversity Studies (/isis/citation/CBB182986827/)

Article Kohler, Robert E.; (2008)
Plants and Pigeonholes: Classification as a Practice in American Ecology (/isis/citation/CBB000950399/)

Article Eliot, Christopher; (2007)
Method and Metaphysics in Clements's and Gleason's Ecological Explanations (/isis/citation/CBB000770758/)

Article da Silva Nunes, Patricia; Cavassan, Osmar; da Rocha Brando, Fernanda; (2013)
Frederic Edward Clements e o conceito de sucessão ecológica (/isis/citation/CBB001214031/)

Article Bocking, Stephen; (2012)
Science, Salmon, and Sea Lice: Constructing Practice and Place in an Environmental Controversy (/isis/citation/CBB001320034/)

Chapter Kenneth W. Noe; (2015)
Fateful Lightning: The Significance of Weather and Climate to Civil War History (/isis/citation/CBB769919988/)

Comments

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}