IsisCB Explore

Article ID: CBB001213348

A Dark Business, Full of Shadows: Analogy and Theology in William Harvey (2013)

Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C: Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences
Volume: 44, no. 3
Issue: 3
Pages: 419-432

Outside Links

PubMed

WorldCat

Google Scholar

JSTOR

Academia.edu

Theology Natural philosophy Mind and body Metaphors; analogies Reproduction Early modern 17th century Harvey, William

In a short work called De conceptione appended to the end of his Exercitationes de generatione animalium (1651), William Harvey developed a rather strange analogy. To explain how such marvelous productions as living beings were generated from the rather inauspicious ingredients of animal reproduction, Harvey argued that conception in the womb was like conception in the brain. It was mostly rejected at the time; it now seems a ludicrous theory based upon homonymy. However, this analogy offers insight into the structure and function of analogies in early modern natural philosophy. In this essay I hope to not only describe the complex nature of Harvey's analogy, but also offer a novel interpretation of his use of analogical reasoning, substantially revising the account offered by Guido Giglioni (1993). I discuss two points of conceptual change and negotiation in connection with Harvey's analogy, understanding it as both a confrontation between the border of the natural and the supernatural, as well as a moment in the history of psychology. My interpretation touches upon a number of important aspects, including why the analogy was rejected, how Harvey systematically deployed analogies according to his notions of natural philosophical method, how the analogy fits into contemporary discussions of analogies in science, and finally, how the analogy must be seen in the context of changing Renaissance notions of the science of the soul, ultimately confronting the problem of how to understand final causality in Aristotelian science. In connection with the last, I conclude the essay by turning to how Harvey embeds the analogy within a natural theological cosmology.

...More

Description On Harvey's analogy that conception in the womb is like conception in the brain, and its theological aspects.

Citation URI

https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB001213348/

Citations Indexes

Similar Citations

Chapter Fabrizio Baldassarri; (2023)
From the Analogy with Animals to the Anatomy of Plants in Medicine: The Physiology of Living Processes from Harvey to Malpighi (/isis/citation/CBB896255641/)

Book Neumann, Hanns-Peter; (2004)
Natura sagax: Die geistige Natur. Zum Zusammenhang von Naturphilosophie und Mystik in der frühen Neuzeit am Beispiel Johann Arndts (/isis/citation/CBB000640078/)

Article Horst Steinke; (2020)
Mind, Body, and Language in Vico’s Scienza nuova (/isis/citation/CBB704633145/)

Book Lugt, Maaike van der; (2004)
Le ver, le démon et la Vierge: Les théories médiévales de la génération extraordinaire. Une étude sur les rapports entre théologie, philosophie naturelle et médecine (/isis/citation/CBB000501937/)

Article Ekholm, Karin J.; (2008)
Harvey's and Highmore's Accounts of Chick Generation (/isis/citation/CBB000850590/)

Article Ekholm, Karin; (2010)
Fabricius's and Harvey's Representations of Animal Generation (/isis/citation/CBB001020870/)

Thesis Attie, Katherine Bootle; (2007)
The Politics of Metaphor in Seventeenth-Century England (/isis/citation/CBB001560828/)

Book Fabrizio Baldassarri; Andreas Blank; (2021)
Vegetative Powers: The Roots of Life in Ancient, Medieval and Early Modern Natural Philosophy (/isis/citation/CBB355406563/)

Article Naama Cohen-Hanegbi; (2016)
A Moving Soul: Emotions in Late Medieval Medicine (/isis/citation/CBB186537346/)

Chapter Pulkkinen, Jarmo; (2008)
The Role of Metaphors in William Harvey's Thought (/isis/citation/CBB000952612/)

Article Gorham, Geoffrey; (1994)
Mind-body dualism and the Harvey-Descartes controversy (/isis/citation/CBB000040141/)

Thesis Habinek, Lianne; (2009)
“Such Wondrous Science”: Brain and Metaphor in Early Modern English Literature (/isis/citation/CBB001562859/)

Chapter Francesco Fronterotta; (2022)
La metafora eraclitea del fiume e la sua interpretazione in Platone e Aristotele (/isis/citation/CBB047222730/)

Book Massimiliano Lenzi; Olga L. Lizzini; Pina Totaro; Luisa Valente; (2022)
Fonti, flussi, onde. L'acqua tra realtà e metafora nel pensiero antico, medievale e moderno (/isis/citation/CBB040022491/)

Article Thomas Leinkauf; (2020)
The ‘Book of Nature’ as Image of the Complexity and Totality of the Divine Intellect (/isis/citation/CBB462414443/)

Article Natacha Fabbri; (2022)
Le piante tra natura naturans e natura naturata: immagini di armonia vegetale nella prima età moderna (/isis/citation/CBB928108664/)

Article McMahon, C. E.; (1975)
Harvey on the soul: A unique episode in the history of psycyophysiological thought (/isis/citation/CBB000017519/)

Article Benjamin Goldberg; (2015)
William Harvey on Anatomy and Experience (/isis/citation/CBB534950714/)

Article Sarah E. Parker; (2016)
The Reader as Authorial Figure in Scientific Debate (/isis/citation/CBB342643342/)

Article Xiaona Wang; (2019)
By Analogy to the Element of the Stars: The Divine in Jean Fernel's and William Harvey's Theories of Generation (/isis/citation/CBB848009397/)

Comments

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}