The Cholera Stigma and the Challenge of Interdisciplinary Epistemology: From Bengal to Haiti (2012)
For a century and a half cholera has been a stigmatizing disease. That the entire world was susceptible to it seemed merely to accentuate its association with Asia, and particularly with Bengal and its people. The recent epidemic in Haiti suggests that cholera still carries stigma. That stigma is the product of epistemic practices within an interdisciplinary and orientalist cholera science that took shape in the 1860s and 1870s, which have, without renewed scrutiny, prevailed largely uncontested until recent decades. Those practices involved an over-interpretation of the historical epidemiological work of John Macpherson by his colleague N. C. Macnamara. Recent research, recognizing the wide distribution and genetic instability of Vibrio cholerae, offers an alternative context for appreciating Macpherson's insights. This new program of interdisciplinary cholera research seems largely free of stigmatizing representations, but nor does it offer (or seek) a single and simple program of cholera prevention. The cholera case study invites reflection on the little-studied problem of epistemic accountability in interdisciplinary research, alerts us to questions of how disciplines are (and might be) made to cohere in policy-driven inquiries. The chief maxim is toward more explicit inclusion of the concept of multiple working hypotheses.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Book
Sally Shuttleworth;
Melissa Dickson;
Emilie Taylor-Brown;
David Cantor;
(2020)
Progress and pathology: Medicine and culture in the nineteenth century
(/isis/citation/CBB449680297/)
Article
Almeida, Maria Antónia Pires de;
(2012)
The Portuguese cholera morbus Epidemic of 1853--56 as Seen by the Press
(/isis/citation/CBB001220430/)
Article
Almeida, Maria Antónia Pires de;
(2014)
As epidemias nas notícias em Portugal: cólera, peste, tifo, gripe e varíola, 1854--1918
(/isis/citation/CBB001420729/)
Article
Karimkhanzand, Mostafa;
(2013)
Iranian Medicine's Encounter with the Cholera and Plague Epidemics in Qajar Iran in the 19th Century
(/isis/citation/CBB001510311/)
Thesis
Lopez Denis, Adrian;
(2007)
Disease and Society in Colonial Cuba, 1790--1840
(/isis/citation/CBB001561294/)
Article
Nunes, Everardo Duarte;
(2012)
Henry Mayhew: jornalista, investigador social e precursor da pesquisa qualitativa
(/isis/citation/CBB001420604/)
Article
Janakan, Gnananandan;
Ellis, Harold;
(2013)
Dr Thomas Aitchison Latta (c.1796--1833): Pioneer Of Intravenous Fluid Replacement in the Treatment of Cholera
(/isis/citation/CBB001421950/)
Article
Tullo, Ellen;
(2010)
Plague of Icy Breath. Cholera and the Gateshead Community 1831--1832
(/isis/citation/CBB001220542/)
Book
Henze, Charlotte;
(2009)
Disease, Health Care and Government in Late Imperial Russia
(/isis/citation/CBB001252071/)
Chapter
William Johnston;
(2014)
The Shifting Epistemological Foundations of Cholera Control in Japan (1822-1900)
(/isis/citation/CBB382394873/)
Article
Almeida, Maria Antónia Pires de;
(2013)
Epidemics in the News: Health and Hygiene in the Press in Periods of Crisis
(/isis/citation/CBB001320417/)
Article
Antonio Fornaciari;
Valentina Giuffra;
(2021)
The 1854-55 cholera epidemic in Tuscany and the cholera cemetery of the village of Benabbio
(/isis/citation/CBB254338128/)
Book
Hempel, Sandra;
(2007)
The Strange Case of the Broad Street Pump: John Snow and the Mystery of Cholera
(/isis/citation/CBB000741892/)
Article
Rebelo, Fernanda;
(2013)
Entre o Carlo R. e o Orleannais: a saúde pública e a profilaxia marítima no relato de dois casos de navios de imigrantes no porto do Rio de Janeiro, 1893--1907
(/isis/citation/CBB001420664/)
Book
Holland, Michael;
Gill, Geoffrey;
Burrell, Sean;
(2009)
Cholera and Conflict: 19th Century Cholera in Britain and Its Social Consequences
(/isis/citation/CBB000933046/)
Article
Carbonetti, Adrián;
Rodríguez, María Laura;
(2007)
Las epidemias de cólera en Córdoba a través del periodismo: la oferta de productos preservativos y curativos durante la epidemiade 1867--1868
(/isis/citation/CBB000720361/)
Article
Margaret Pelling;
(2020)
'Bosom Vipers': Endemic Versus Epidemic Disease
(/isis/citation/CBB218133605/)
Book
Whooley, Owen;
(2013)
Knowledge in the Time of Cholera: The Struggle over American Medicine in the Nineteenth Century
(/isis/citation/CBB001420158/)
Chapter
Tina Travagliante;
(2021)
Democratismo e indipendentismo: dall'epidemia di colera del 1837 alla rivoluzione del 1848 in Sicilia
(/isis/citation/CBB368945703/)
Article
Rus, Dorin-Ioan;
(2013)
Das Tagebuch und die Briefkarten des Pfarrers Gustav Kinn uber die Choleraepidemie in Sächsisch-Regen im Jahre 1873
(/isis/citation/CBB001421909/)
Be the first to comment!