On the Distinction between Peirce's Abduction and Lipton's Inference to the Best Explanation (2011)
I argue against the tendency in the philosophy of science literature to link abduction to the inference to the best explanation (IBE), and in particular, to claim that Peircean abduction is a conceptual predecessor to IBE. This is not to discount either abduction or IBE. Rather the purpose of this paper is to clarify the relation between Peircean abduction and IBE in accounting for ampliative inference in science. This paper aims at a proper classification---not justification---of types of scientific reasoning. In particular, I claim that Peircean abduction is an in-depth account of the process of generating explanatory hypotheses, while IBE, at least in Peter Lipton's thorough treatment, is a more encompassing account of the processes both of generating and of evaluating scientific hypotheses. There is then a two-fold problem with the claim that abduction is IBE. On the one hand, it conflates abduction and induction, which are two distinct forms of logical inference, with two distinct aims, as shown by Charles S. Peirce; on the other hand it lacks a clear sense of the full scope of IBE as an account of scientific inference.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Book
Forster, Paul;
(2011)
Peirce and the Threat of Nominalism
(/isis/citation/CBB001210617/)
Article
Niiniluoto, Ilkka;
(2011)
Abduction, Tomography, and Other Inverse Problems
(/isis/citation/CBB001024148/)
Article
Snyder, Laura J.;
(1999)
Renovating the Novum Organum: Bacon, Whewell and induction
(/isis/citation/CBB000111667/)
Article
Claudia Cristalli;
Ahti-Veikko Pietarinen;
(2021)
Abstraction and Generalization in the Logic of Science: Cases from Nineteenth-Century Scientific Practice
(/isis/citation/CBB855367059/)
Article
Michael J. Flexer;
(2020)
If p0, Then 1: The Impossibility of Thinking Out Cases
(/isis/citation/CBB601183479/)
Article
Pihlström, Sami;
(2008)
How (Not) to Write the History of Pragmatist Philosophy of Science?
(/isis/citation/CBB000831774/)
Chapter
Hilpinen, Risto;
(2009)
Conditional and Possible Worlds: On C. S. Pierce's Conception of Conditionals and Modalities
(/isis/citation/CBB001210353/)
Article
Francesco Bellucci;
(2015)
Logic, Psychology, and Apperception: Charles S. Peirce and Johann F. Herbart
(/isis/citation/CBB115765207/)
Article
Francesco Bellucci;
(2015)
Neat, Swine, Sheep, and Deer: Mill and Peirce on Natural Kinds
(/isis/citation/CBB590791562/)
Chapter
Haaparanta, Leila;
(2009)
The Relations between Logic and Philosophy, 1874--1931
(/isis/citation/CBB001210347/)
Article
Daude, Olivier;
(2011)
Le pragmaticisme et la question du témoignage
(/isis/citation/CBB001024474/)
Article
Ainsworth, Peter M.;
(2012)
The Third Path to Structural Realism
(/isis/citation/CBB001210957/)
Chapter
Martin, Christopher J.;
(2005)
Aristotle and the Logic of Consequences: The Development of the Theory of Inference in the Early Thirteenth Century
(/isis/citation/CBB000701175/)
Article
Plutynski, Anya;
(2011)
Four Problems of Abduction: A Brief History
(/isis/citation/CBB001230106/)
Chapter
Mohanty, J. N.;
Saha, S. R.;
Chatterjee, Amita;
Sarkar, Tushar Kanti;
Bhattacharyya, Sibajiban;
(2009)
Indian Logic
(/isis/citation/CBB001210359/)
Book
Brady, Geraldine;
(2000)
From Peirce to Skolem: A Neglected Chapter in the History of Logic
(/isis/citation/CBB000102342/)
Article
Weatherson, Brian;
(1999)
Begging the question and Bayesians
(/isis/citation/CBB000110819/)
Chapter
Sundholm, Göran;
(2009)
A Century of Judgment and Inference, 1837--1936: Some Strands in the Development of Logic
(/isis/citation/CBB001210348/)
Book
Moulines, Carles Ulises;
(2008)
Die Entwicklung der modernen Wissenschaftstheorie (1890--2000): Eine historische Einführung
(/isis/citation/CBB001230060/)
Article
Shannon Dea;
(2015)
A House at War Against Itself: Absolute Versus Pluralistic Idealism in Spinoza, Peirce, James and Royce
(/isis/citation/CBB655215457/)
Be the first to comment!