In his classic work The Mind and its Place in Nature published in 1925 at the height of the development of quantum mechanics but several years after the chemists Lewis and Langmuir had already laid the foundations of the modern theory of valence with the introduction of the covalent bond, the analytic philosopher C. D. Broad argued for the emancipation of chemistry from the crass physicalism that led physicists then and later---with support from a rabblement of philosophers who knew as much about chemistry as etymologists---to believe that chemistry reduced to physics. Here Broad's thesis is recast in terms more familiar to chemists. In the hard sell of particle physics, several prominent figures in chemistry---Hoffmann, Primas, and Pauling---have had their views interpreted to imply that they were sympathetic to greedy reductionism when in fact they were not. Indeed, being chemists without physicists as alter egos, they could not but side with Broad's contention that chemistry, as a science that deals primarily in emergent phenomena which are beyond the purview of physicalism, owes no acquiescence to particle physics and its ethereal wares. Historically, among the most widely used expediencies in chemistry and materials science are additivity or mixture rules and their cohort transferability, all of which are devised and used under the mantle of naive reductionism. Here it is argued that while the transfer of functional groups between molecules works empirically to an extent, it is strictly outlawed by the no-cloning theorem of quantum mechanics. Several illustrative examples related to chemistry's irreducibility to physics are presented and discussed. The failure of naive reductionism exhibited by the deep-inelastic scattering of leptons by A > 2 nuclei is traced to the same flawed reasoning that was the original basis of Moffitt's `atoms in molecules' hypothesis, the neglect of context, nuclei in the case of high-energy physics and molecules in the case of chemistry. A non-exhaustive list of other contexts from physics, chemistry, and molecular biology evidencing similar departures from the ideal of additivity or reductionism is provided for the perusal of philosophers. Had the call by the mathematician J. T. Schwartz for developments in mathematical linguistics possessed of a less single, less literal, and less simple-minded nature been met, perhaps it might have persuaded scientists to abandon their regressive fixation with unphysical reductionism and to adapt to new methodologies that engender a more nuanced handling of ubiquitous emergent phenomena as they arise in Nature than is the case today.
...MoreDescription On the history of the idea that chemistry is not reducible to physics.
Article
Earley, Joseph E., Sr.;
(2012)
A Neglected Aspect of the Puzzle of Chemical Structure: How History Helps
(/isis/citation/CBB001210755/)
Article
Causá, Mauro;
Savin, Andreas;
Silvi, Bernard;
(2014)
Atoms and Bonds in Molecules and Chemical Explanations
(/isis/citation/CBB001321116/)
Article
Scerri, Eric R.;
(2012)
What Is an Element? What Is the Periodic Table? And What Does Quantum Mechanics Contribute to the Question?
(/isis/citation/CBB001232598/)
Book
Gavroglu, Kostas;
Simões, Ana;
(2011)
Neither Physics nor Chemistry: A History of Quantum Chemistry
(/isis/citation/CBB001221167/)
Article
Niese, Siegfried;
(2009)
Mottenkugeln zum Nachweis der Kernstrahlung: Hartmut Kallmann (1896--1978) und die organischen Szintillatoren
(/isis/citation/CBB001220772/)
Article
Bishop, Robert C.;
(2010)
Whence Chemistry?
(/isis/citation/CBB001024209/)
Book
Carl Gillett;
(2016)
Reduction and Emergence in Science and Philosophy
(/isis/citation/CBB296330317/)
Article
Helge Kragh;
(2022)
Chemists Without Knowing It? Computational Chemistry and the Møller-Plesset Perturbation Theory
(/isis/citation/CBB663914589/)
Article
Kragh, Helge;
(2001)
Before quantum chemistry: Erich Hückel and the physics-chemistry interface
(/isis/citation/CBB000100847/)
Article
Healy, Eamonn F.;
(2011)
Heisenberg's Chemical Legacy: Resonance and the Chemical Bond
(/isis/citation/CBB001034528/)
Book
Bokulich, Alisa;
(2008)
Reexamining the Quantum-Classical Relation: Beyond Reductionism and Pluralism
(/isis/citation/CBB001032943/)
Article
Harris, Martha L.;
(2008)
Chemical Reductionism Revisited: Lewis, Pauling and the Physico-Chemical Nature of the Chemical Bond
(/isis/citation/CBB000930749/)
Article
Needham, Paul;
(2010)
Nagel's Analysis of Reduction: Comments in Defense as Well as Critique
(/isis/citation/CBB000933696/)
Book
Kaiser, David;
(2005)
Pedagogy and The Practice of Science: Historical and Contemporary Perspectives
(/isis/citation/CBB000550490/)
Article
Pérez, Enric;
Sauer, Tilman;
(2010)
Einstein's Quantum Theory of the Monatomic Ideal Gas: Non-Statistical Arguments for a New Statistics
(/isis/citation/CBB001022007/)
Book
Vedral, Vlatko;
(2010)
Decoding Reality: The Universe as Quantum Information
(/isis/citation/CBB001500142/)
Article
Eberhart, Mark;
Travis, Jones;
(2013)
The Two Faces of Chemistry: Can They Be Reconciled?
(/isis/citation/CBB001321114/)
Book
Salvatore Califano;
Vincenzo Schettino;
(2018)
La nascita della meccanica quantistica
(/isis/citation/CBB783938005/)
Article
Matta, Chérif F.;
(2013)
Special issue: Philosophical Aspects and Implications of the Quantum Theory of Atoms in Molecules (QTAIM).
(/isis/citation/CBB001321113/)
Article
Schummer, Joachim;
(2000)
Models in Chemistry (2): Molecular Models
(/isis/citation/CBB000101910/)
Be the first to comment!