IsisCB Explore

Article ID: CBB001210307

Discipline and Credibility in the Post-War Australopithecine Controversy: Le Gros Clark versus Zuckerman (2012)

History and Philosophy of the Life Sciences
Volume: 34
Pages: 43--78

Publication Date: 2012
Edition Details: Part of a special issue on the history, philosophy, and social studies of paleoanthropology.
Language: English

Outside Links

WorldCat

Google Scholar

JSTOR

Academia.edu

Comparative anatomy Scientific communities; interprofessional relations Controversies and disputes Human evolution Paleoanthropology Discipline formation 20th century, late Zuckerman, Solly Clark, Wilfrid Edward Le Gros

Paleoanthropologists and outside commentators have often remarked upon the apparent difficulty of securing shared belief among experts in the science of human evolution. The field has been and continues to be particularly prone to disagreement and even controversy among its practitioners to a degree that sets it apart from other areas of scientific inquiry. The fact that the field lies at the intersection of a number of disciplines may help to explain this predicament. Displays of discipline serve as an important resource for scientists as they work to secure credibility. Where a field of inquiry spans a host of disciplinary approaches, there can be disagreement about the kind of disciplined behavior appropriate to making credible claims about that field's subject matter. A conflict of this sort emerged after WWII over the claim that the australopithecines of South Africa represented a likely ancestral link in the evolution of human beings. W.E. Le Gros Clark, working in the established disciplinary tradition of comparative anatomy, endorsed the claim of ancestry, while Solly Zuckerman, reflecting his recent immersion in war-time operations research, criticized that claim on the grounds that it came without the rigorous quantitative demonstration that he felt was the hallmark of a properly disciplined science.

...More

Included in

Article Delisle, Richard G. (2012) Human Evolution: An Agenda for History, Philosophy, and Social Studies. History and Philosophy of the Life Sciences (p. 3). unapi

Citation URI

https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB001210307/

Citations Indexes

Similar Citations

Book Oisín Wall; (2017)
The British Anti-Psychiatrists: From Institutional Psychiatry to the Counter-Culture, 1960-1971 (/isis/citation/CBB248999877/)

Article Goodrum, Matthew R.; (2012)
The Idea of Human Prehistory: The Natural Sciences, the Human Sciences, and the Problem of Human Origins in Victorian Britain (/isis/citation/CBB001210310/)

Article Delisle, Richard G.; (2012)
Welcome to the Twilight Zone: A Forgotten Early Phase of Human Evolutionary Studies (/isis/citation/CBB001210165/)

Article Delisle, Richard G.; (2012)
The Disciplinary and Epistemological Structure of Paleoanthropology: One Hundred and Fifty Years of Development (/isis/citation/CBB001210316/)

Article Bender, Renato; Tobias, Phillip V.; Bender, Nicole; (2012)
The Savannah Hypotheses: Origin, Reception and Impact on Paleoanthropology (/isis/citation/CBB001210311/)

Article Delisle, Richard G.; (2012)
Human Evolution: An Agenda for History, Philosophy, and Social Studies (/isis/citation/CBB001210304/)

Article Claudine Cohen; (2017)
“How nationality influences Opinion”: Darwinism and palaeontology in France (1859–1914) (/isis/citation/CBB709081900/)

Article Mathilde Lequin; (2022)
Comment nommer la lignée humaine ? De l’ordre des Bimanes à la sous-tribu des hominiens (/isis/citation/CBB412033582/)

Article Schwartz, Jeffrey H.; (2012)
Molecular Anthropology and the Subversion of Paleoanthropology: An Example of “The Emperor's Clothes” Effect? (/isis/citation/CBB001210314/)

Article Sommer, Marianne; (2008)
History in the Gene: Negotiations between Molecular and Organismal Anthropology (/isis/citation/CBB000850670/)

Article Pierre-Olaf Schut; Matthieu Delalandre; (2015)
L’échec d’une discipline: Montée et déclin de la spéléologie en France (1888-1978) (/isis/citation/CBB728490474/)

Book Biagioli, Mario; Galison, Peter Louis; (2003)
Scientific Authorship: Credit and Intellectual Property in Science (/isis/citation/CBB000430244/)

Essay Review Benedictus, Fedde; (2012)
Quantum Information (/isis/citation/CBB001500141/)

Article Bulpin, Kate; Molyneux-Hodgson, Susan; (2013)
The Disciplining of Scientific Communities (/isis/citation/CBB001201234/)

Article Weldon, Stephen P.; (2013)
Bibliography Is Social: Organizing Knowledge in the Isis Bibliography from Sarton to the Early Twenty-First Century (/isis/citation/CBB001321215/)

Article Johnson, Ann; (2009)
Modeling Molecules: Computational Nanotechnology as a Knowledge (/isis/citation/CBB000932270/)

Book Fuchs, Christopher A.; (2011)
Coming of Age with Quantum Information: Notes on a Paulian Idea: Selected Correspondence, 1995--2001 (/isis/citation/CBB001500143/)

Article Vanpaemel, Geert; (2013)
Versnippering of diversiteit? De Belgische wetenschapsgeschiedenis na de Tweede Wereldoorlog (/isis/citation/CBB001321082/)

Article Park, Buhm Soon; (2003)
The “Hyperbola of Quantum Chemistry”: The Changing Practice and Identity of a Scientific Discipline in the Early Years of Electronic Digital Computers, 1945--65 (/isis/citation/CBB000330689/)

Article Silvia Lévy; Miguel Huertas-Maestro; Rafael Huertas; (2022)
The reception of psychodrama in Spain: Correspondence between Jacob Levy Moreno and Ramón Sarró (/isis/citation/CBB764974543/)

Comments

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}