IsisCB Explore

Article ID: CBB001202105

Animal Individuals: A Plea for a Nominalistic Turn in Animal Studies? (2013)

Hoquet, Thierry (Author)

History and Theory
Volume: 52, no. 4
Issue: 4
Pages: 68-90

DOI: 10.1111/hith.10688

Publication Date: 2013
Edition Details: Special Issue: Does History Need Animals?
Language: English

Outside Links

WorldCat

Google Scholar

JSTOR

Academia.edu

Specimens Visual representation; visual communication Nominalism (philosophy) Philosophy of science, as a discipline Animals Symbolism; symbolic representation Science and art Individuality Science and law 18th century Buffon, Georges Louis Leclerc de Condillac, Étienne Bonnot de

This paper focuses on the concept of animal individuals and puts forward a nominalistic approach. Nominalism is an ontological thesis (only individuals exist), but also an epistemological claim: that our nouns are practical tools for a quick dispatch of things, but do not correspond to anything real. Hence for a consistent nominalist, animals do not exist, except as a powerful fiction. First, we show that the word animal commits what we call (after Plato) the fallacy of the crane: it encompasses a huge range of living entities that have only one thing in common: they are not humans. Differences between our term animal and the ancient Greek zoon also show the fluctuating boundaries of animality. Besides, our ways of speaking systematically deny individuality to nonhuman animals. The philosophical meaning of the term individual implies a genuine dimension of artistic singularity and a political claim for emancipation. Portraits of apes are striking instances of such individuality, captured by photography, as is art produced by particular animals. Methodologically, this leads also to the collection of anecdotes and a focus on animal biographies. The eighteenth-century controversy between Buffon and Condillac helps us understand what is at stake in the tension between species and individuals. Buffon claims that each nonhuman animal species can be represented by a specimen, whereas Condillac shows that animal individuals feel like us and that their nature is impenetrable to us. Finally, a focus on individuals is not only a way to renew or extend historical methods. Biologists are also increasingly concerned with individuals. They develop tools to distinguish individuals from one another: animal bertillonage for morphology. They question standard norms of behavior and preferences. This emphasis on animal individuality has not only theoretical but also ethical and legal consequences.

...More

Included in

Article Shaw, David Gary (2013) A Way with Animals. History and Theory (pp. 1-12). unapi

Citation URI

https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB001202105/

Citations Indexes

Similar Citations

Article Hein van den Berg; (2020)
Theoretical Virtues in Eighteenth-Century Debates on Animal Cognition (/isis/citation/CBB446986848/)

Article Kemp, Martin; (2012)
“The testimony of my own eyes”: The Strange Case of the Mammal with a Beak (/isis/citation/CBB001212087/)

Article Liebman, Elizabeth Amy; (2010)
Animal Attitudes: Motion and Emotion in Eighteenth-Century Animal Representation (/isis/citation/CBB001032696/)

Chapter Vermij, Rienk; (2011)
The Light of Nature and the Allegorisation of Science on Dutch Frontispieces around 1700 (/isis/citation/CBB001201619/)

Thesis Liebman, Elizabeth Amy; (2003)
Painting Natures: Buffon and the Art of the “Histoire naturelle” (/isis/citation/CBB001560564/)

Book Groom, Linda; (2009)
First Fleet Artist: George Raper's Birds and Plants of Australia (/isis/citation/CBB001033600/)

Article Ridley, Glynis; (2010)
Introduction: Representing Animals (/isis/citation/CBB001032699/)

Article E. Charles Nelson; (2023)
New identifications of natural history images on the “Bodleian Plate”, an early eighteenth-century engraved copperplate (/isis/citation/CBB367812823/)

Chapter Loveland, Jeff; (2003)
French Thought in William Smellie's Natural History: A Scottish Reception of Buffon and Condillac (/isis/citation/CBB000410948/)

Book Antoine Traisnel; (2020)
Capture: American Pursuits and the Making of a New Animal Condition (/isis/citation/CBB660480379/)

Book Scott Selisker; (2016)
Human Programming: Brainwashing, Automatons, and American Unfreedom (/isis/citation/CBB521192758/)

Article Alvise Sforza Tarabochia; (2021)
The staff of madness: the visualization of insanity and the othering of the insane (/isis/citation/CBB672317709/)

Article Tevebring, Frederika; (2012)
Unveiling the Goddess. Artemis of Ephesus as a Symbol of Nature at the Turn of the Nineteenth Century (/isis/citation/CBB001320378/)

Book Liana De Girolami Cheney; (2021)
Edward Burne-Jones on Nature: Physical and Metaphysical Realms (/isis/citation/CBB859584510/)

Article Rossi, Adriana; (2004)
Il Cristo Cronocratore: Allegorie e simboli nel chiostro di Sant Cugat (/isis/citation/CBB000640287/)

Article Daszkiewicz, Piotr; Edel, Philippe; (2014)
The Will of Ludwig Heinrich Bojanus (1776--1827), an Interesting Nineteenth-Century Natural History Document (/isis/citation/CBB001321134/)

Article Torrens, Erica; Barahona, Ana; (2012)
The “Tree of Life” in Textbooks and Museums (/isis/citation/CBB001320806/)

Book Peter Whitfield; (2016)
Mapping Shakespeare's World (/isis/citation/CBB880899390/)

Article Whitney E. Laemmli; (2022)
How to Capture Movement (/isis/citation/CBB065455071/)

Book Meisen, Lydia; (2008)
Die Charakterisierung der Tiere in Buffons Histoire naturelle (/isis/citation/CBB000950241/)

Comments

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}