Interpreting transnational infrastructure vulnerability: 4/11 and the historical dynamics of transnational electricity governance (2010)
Lagendijk, Vincent (Author)
Vleuten, Erik van der (Author)
Energy Policy
Volume: 38
Issue: 4
Pages: 2053-2062
Recent transnational blackouts exposed two radically opposed interpretations of Europe’s electricity infrastructure, which inform recent and ongoing negotiations on transnational electricity governance. To EU policy makers such blackouts revealed the fragility of Europe’s power grids and the need of a more centralized form of governance, thus legitimizing recent EU interventions. Yet to power sector spokespersons, these events confirmed the reliability of transnational power grids and the traditional decentralized governance model: the disturbances were quickly contained and repaired. This paper inquires the historic legacies at work in these conflicting interpretations and associated transnational governance preferences. It traces the power sector’s interpretation to its building of a secure transnational power grid from the 1950s through the era of neoliberalization. Next it places the EU interpretation and associated policy measures against the historical record of EU attempts at transnational infrastructure governance. Uncovering the historical roots and embedding of both interpretations, we conclude that their divergence is of a surprisingly recent date and relates to the current era of security thinking. Finally we recommend transnational, interpretative, and historical analysis to the field of critical infrastructure studies.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Lagendijk, Vincent;
Vleuten, Erik van der;
(April 2010)
Transnational infrastructure vulnerability: The historical shaping of the 2006 European blackout
(/isis/citation/CBB001180972/)
Article
Lagendijk, Vincent;
Vleuten, Erik van der;
Anastasiadou, Irene;
Schipper, Frank;
(2007)
Europe's system builders: The contested shaping of transnational road, electricity, and rail networks
(/isis/citation/CBB001180965/)
Article
Christopher Lawless;
(2020)
Assembling airspace: The Single European Sky and contested transnationalities of European air traffic management
(/isis/citation/CBB169587089/)
Book
Daniel Jordan Smith;
(2022)
Every Household Its Own Government: Improvised Infrastructure, Entrepreneurial Citizens, and the State in Nigeria
(/isis/citation/CBB663829322/)
Chapter
Lagendijk, Vincent;
(2010)
New connections for an old continent: Rail, road, and electricity in the league of Nations' Organisation for communications and transit
(/isis/citation/CBB001180970/)
Article
Lagendijk, Vincent;
(2008)
Histoire de l'idée d'un système Européen de l'électricité: Projet, progrès, persistance; (History of the Idea of a European electricity: Project, progress, persistence)
(/isis/citation/CBB001180967/)
Book
Huub Dijstelbloem;
(2021)
Borders as Infrastructure: The Technopolitics of Border Control
(/isis/citation/CBB684823908/)
Book
Valentine Aldebert;
Christian Henrich-Franke;
Léonard Laborie;
Sabrina Proschmann;
Guido Thiemeyer;
(2022)
Conflict in Cooperation: Crossborder Infrastructures in Europe Facing the Second World War
(/isis/citation/CBB020477436/)
Chapter
Schipper, Frank;
(2009)
European integration and infrastructures since the 19th century
(/isis/citation/CBB001181613/)
Book
Badenoch, Alexander;
Fickers, Andreas;
(2010)
Materializing Europe: Transnational infrastructures and the project of Europe
(/isis/citation/CBB001181606/)
Book
Badenoch, Alexander;
Fickers, Andreas;
(2010)
Materializing Europe: Transnational infrastructures and the project of Europe
(/isis/citation/CBB001180968/)
Book
Arne Kaijser;
Per Högselius;
Erik van der Vleuten;
(2016)
Europe’s Infrastructure Transition: Economy, War, Nature
(/isis/citation/CBB434310927/)
Book
Disco, Cornelis;
Kranakis, Eda;
(2013)
Cosmopolitan Commons: Sharing Resources and Risks across Borders
(/isis/citation/CBB001421290/)
Book
Merger, Michèle;
Carreras, Albert;
Giuntini, Andrea;
(1995)
Les réseaux européens transnationaux: XIXe - XXe siècles: quels enjeux? (Trans-European networks: XIX - XX centuries: What issues?)
(/isis/citation/CBB001180505/)
Article
Schot, Johan;
Buiter, Hans;
Anastasiadou, ;
(2011)
The Dynamics of Transnational Railway Governance in Europe during the Long Nineteenth Century
(/isis/citation/CBB001210208/)
Chapter
Laer, Arthe Van;
Bussière, E.;
(2007)
Recherche et technologie ou la “sextuple tutelle” des États sur “la Commission, éternelle mineure”; (Research and Technology or “sextuple trust” under the States “the Commission, eternal minor”)
(/isis/citation/CBB001181581/)
Article
Krebs, Stefan;
(2012)
Standardizing Car Sound---Integrating Europe? International Traffic Noise Abatement and the Emergence of a European Car Identity, 1950--1975
(/isis/citation/CBB001210227/)
Article
Laborie, Léonard;
(2011)
Fragile Links, Frozen Identities: The Governance of Telecommunication Networks and Europe (1944--53)
(/isis/citation/CBB001210210/)
Article
Lagendijk, Vincent;
(2012)
“To Consolidate Peace”? The International Electro-technical Community and the Grid for the United States of Europe
(/isis/citation/CBB001200207/)
Article
Tatiana Acevedo-Guerrero;
(2019)
Light is like water: Flooding, blackouts, and the state in Barranquilla
(/isis/citation/CBB476051463/)
Be the first to comment!