As the deficit model's failure leaves scientists searching for more effective communicative approaches, science communication scholars have begun promoting narrative as a potent persuasive tool. Narratives can help the public make choices by setting out a scientific issue's contexts, establishing the stakes involved, and offering potential solutions. However, employing narrative for persuasion risks embracing the same top-down communication approach underlying deficit model thinking. This essay explores the parallels between movie censorship and the current use of narrative to influence public opinion by examining how the Hays Office and the Catholic Legion of Decency responded to science in movies. I argue that deploying narratives solely as public relations exercises demonstrates the same mistrust of audiences that provided the foundation of movie censorship. But the history of movie censorship reveals the dangers of using narrative to remove the public's agency and to coerce them towards a preferred position rather than fostering their ability to come to their own conclusions.
...MoreArticle Fernando Vidal (2018) Introduction: From “The Popularization of Science through Film” to “The Public Understanding of Science”. Science in Context (pp. 1-14).
Article
David A. Kirby;
(2019)
Darwin on the Cutting-Room Floor: Evolution, Religion, and Film Censorship
(/isis/citation/CBB439203153/)
Article
Logan Brown;
(July 2022)
Learning to Love Computers: Useful Cinema and the Mediation of American Computing, 1958–62
(/isis/citation/CBB844898152/)
Chapter
Pieter Cools;
Ana Prades;
Beatriz Medina;
Ann Enander;
Wilfried Konrad;
Josep Espluga;
(2021)
Risky or Beneficial? Exploring Perceptions of Nuclear Energy
over Time in a Cross-Country Perspective
(/isis/citation/CBB912308416/)
Book
Sean W. Maher;
(2020)
Film Noir and Los Angeles: Urban History and the Dark Imaginary
(/isis/citation/CBB729971685/)
Article
Wosk, Julie;
(2010)
Update on the film Metropolis
(/isis/citation/CBB001180649/)
Book
Richard Butsch;
(2019)
Screen Culture: a global history
(/isis/citation/CBB784918517/)
Book
Luci Marzola;
(2021)
Engineering Hollywood : Technology, technicians, and the science of building the studio system
(/isis/citation/CBB438938942/)
Article
Nikolas Dörr;
(2019)
Die „saubere“ Atombombe. Die Bedeutung der Neutronenwaffe als Projektionsfl äche im Kalten Krieg (The “Clean” Atomic Bomb. The Significance of Neutron Weaponry as a Projection Screen during the Cold War)
(/isis/citation/CBB198141177/)
Book
Megan Finn;
(2018)
Documenting Aftermath: Information Infrastructures in the Wake of Disasters
(/isis/citation/CBB913221779/)
Article
Fernando Vidal;
(2018)
Accuracy, Authenticity, Fidelity: Aesthetic Realism, the “Deficit Model,” and the Public Understanding of Science
(/isis/citation/CBB590284632/)
Article
Carlos Tabernero;
(2018)
The Changing Nature of Modernization Discourses in Documentary Films
(/isis/citation/CBB507058201/)
Book
Matthew B. Karush;
(2012)
Culture of Class: Radio and Cinema in the Making of a Divided Argentina
(/isis/citation/CBB674935177/)
Article
Womack, Jeffrey;
(January 2013)
Nuclear Weapons, Dystopian Deserts, and Science Fiction Cinema
(/isis/citation/CBB406896513/)
Article
Wosk, Julie;
(2010)
Metropolis
(/isis/citation/CBB001180650/)
Article
Sudev Sheth;
Geoffrey Jones;
Morgan Spencer;
(Autumn 2021)
Emboldening and Contesting Gender and Skin Color Stereotypes in the Film Industry in India, 1947–1991
(/isis/citation/CBB186027195/)
Article
Ryuma Shineha;
(September 2016)
Attention to Stem Cell Research in Japanese Mass Media: Twenty-Year Macrotrends and the Gap between Media Attention and Ethical, Legal, and Social Issues
(/isis/citation/CBB102505484/)
Article
Kirsten Ostherr;
(2018)
The Shifting Aesthetics of Expertise in the Sharing Economy of Scientific Medicine
(/isis/citation/CBB431151741/)
Article
Cian O’Donovan;
Johan Schot;
(May 2018)
Crafting Stories of Technology and Progress: Five Considerations
(/isis/citation/CBB258988265/)
Article
Dunaway, Finis;
(July 2017)
Gallery Editor's Note
(/isis/citation/CBB975325092/)
Chapter
Mindell, David;
Segal, Jérôme;
Gerovitch, Slava;
(2003)
From Communications Engineering to Communications Science: Cybernetics and Information Theory in the United States, France, and the Soviet Union
(/isis/citation/CBB000301261/)
Be the first to comment!