Claiming and Adjudicating on Mt. Kilimanjaro's Shrinking Glaciers: Guy Callendar, Al Gore and Extended Peer Communities (2010)
Climate change has mutated from being a physical phenomenon to be studied to an idea to be contested. The sites of adjudication between competing truth claims have therefore moved from the secluded academy and scientific peer review to the vociferous agora and the extended peer community. This move is illustrated here using the case of the shrinking glaciers of Mt Kilimanjaro. Both the British engineer Guy Callendar, in 1944, and the American campaigner Al Gore, in 2006, claimed that the primary cause of this glacial recession was rising world temperature. Both were passionate believers in the reality of human-induced global warming, but they had very different resources at their disposal to advance these beliefs. While Callendar's claim was revealed only to the editor of the science journal Nature, Gore's claims were visible to millions through his film An Inconvenient Truth. While the force of Callendar's claim was weighed and adjudicated by one peer reviewer, the validity of Gore's claim was tested very publicly in the British courts. Both claims about the cause of Kilimanjaro's retreating glaciers were found wanting. The paper argues that this simple, but powerful, comparison between identical claims-making drawn from two different eras of science, yet with contrasting processes of truth-adjudication, illuminates the different `post-normal' world of science climate change now inhabits. The case study is used to reflect on the role of the extended peer community in establishing and validating scientific knowledge about climate change: who participates, how trust is stabilised and whether science is thereby democratised.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Moser, Susanne C.;
(2010)
Communicating Climate Change: History, Challenges, Process and Future Directions
(/isis/citation/CBB001221298/)
Article
Jamison, Andrew;
(2010)
Climate Change Knowledge and Social Movement Theory
(/isis/citation/CBB001221292/)
Article
Buys, Laurie;
Aird, Rosemary;
Megen, Kimberley van;
Miller, Evonne;
Sommerfeld, Jeffrey;
(2014)
Perceptions of Climate Change and Trust in Information Providers in Rural Australia
(/isis/citation/CBB001420056/)
Article
Rudiak-Gould, Peter;
(2014)
Progress, Decline, and the Public Uptake of Climate Science
(/isis/citation/CBB001420054/)
Article
Melinda Baldwin;
(2019)
Peer Review
(/isis/citation/CBB566141723/)
Book
David Harker;
(2015)
Creating Scientific Controversies: Uncertainty and Bias in Science and Society
(/isis/citation/CBB156153688/)
Article
James Lawrence Powell;
(2016)
The Consensus on Anthropogenic Global Warming Matters
(/isis/citation/CBB862128887/)
Article
Ranalli, Brent Tibor;
(2011)
A Prehistory of Peer Review: Religious Blueprints from the Hartlib Circle
(/isis/citation/CBB001220692/)
Article
Sörlin, Sverker;
(2011)
The Anxieties of a Science Diplomat: Field Coproduction of Climate Knowledge and the Rise and Fall of Hans Ahlmann's “Polar Warming”
(/isis/citation/CBB001034574/)
Article
Sophie Ritson;
(August 2016)
‘Crackpots’ and ‘active researchers’: The controversy over links between arXiv and the scientific blogosphere
(/isis/citation/CBB402774757/)
Article
Sörlin, Sverker;
(2009)
Narratives and Counter-Narratives of Climate Change: North Atlantic Glaciology and Meteorology, c.1930--1955
(/isis/citation/CBB001034159/)
Article
Nierenberg, Nicolas;
Tschinkel, Walter R.;
Tschinkel, Victoria J.;
(2010)
Early Climate Change Consensus at the National Academy: The Origins and Making of Changing Climate
(/isis/citation/CBB001022609/)
Book
Max Martin;
Vinita Damodaran;
Rohan D'Souza;
(2019)
Geography in Britain after World War II: Nature, Climate, and the Etchings of Time
(/isis/citation/CBB611603124/)
Article
Bohn, Maria;
(2011)
Concentrating on CO2: The Scandinavian and Arctic Measurements
(/isis/citation/CBB001034579/)
Article
Evelyn Fox Keller;
(2017)
Climate science, truth, and democracy
(/isis/citation/CBB787498022/)
Article
Gupta, Joyeeta;
(2010)
A History of International Climate Change Policy
(/isis/citation/CBB001221294/)
Thesis
Sonnett, John H.;
(2006)
Representing the Earth: Global Climate Issues in Popular, Political, Scientific, Business, Industry, and Environmentalist News: A New Old Sociology of Knowledge
(/isis/citation/CBB001560796/)
Article
Rekdal, Ole Bjørn;
(2014)
Academic Urban Legends
(/isis/citation/CBB001421187/)
Article
Andrew G. Skuce;
John Cook;
Mark Richardson;
Bärbel Winkler;
Ken Rice;
Sarah A. Green;
Peter Jacobs;
Dana Nuccitelli;
(2016)
Does It Matter if the Consensus on Anthropogenic Global Warming Is 97% or 99.99%?
(/isis/citation/CBB075592404/)
Article
Wibeck, Victoria;
(2014)
Social Representations of Climate Change in Swedish Lay Focus Groups: Local or Distant, Gradual or Catastrophic?
(/isis/citation/CBB001420058/)
Be the first to comment!