Article ID: CBB001034642

Envisioning Ethical Nanotechnology: The Rhetorical Role of Visions in Postponing Societal and Ethical Implications Research (2011)

unapi

Visions of the future are often used to promote new technologies, including nanotechnology. They are also used in discussions of the social and ethical issues (SEI) of nanotechnology, yet their roles in these discussions are unclear. These roles, however, are important because stakeholders and government funding agencies rely on the discourses in which visions appear to understand what SEI are and how they should be addressed. Rhetorical analysis of three common future visions found in arguments supporting US funding of nanotechnology SEI research in a 2003 US House of Representatives hearing shows how anticipations are used to help constitute discussions about SEI research and programs. The effects of the deployment of these visions are to emphasize postponement of SEI research, frame a vague role for SEI dependent on technological development, and contribute to a vision of a vaguely defined, yet ethical future nanotechnology that helps halt concerns about nanotechnology while also directing attention away from present concerns and possible action. This last vision affects discussions about what SEI of nanotechnology should be by functioning as a frame for articulating SEI as postponed to the future and so indicating that technological development should continue without engaging SEI concerns. These findings also resonate with recent articulations of SEI appearing in 2008 US government documents and contradict other statements about funding nanotechnology's SEI. Further, these findings suggest a need for more clearly addressing the presence and roles of visions in SEI discourses to better articulate possibilities and limits of SEI research and programs

...More
Citation URI
https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB001034642/

Similar Citations

Article Jeff Robbins; (September 2019)
If Technology Is a Parasite Masquerading as a Symbiont—Are We the Host? (/isis/citation/CBB920285686/)

Article Jeremy Pitt; Katina Michael; Terri Bookman; (September 2019)
ISTAS 2018: Technology, Ethics, and Policy [Special Issue Introduction] (/isis/citation/CBB486814525/)

Article Bennett, Ira; Sarewitz, Daniel; (2006)
Too Little, Too Late? Research Policies on the Societal Implications of Nanotechnology in the United States (/isis/citation/CBB000720308/)

Article Guston, David H.; (2014)
Understanding “Anticipatory Governance” (/isis/citation/CBB001421172/)

Article Cacciatore, Michael A.; Scheufele, Dietram A.; Corley, Elizabeth A.; (2011)
From Enabling Technology to Applications: The Evolution of Risk Perceptions about Nanotechnology (/isis/citation/CBB001034664/)

Book Roco, Mihail C.; Bainbridge, William Sims; (2007)
Nanotechnology: Societal implications, Vol. II, Individual perspectives (/isis/citation/CBB001180394/)

Article Baird, Davis; Schummer, Joachim; (2005)
Editorial (/isis/citation/CBB000630293/)

Article Ebbesen, Mette; Andersen, Svend; Besenbacher, Flemming; (2006)
Ethics in Nanotechnology: Starting From Scratch? (/isis/citation/CBB000780182/)

Book Milburn, Colin; (2008)
Nanovision: Engineering the Future (/isis/citation/CBB000951114/)

Book David D. Clark; Sandra Braman; (2018)
Designing an Internet (/isis/citation/CBB601148284/)

Book Lipsey, Richard G; Carlaw, Kenneth; Bekar, Clifford; (2005)
Economic transformations: General purpose technologies and long-term economic growth (/isis/citation/CBB001180076/)

Article Bulliet, William M.; Berne, Rosalyn W.; (Sprin 2019)
EES Perspective: Aging, Technology and Ethics (/isis/citation/CBB220644089/)

Article Tien, James M.; (Winter 2014)
Overview of Big Data: A US Perspective (/isis/citation/CBB504574424/)

Article Ott, Ingrid; Papilloud, Christian; (2007)
Converging Institutions: Shaping Relationships between Nanotechnologies, Economy, and Society (/isis/citation/CBB000720390/)

Essay Review Seely, Bruce Edsall; (2008)
Big Promises: David Berube's Nano-Hype (/isis/citation/CBB001566978/)

Article Pense, Christine M.; Cutcliffe, Stephen H.; (2007)
Risky Talk: Framing the Analysis of the Social Implications of Nanotechnology (/isis/citation/CBB000720384/)

Thesis Rudd, Jeffrey D.; (2009)
U.S. Nanotechnology Policy and the Decay of Environmental Law, 1980--2005 (/isis/citation/CBB001561123/)

Authors & Contributors
Schummer, Joachim
Katina Michael
Terri Bookman
Jeremy Pitt
Jeff Robbins
Tien, James M.
Concepts
Technology
Nanotechnology
Technology and society
Technology and ethics
Technological innovation
Technology and politics
Time Periods
21st century
20th century, late
20th century
19th century
Places
United States
Europe
Institutions
National Nanotechnology Initiative (U.S.)
Comments

Be the first to comment!

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}

Log in or register to comment