Ontological Tensions in Sixteenth- and Seventeenth-Century Chemistry: Between Mechanism and Vitalism (2011)
The sixteenth and seventeenth centuries marks a period of transition between the vitalistic ontology that had dominated Renaissance natural philosophy and the Early Modern mechanistic paradigm endorsed by, among others, the Cartesians and Newtonians. This paper will focus on how the tensions between vitalism and mechanism played themselves out in the context of sixteenth and seventeenth century chemistry and chemical philosophy, particularly in the works of Paracelsus, Jan Baptista Van Helmont, Robert Fludd, and Robert Boyle. Rather than argue that these natural philosophers each embraced either fully vitalistic or fully mechanistic ontologies, I hope to demonstrate that these thinkers adhered to complicated and nuanced ontologies that cannot be described in either purely vitalistic or purely mechanistic terms. A central feature of my argument is the claim that a corpuscularian theory of matter does not entail a strictly mechanistic and reductionistic account of chemical properties. I also argue that what marks the shift from pre-modern vitalistic chemical philosophy to the modern chemical philosophy that marked the Chemical Revolution is not the victory of mechanism and reductionism in chemistry but, rather, the shift to a physicalistic and naturalistic account of chemical properties and vital spirits.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Book
Wagner, Lioba;
(2011)
Alchemie und Naturwissenschaft: Über die Entstehung neuer Ideen an der Reibungsfläche zweier Weltbilder. Gezeigt an Paracelsus, Robert Boyle und Isaac Newton
(/isis/citation/CBB001221169/)
Book
Newman, William R.;
Principe, Lawrence M.;
(2002)
Alchemy Tried in the Fire: Starkey, Boyle, and the Fate of Helmontian Chymistry
(/isis/citation/CBB000301520/)
Article
Newman, William R.;
(2009)
The Significance of “Chymical Atomism”
(/isis/citation/CBB000932579/)
Book
Clericuzio, Antonio;
(2000)
Elements, Principles and Corpuscles: A Study of Atomism and Chemistry in the Seventeenth Century
(/isis/citation/CBB000100183/)
Article
Emma Wilkins;
(2016)
‘Exploding’ Immaterial Substances: Margaret Cavendish’s Vitalist-Materialist Critique of Spirits
(/isis/citation/CBB644104711/)
Book
Didier Kahn;
(2016)
Le fixe et le volatil: chimie et alchimie, de Paracelse à Lavoisier
(/isis/citation/CBB308791400/)
Chapter
Hirai, Hiro;
(2010)
The World-Spirit and Quintessence in the Chymical Philosophy of Joseph du Chesne
(/isis/citation/CBB001023513/)
Article
Linda A. Newson;
(2020)
Alchemy and Chemical Medicines in Early Colonial Lima, Peru
(/isis/citation/CBB042314859/)
Book
López Pérez, Miguel;
Kahn, Didier;
Rey Bueno, Mar;
(2010)
Chymia: Science and Nature in Early Modern Europe (1450--1750)
(/isis/citation/CBB001023359/)
Article
Hedesan, Georgiana D.;
(2014)
Paracelsian Medicine and Theory of Generation in “Exterior homo”, a Manuscript Probably Authored by Jan Baptist Van Helmont (1579--1644)
(/isis/citation/CBB001422153/)
Article
Keller, Vera;
(2010)
Drebbel's Living Instruments, Hartmann's Microcosm, and Libavius's Thelesmos: Epistemic Machines before Descartes
(/isis/citation/CBB000953650/)
Chapter
Keller, Vera;
(2011)
How to Become a Seventeenth-Century Natural Philosopher: The Case of Cornelis Drebbel (1572--1633)
(/isis/citation/CBB001221244/)
Chapter
William R. Newman;
(2016)
Spirits in the Laboratory: Some Helmontian Collaborators of Robert Boyle
(/isis/citation/CBB772036414/)
Book
Debus, Allen G.;
(2001)
Chemistry and Medical Debate: van Helmont to Boerhaave
(/isis/citation/CBB000320370/)
Article
William R. Newman;
(2020)
Bad Chemistry: Basilisks and Women in Paracelsus and pseudo-Paracelsus
(/isis/citation/CBB593660659/)
Book
Paracelsus, ;
Weeks, Andrew;
(2008)
Essential Theoretical Writings
(/isis/citation/CBB001220259/)
Article
Marta Licata;
Ilaria Gorini;
Valeria Schiavone;
Rosagemma Ciliberti;
(2018)
Magic, Science and Morality in Renaissance Humanist Medicine and Psychiatry
(/isis/citation/CBB937658561/)
Article
Porto, Paulo A.;
(2002)
“Summus atque felicissimus salium”: The Medical Relevance of the Liquor alkahest
(/isis/citation/CBB000201120/)
Article
Marieke M. A. Hendriksen;
(2015)
Anatomical Mercury: Changing Understandings of Quicksilver, Blood, and the Lymphatic System, 1650–1800
(/isis/citation/CBB297910392/)
Article
Fors, Hjalmar;
(2007)
Kemi, paracelsism och mekanisk filosofi. Bergskollegium och Uppsala cirka 1680--1770
(/isis/citation/CBB001220351/)
Marchand, Suzanne L.
British Journal for the History of Philosophy
Bulletin of the History of Medicine
Early Science and Medicine: A Journal for the Study of Science, Technology and Medicine in the Pre-modern Period
History of Science
Be the first to comment!