Newton's Substance Monism, Distant Action, and the Nature of Newton's Empiricism: Discussion of H. Kochiras “Gravity and Newton's Substance Counting Problem” (2011)
Schliesser, Eric S. (Author)
Studies in History and Philosophy of Science
Volume: 42
Pages: 160--166
This paper is a critical response to Hylarie Kochiras' Gravity and Newton's substance counting problem, Studies in History and Philosophy of Science 40 (2009) 267--280. First, the paper argues that Kochiras conflates substances and beings; it proceeds to show that Newton is a substance monist. The paper argues that on methodological grounds Newton has adequate resources to respond to the metaphysical problems diagnosed by Kochiras. Second, the paper argues against the claim that Newton is committed to two speculative doctrines attributed to him by Kochiras and earlier Andrew Janiak: i) the passivity of matter and ii) the principle of local causation. Third, the paper argues that while Kochiras' (and Janiak's) arguments about Newton's metaphysical commitments are mistaken, it qualifies the characterization of Newton as an extreme empiricist as defended by Howard Stein and Rob DiSalle. In particular, the paper shows that Newton's empiricism was an intellectual and developmental achievement that built on non trivial speculative commitments about the nature of matter and space.
...MoreDescription A response to JournalArticle; Hylarie Kochiras; Gravity's Cause and Substance... (2011) [1024153]
Article Kochiras, Hylarie (2011) Gravity's Cause and Substance Counting: Contextualizing the Problems. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science (p. 167).
Similar Citations
Article
Ducheyne, Steffen;
(2011)
Newton on Action at a Distance and the Cause of Gravity
(/isis/citation/CBB001024151/)
Article
Kochiras, Hylarie;
(2011)
Gravity's Cause and Substance Counting: Contextualizing the Problems
(/isis/citation/CBB001024153/)
Thesis
Kochiras, Hylarie;
(2008)
Force, Matter, and Metaphysics in Newton's Natural Philosophy
(/isis/citation/CBB001561168/)
Article
Kochiras, Hylarie;
(2009)
Gravity and Newton's Substance Counting Problem
(/isis/citation/CBB000932501/)
Article
Dmitri Levitin;
(2021)
Isaac Newton’s ‘De gravitatione et aequipondio fluidorum’: its purpose in historical context
(/isis/citation/CBB857612261/)
Article
Slowik, Edward;
(2009)
Newton's Metaphysics of Space: A “Tertium Quid” betwixt Substantivalism and Relationism, or Merely a “God of the (Rational Mechanical) Gaps”?
(/isis/citation/CBB000932275/)
Article
Belkind, Ori;
(2013)
Leibniz and Newton on Space
(/isis/citation/CBB001320865/)
Article
Gregory Brown;
(2016)
Did Samuel Clarke Really Disavow Action at a Distance in His Correspondence with Leibniz?: Newton, Clarke, and Bentley on Gravitation and Action at a Distance
(/isis/citation/CBB410182076/)
Article
John Henry;
(2023)
Newton's ‘De Aere et Aethere’ and the introduction of interparticulate forces into his physics
(/isis/citation/CBB856534771/)
Article
Eduardo Salles de Oliveira Barra;
Ricardo Batista dos Santos;
(2017)
Duhem’s Analysis of Newtonian Method and the Logical Priority of Physics over Metaphysics
(/isis/citation/CBB541274680/)
Chapter
Lisa Downing;
(2014)
Locke's Metaphysics and Newtonian Metaphysics
(/isis/citation/CBB820506672/)
Article
Aaron Spink;
(2018)
The Experimental Physics of Jacques Rohault
(/isis/citation/CBB768305096/)
Article
John Henry;
(2020)
Primary and Secondary Causation in Samuel Clarke’s and Isaac Newton’s Theories of Gravity
(/isis/citation/CBB866910656/)
Essay Review
Guicciardini, Niccolò;
(2013)
Harper and Ducheyne on Newton
(/isis/citation/CBB001566365/)
Article
Henry, John;
(2011)
Gravity and De Gravitatione: The Development Of Newton's Ideas on Action at a Distance
(/isis/citation/CBB001024137/)
Article
Ducheyne, Steffen;
(2009)
Understanding (in) Newton's Argument for Universal Gravitation
(/isis/citation/CBB001230068/)
Article
Smith, George;
(1999)
How Did Newton Discover Universal Gravity?
(/isis/citation/CBB000430218/)
Article
Harper, William;
(1999)
The First Six Propositions in Newton's Argument for Universal Gravitation
(/isis/citation/CBB000430220/)
Article
Ruffner, J. A.;
(2012)
Newton's “De Gravitatione”: A Review and Reassessment
(/isis/citation/CBB001232493/)
Article
Tonietti, Tito M.;
(2000)
Does Newton's Musical Model of Gravitation Work? A Mistake and Its Meaning
(/isis/citation/CBB000111533/)
Be the first to comment!