Can De-Growth Be Considered a Policy Option? A Historical Note on Nicholas Georgescu-Roegen and the Club of Rome (2010)
Levallois, Clement (Author)
Ecological Economics: The Journal of the International Society for Ecological Economics
Volume: 69
Pages: 2271--2278
At a few months' interval, Georgescu-Roegen's The Entropy Law and the Economic Process (1971) and Club of Rome's Limits to Growth (1972) were published. Both emphasized the dangers of economic growth, and both drew negative reactions from mainstream economists. Relying on archival evidence, we show that Georgescu-Roegen and the Club of Rome developed strategies of mutual support, which would present them at first view as natural allies. Georgescu-Roegen actually became a member of the Club of Rome, while Dennis Meadows acknowledged the influence of Georgescu-Roegen's ideas on the team of authors of Limits to Growth. But in the late 70's, the gap widened between Georgescu-Roegen's adamant defense of de-growth, and the Club of Rome's less firm view of sustainable growth. This paper explores the process leading to the self-isolation of Georgescu-Roegen, by showing that beyond a shared acknowledgment that economic and biologic systems were interdependent, technological optimism and ambitions for the global management of growth were central to the Club of Rome, while Georgescu-Roegen's personal history led him to ignore those practicalities and judge that de-growth was inescapable. Keywords: Nicholas Georgescu-Roegen; History of ecological economics; De-growth; Club of Rome
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Blanchard, Elodie Vieille;
(2010)
Modelling the Future: An Overview of the “Limits to Growth” Debate
(/isis/citation/CBB000954821/)
Article
Lenfant, Jean-Sébastien;
(2012)
Indifference Curves and the Ordinalist Revolution
(/isis/citation/CBB001451797/)
Article
François Allisson;
Antoine Missemer;
(2020)
Some historiographical tools for the study of intellectual legacies
(/isis/citation/CBB123808630/)
Article
Latorre, Juan Garcia;
Picon, Andres Sanchez;
Latorre, Jesus Garcia;
(2001)
The Man-Made Desert: Effects of Economic and Demographic Growth on the Ecosystems of Arid Southeastern Spain
(/isis/citation/CBB000101031/)
Article
Kruke, Anja;
Woyke, Meik;
(2010)
Editorial
(/isis/citation/CBB001023652/)
Article
Mokyr, Joel;
(2005)
The Intellectual Origins of Modern Economic Growth
(/isis/citation/CBB000660456/)
Book
Viktor Pál;
(2017)
Technology and the Environment in State-Socialist Hungary: an Economic History
(/isis/citation/CBB798286827/)
Article
Teräväinen, Tuula;
(2014)
Representations of Energy Policy and Technology in British and Finnish Newspaper Media: A Comparative Perspective
(/isis/citation/CBB001420064/)
Book
Lifset, Robert;
(2014)
American Energy Policy in the 1970s
(/isis/citation/CBB001422389/)
Article
Stamhuis, Ida H.;
(2007)
A Nineteenth-Century Statistical Society that Abandoned Statistics
(/isis/citation/CBB000773207/)
Article
Hartmann, Heinrich;
(2010)
Verwissenschaftlichte Moderne? Bevölkerungspolitische Handlungsfelder in der Türkei als Zonen komplexen Wissenstransfers von den 1940er bis zu den 1970er Jahren. Eine Skizze
(/isis/citation/CBB001023662/)
Article
Ramsden, Edmund;
(2014)
Surveying the Meritocracy: The Problems of Intelligence and Mobility in the Studies of the Population Investigation Committee
(/isis/citation/CBB001421072/)
Thesis
Nair, Rahul S.;
(2006)
The Discourse on Population in India, 1870--1960
(/isis/citation/CBB001561469/)
Article
Arunabh Ghosh;
(2018)
Lies, Damned Lies, and (Bourgeois) Statistics: Ascertaining Social Fact in Midcentury China and the Soviet Union
(/isis/citation/CBB399530810/)
Chapter
Pogliano, Claudio;
(2001)
Images and Practice of Science in Post-War Italy
(/isis/citation/CBB000102132/)
Article
David Bates;
(2020)
The Political Theology of Entropy: A Katechon for the Cybernetic Age
(/isis/citation/CBB798000079/)
Article
Nalewajski, Roman;
(2014)
Entropic Concepts in Electronic Structure Theory
(/isis/citation/CBB001321117/)
Article
Baker, Kevin T.;
(2017)
Simulation and “Seduction” at the Policy Interface
(/isis/citation/CBB450364367/)
Article
Daniel A. Crane;
(Winter 2019)
A Premature Postmortem on the Chicago School of Antitrust
(/isis/citation/CBB064762036/)
Book
Alberto Alesina;
Giavazzi, Francesco;
Carlo A Favero;
(2019)
Austerity: When it works and when it doesn't
(/isis/citation/CBB297004661/)
Be the first to comment!