Article ID: CBB000933672

Why Were Matrix Mechanics and Wave Mechanics Considered Equivalent? (2008)

unapi

A recent rethinking of the early history of Quantum Mechanics deemed the late 1920s agreement on the equivalence of Matrix Mechanics and Wave Mechanics, prompted by Schrödinger's 1926 proof, a myth. Schrödinger supposedly failed to prove isomorphism, or even a weaker equivalence (Schrödinger-equivalence) of the mathematical structures of the two theories; developments in the early 1930s, especially the work of mathematician von Neumann provided sound proof of mathematical equivalence. The alleged agreement about the Copenhagen Interpretation, predicated to a large extent on this equivalence, was deemed a myth as well. In response, I argue that Schrödinger's proof concerned primarily a domain-specific ontological equivalence, rather than the isomorphism or a weaker mathematical equivalence. It stemmed initially from the agreement of the eigenvalues of Wave Mechanics and energy-states of Bohr's Model that was discovered and published by Schrödinger in his first and second communications of 1926. Schrödinger demonstrated in this proof that the laws of motion arrived at by the method of Matrix Mechanics are satisfied by assigning the auxiliary role to eigenfunctions in the derivation of matrices (while he only outlined the reversed derivation of eigenfunctions from Matrix Mechanics, which was necessary for the proof of both isomorphism and Schrödinger-equivalence of the two theories). This result was intended to demonstrate the domain-specific ontological equivalence of Matrix Mechanics and Wave Mechanics, with respect to the domain of Bohr's atom. And although the mathematical equivalence of the theories did not seem out of the reach of existing theories and methods, Schrödinger never intended to fully explore such a possibility in his proof paper. In a further development of Quantum Mechanics, Bohr's complementarity and Copenhagen Interpretation captured a more substantial convergence of the subsequently revised (in light of the experimental results) Wave and Matrix Mechanics. I argue that both the equivalence and Copenhagen Interpretation can be deemed myths if one predicates the philosophical and historical analysis on a narrow model of physical theory which disregards its historical context, and focuses exclusively on its formal aspects and the exploration of the logical models supposedly implicit in it.

...More
Citation URI
https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB000933672/

Similar Citations

Article Bacciagaluppi, Guido; Crull, Elise; (2009)
Heisenberg (and Schrödinger, and Pauli) on Hidden Variables (/isis/citation/CBB000933686/)

Article Mawhin, Jean; Ronveaux, André; (2010)
Schrödinger and Dirac Equations for the Hydrogen Atom, and Laguerre Polynomials (/isis/citation/CBB001022003/)

Article Hilgevoord, Jan; (2005)
Time in Quantum Mechanics: A Story of Confusion (/isis/citation/CBB000501568/)

Book Jennifer Burwell; (2018)
Quantum Language and the Migration of Scientific Concepts (/isis/citation/CBB682085795/)

Article Joas, Christian; Lehner, Christoph; (2009)
The Classical Roots of Wave Mechanics: Schrödinger's Transformations of the Optical-Mechanical Analogy (/isis/citation/CBB000933683/)

Article D'Agostino, Salvo; (2009)
Il ‘gatto’ di Schroedinger in una lettura del testo originale del celebre saggio (/isis/citation/CBB314642805/)

Book Parkinson, Gavin; (2008)
Surrealism, Art, and Modern Science Relativity, Quantum Mechanics, Epistemology (/isis/citation/CBB001251160/)

Thesis Diamond, Ethel; (2006)
The Role of Philosophy in the Conceptual Development of Quantum Physics (/isis/citation/CBB001560852/)

Book Martins, Roberto A.; Boido, Guillermo; Rodríguez, Victor; (2006)
Física: Estudos Filosóficos e Históricos (/isis/citation/CBB000820179/)

Book David Kaiser; Alan Lightman; (2020)
Quantum Legacies: Dispatches from an Uncertain World (/isis/citation/CBB385682968/)

Article Rigden, John S.; Stuewer, Roger H.; (2012)
Understanding of Quantum Mechanics Eludes Physicists for Eighty-Six Years (/isis/citation/CBB001221642/)

Chapter Valia Allori; (2009)
La storia del gatto che era sia morto che vivo (/isis/citation/CBB919785743/)

Article Allori, Valia; Goldstein, Sheldon; Tumulka, Roderich; Zanghì, Nino; (2011)
Many Worlds and Schrödinger's First Quantum Theory (/isis/citation/CBB001230042/)

Article Enric Pérez Canals; Gonzalo Gimeno; Mercedes Xipell Gómez del Moral; Marià Baig i Aleu; (2020)
La mecánica ondulatoria llega a España: Schrödinger en la Universidad Internacional de Santander, agosto de 1934 (/isis/citation/CBB717742451/)

Article Joas, Christian; Katzir, Shaul; (2011)
Analogy, Extension, and Novelty: Young Schrödinger on Electric Phenomena in Solids (/isis/citation/CBB001024241/)

Article D'Agostino, Salvo; (2004)
The Bild Conception of Physical Theory: Helmholtz, Hertz, and Schrödinger (/isis/citation/CBB000641781/)

Book Gumbrecht, Hans Ulrich; (2011)
What Is Life? The Intellectual Pertinence of Erwin Schrödinger (/isis/citation/CBB001231937/)

Authors & Contributors
Joas, Christian
Allori, Valia
Moral, Mercedes Xipell Gómez del
Burwell, Jennifer
Gimeno, Gonzalo
D'Agostino, Salvo
Concepts
Physics
Quantum mechanics
Philosophy of science
Theoretical physics
Mechanics
Epistemology
Time Periods
20th century, early
20th century
21st century
19th century
Places
Spain
Paris (France)
Comments

Be the first to comment!

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}

Log in or register to comment