IsisCB Explore

Article ID: CBB000932753

Material Rhetoric: Spreading Stones and Showing Bones in the Study of Prehistory (2009)

Reybrouck, David Van (Author)
Bont, Raf de (Author)
Rock, Jan (Author)

Science in Context
Volume: 22
Pages: 195--216

Outside Links

WorldCat

Google Scholar

JSTOR

Academia.edu

Human paleontology Physical anthropology Human evolution 19th century 20th century, early Rutot, Aimé Fraipont, Julien

Since the linguistic turn, the role of rhetoric in the circulation and the popular representation of knowledge has been widely accepted in science studies. This article aims to analyze not a textual form of scientific rhetoric, but the crucial role of materiality in scientific debates. It introduces the concept of material rhetoric to understand the promotional regimes in which material objects play an essential argumentative role. It analyzes the phenomenon by looking at two students of prehistory from nineteenth-century Belgium. In the study of human prehistory and evolution, material data are either fairly abundant stone tools or very scarce fossil bones. These two types of material data stand for two different strategies in material rhetoric. In this article, the first strategy is exemplified by Aimé Rutot, who gathered great masses of eoliths (crudely chipped stones which he believed to be prehistoric tools). The second strategy is typified by the example of Julien Fraipont, who based his scientific career on only two Neanderthal skeletons. Rutot sent his artifacts to a very wide audience, while Fraipont showed his skeletons to only a few selected scholars. Unlike Rutot, however, Fraipont was able to monitor his audience's interpretation of the finds by means of personal contacts. What an archaeologist gains in reach, he or she apparently loses in control. In this article we argue that only those scholars who find the right balance between the extremes of reach and control will prove to be successful.

...More

Description On the attempt to understand human prehistory and evolution through investigation of stone tools or bones. Case studies of Julien Fraipont and Aimé Rutot.

Citation URI

https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB000932753/

Citations Indexes

Similar Citations

Book Schmalzer, Sigrid; (2008)
The People's Peking Man: Popular Science and Human Identity in Twentieth-Century China (/isis/citation/CBB000970011/)

Book Walker, Alan; Shipman, Pat; (2005)
The Ape in the Tree: An Intellectual and Natural History of Proconsul (/isis/citation/CBB000610265/)

Article Kjærgaard, Peter C.; (2014)
Inventing Homo gardarensis: Prestige, Pressure, and Human Evolution in Interwar Scandinavia (/isis/citation/CBB001420413/)

Article Manias, Chris; (2015)
The Problematic Construction of “Palaeolithic Man”: The Old Stone Age and the Difficulties of the Comparative Method, 1859--1914 (/isis/citation/CBB001422413/)

Article Catalá Gorgues, Jesús I.; (2012)
La polémica sobre el hombre terciario y su expresión en la valencia de comienzos del siglo XX (/isis/citation/CBB001450427/)

Article Amy Way; (2021)
Natural selection and the ‘antiquity of man’: Intellectual impacts in the Australian colonies (/isis/citation/CBB758799279/)

Article Delisle, Richard G.; (2012)
Welcome to the Twilight Zone: A Forgotten Early Phase of Human Evolutionary Studies (/isis/citation/CBB001210165/)

Book Gundling, Tom; (2005)
First In Line: Tracing Our Ape Ancestry (/isis/citation/CBB000651133/)

Article Podgorny, Irina; (2005)
Bones and Devices in the Constitution of Paleontology in Argentina at the End of the Nineteenth Century (/isis/citation/CBB000651660/)

Article Catalá-Gorgues, Jesús I.; (2010)
Notícies i idees sobre l'origen, antiguitat i evolució de l'home a la revista Ibérica (/isis/citation/CBB001021872/)

Article Sommer, Marianne; (2005)
Ancient Hunters and Their Modern Representatives: William Sollas's (1849--1936) Anthropology from Disappointed Bridge to Trunkless Tree and the Instrumentalisation of Racial Conflict (/isis/citation/CBB000550956/)

Book Preuss, Dirk; Hossfeld, Uwe; Breidbach, Olaf; (2006)
Anthropologie nach Haeckel (/isis/citation/CBB000774412/)

Chapter Tobias, Phillip V.; (2008)
Raymond Arthur Dart: The Man Who Unwillingly Ushered in a Revolution in the Evolution of Humankind (/isis/citation/CBB000960092/)

Chapter Backenköhler, Dirk; (2009)
Alles nur “Träume eines Mittagsschläfchens”? Darwins Evolutionstheorie und die Entstehung der biologischen Anthropologie im deutschsprachigen Raum (1860--1875) (/isis/citation/CBB001035237/)

Article Eddy, Matthew D.; (2011)
The Prehistoric Mind as a Historical Artefact (/isis/citation/CBB001022765/)

Article Paige Madison; (2020)
Characterized by Darkness: Reconsidering the Origins of the Brutish Neanderthal (/isis/citation/CBB746767437/)

Article Bauduer, Frédéric; (2008)
Histoire de l'anthropologie biologique de la population basque: De l'empirisme à la génétique moléculaire (/isis/citation/CBB000933242/)

Article Pettitt, Paul B.; White, Mark J.; (2011)
Cave Men: Stone Tools, Victorian Science, and the “Primitive Mind” of Deep Time (/isis/citation/CBB001022767/)

Article Sánchez Arteaga, Juan Manuel; (2008)
La biología humana como ideología: el racismo biológico y las estructuras simbólicas de dominación racial a fines del siglo XIX (/isis/citation/CBB000933626/)

Article Aviles-Galan, Miguel Angel; (2010)
Measuring Skulls: Race and Science in Vicente Riva Palacio's México a través de los Siglos (/isis/citation/CBB001030951/)

Comments

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}