Jean-Baptiste de Lamarck (1744--1829). A Dispute on the Mechanism of Evolution on the Bicentenary of the Publication of “Philosophie Zoologique” (1809) (2009)
Bednarczyk, Andrzej (Author)
Kwartalnik Historii Nauki i Techniki
Volume: 54, no. 3-4
Issue: 3 - 4
Pages: 31-98
Edition Details: [Translated title.] In Polish.
Language: Polish
The author of the paper has made an attempt to prove that a teleological interpretation of Lamarck's theory is false. It is unwarranted to attribute to Lamarck the idea that a living organism has an internal tendency to complicate its organization and to improve its mode of functioning; such a concept is not confirmed by existing textual evidence, and it is also in direct conflict with Lamarck's undisputed mechanicism. The proof presented in the paper begins with an outline of the history of this false interpretation, including the opinions of Charles Lyell and Charles Darwin. As the tendency is ascribed also to nature itself, the next phase of the proof has involved reconstructing the fully ateleological notion of nature to which Lamarck subscribed. Supposed evidence for the tendency is said to be provided by the existence of a series in which the organization of a living body grows from the simplest to the most complex. That is why the author of the current paper has analysed the concept of 'série animale' used by Lamarck in some detail, in order to demonstrate that it is typological in character, and has nothing to do with the tendency that is allegedly inherent in the nature of an organism. Also presented in the paper, in connection with the construction of the series, is the problem of spontaneous generation, which was made complicated by Lamarck. Finally, the very notion of tendency is analysed and confronted with Lamarck's text; the latter in fact does not contain any explanations that would be teleological in the strict sense of the word. The analysis has enabled the author of the current paper to conduct an exegesis of the fragment of Lamarck's text which might give grounds to it being construed in terms of an explanation resorting to the notion of tendency, and possible interpretations of that fragment have been presented. The paper ends with a description of the mechanism which, according to Lamarck, is responsible for the rise in complexity of an organism that has the nature of a machine; such a mechanism leaves no place for any tendency to be in operation.
...MoreDescription Attempts to show that a teleological interpretation of Lamarck's theory is false.
Similar Citations
Article
Moreno, Juan;
(2009)
Lamarck necesita a Darwin: la búsqueda de intención en el estudio de la evolución y de la historia
(/isis/citation/CBB001020976/)
Article
Jessica Riskin;
(2020)
Biology’s mistress, a brief history
(/isis/citation/CBB880456753/)
Article
Ricardo Noguera-Solano;
Juan Manuel Rodríguez-Caso;
Rosaura Ruiz-Gutiérrez;
(2021)
The Evolutionary Thought of Jean-Baptiste Lamarck
(/isis/citation/CBB508803217/)
Article
Andrés Galera;
(2017)
The Impact of Lamarck’s Theory of Evolution Before Darwin’s Theory
(/isis/citation/CBB907079027/)
Book
(1995)
Lamarck e il Lamarckismo: Atti del Convegno, Napoli, 1-3 dicembre 1988
(/isis/citation/CBB000070251/)
Chapter
Burkhardt, Richard W., Jr.;
(2011)
Lamarck, Cuvier, and Darwin on Animal Behavior and Acquired Characters
(/isis/citation/CBB001500083/)
Article
Egerton, Frank N.;
(1976)
Darwin's early reading of Lamarck
(/isis/citation/CBB000012685/)
Article
Pereira Martins, Lilian Al-Chueyr;
(2013)
Lamarck e a progressão da escala animal
(/isis/citation/CBB001214028/)
Article
Broberg, Gunnar;
(1988)
Larmarckismen i Sverige. (Lamarckism in Sweden)
(/isis/citation/CBB000051796/)
Book
Burkhardt, Richard W., Jr.;
(1995)
The spirit of system: Lamarck and evolutionary biology. Now with “Lamarck in 1995”
(/isis/citation/CBB000071461/)
Article
Gershenowitz, Harry;
(1980)
Napoleon and Lamarck
(/isis/citation/CBB000011277/)
Book
Gillott, David;
(2015)
Samuel Butler against the Professionals: Rethinking Lamarckism 1860-1900
(/isis/citation/CBB001551952/)
Article
(1979)
Les néo-Lamarckiens français
(/isis/citation/CBB000000496/)
Book
Corsi, Pietro;
(1988)
The age of Lamarck: Evolutionary theories in France, 1790-1830. Revised and updated. Translated by Jonathan Mandelbaum
(/isis/citation/CBB000029840/)
Article
Sheets-Johnstone, Maxine;
(1982)
Why Lamarck did not discover the principle of natural selection
(/isis/citation/CBB000023443/)
Book
Burkhardt, Richard W.;
(1977)
The spirit of system: Lamarck and evolutionary biology
(/isis/citation/CBB000022628/)
Chapter
Corsi, Pietro;
(2011)
Jean-Baptiste Lamarck: from Myth to History
(/isis/citation/CBB001500081/)
Book
Grimoult, Cédric;
(2002)
Sur les traces des grands évolutionnistes
(/isis/citation/CBB000600518/)
Book
Gissis, Snait B.;
Jablonka, Eva;
(2011)
Transformations of Lamarckism: From Subtle Fluids to Molecular Biology
(/isis/citation/CBB001500079/)
Article
Caponi, Gustavo;
(2011)
Los taxones como tipos: Buffon, Cuvier y Lamarck
(/isis/citation/CBB001420506/)
Be the first to comment!