The infamous Piltdown hoax offers an excellent opportunity to study how a figure that straddled the human---animal boundary (both figuratively in its positioning as a "missing link," and literally given its post-hoax status as a modern human skull and a modern orangutan jaw) was made to fit dichotomous understandings of it. The process of making this figure human reveals how scientific claims in the disputed border zone between humans and non-human animals are shaped by the cultural themes upon which the division stands. Nationalism, race and species classification became enmeshed in the efforts to lead Piltdown from its liminal position to more conceptually stable ground. The result was a stretching of human-ness, that brought Piltdown closer to us whilst modern-day "savages" were moved further away. The paper's theoretical framework shifts Gieryn's boundary-work model from an ontology of culture to an ontology of nature. Transplanting Gieryn's model in this way is useful not only because of the parallels specifically between the science---culture and human---animal boundaries, but also as it serves as a reminder of the strong relationship between the categorization of the social and natural worlds.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Jan Surman;
(2022)
Julian Ochorowicz's experiments with Eusapia Palladino 1894: The temporality of mass media and the crisis of local credibility
(/isis/citation/CBB345353036/)
Article
Goulden, Murray;
(2007)
Bringing Bones to Life: How Science Made Piltdown Man Human
(/isis/citation/CBB000831461/)
Book
Cain, Joe;
(2004)
Exploring the Borderlands: Documents of the Committee on Common Problems of Genetics, Paleontology, and Systematics, 1943--1944
(/isis/citation/CBB000742073/)
Article
Daniel Gethmann;
(2020)
Levels of communication: The talking horse experiments
(/isis/citation/CBB085423128/)
Article
Pelayo, F.;
(2007)
La evolución humana y su difusión en España en el marco de la JAE (1907--1939)
(/isis/citation/CBB000831518/)
Article
Kjærgaard, Peter C.;
(2012)
The Missing Links Expeditions---Or How the Peking Man Was Not Found
(/isis/citation/CBB001251540/)
Book
Fletcher, Ronald;
(1991)
Science, Ideology, and the Media: The Cyril Burt Scandal
(/isis/citation/CBB001422097/)
Book
Sokal, Alan D.;
(2008)
Beyond the Hoax: Science, Philosophy, and Culture
(/isis/citation/CBB000831305/)
Book
Walsh, Lynda;
(2006)
Sins against Science: The Scientific Media Hoaxes of Poe, Twain, and Others
(/isis/citation/CBB000931055/)
Article
Leahey, Erin;
Reikowsky, Ryan C.;
(2008)
Research Specialization and Collaboration Patterns in Sociology
(/isis/citation/CBB000953503/)
Article
Elizabeth Frances Caldwell;
(2017)
Quackademia? Mass-Media Delegitimation of Homeopathy Education
(/isis/citation/CBB422293911/)
Article
Lambert, Kevin;
(2006)
Fuller's Folly, Kuhnian Paradigms, and Intelligent Design
(/isis/citation/CBB000780208/)
Article
R. Bruce Mcmillan;
(2022)
Albert C. Koch’s Missourium and the Debate over the Contemporaneity of Humans and the Pleistocene Megafauna of North America
(/isis/citation/CBB483731737/)
Article
Elizabeth D. Jones;
(2019)
Assumptions of Authority: The Story of Sue the T-Rex and Controversy Over Access to Fossils
(/isis/citation/CBB334696047/)
Article
Tj Gundling;
(2020)
Ineluctably Us: Early Hominid Discoveries, Mass Media, and the Reification of Human Ancestors
(/isis/citation/CBB255600939/)
Article
R. Bruce Mcmillan;
(2023)
Albert Koch’s Hydrarchos: A Hoax or A Bona Fide Collection of Bones
(/isis/citation/CBB354774746/)
Book
Ellinor Schweighöfer;
(2018)
Vom Neandertal nach Afrika: Der Streit um den Ursprung der Menschheit im 19. und 20. Jahrhundert
(/isis/citation/CBB361986371/)
Article
Podgorny, Irina;
(2005)
Bones and Devices in the Constitution of Paleontology in Argentina at the End of the Nineteenth Century
(/isis/citation/CBB000651660/)
Article
Catalá Gorgues, Jesús I.;
(2013)
Miquel Crusafont, George Simpson y la internacionalización de los estudios de paleontología evolutiva en España
(/isis/citation/CBB001213576/)
Article
Catalá Gorgues, Jesús I.;
(2011)
¿Absolutamente sin cuidado?: Juan Vilanova y la polémica sobre el Hombre terciario
(/isis/citation/CBB001450414/)
Be the first to comment!