Truth, Trust, and Confidence in Surgery, 1890--1910: Patient Autonomy, Communication, and Consent (2009)
During the late nineteenth century, there was a dramatic rise in the number of surgical procedures that doctors were prepared to attempt. This article discusses why there was also a rise in the number of people who were prepared to submit to all of these operations. Contrary to popular assumptions, many nineteenth- century patients did not lack effective autonomy. Their consent to surgery could not be taken for granted, especially as surgery was expensive compared with many other forms of treatment. Persuading patients that surgery could help them was an active process, and patients and their friends were often provided with pertinent information, especially in cases in which the doctors themselves had doubts about an operation. Faith in the theoretical possibility of safe surgery may have been just as important in contributing to doctors' increased willingness to operate as any improvement in practical results. A key factor in the rising popularity of surgery with both doctors and patients was not so much better surgical results as it was confidence in the possibility of better surgical results and the ways in which this confidence was communicated from doctors to patients.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Dodier, Nicolas;
Barbot, Janine;
(2008)
Autonomy and Objectivity as Political Operators in the Medical World: Twenty Years of Public Controversy about AIDS Treatments in France
(/isis/citation/CBB000831754/)
Article
Thomas Schlich;
(2020)
No Time for Statistics: Joseph Lister's Antisepsis and Types of Knowledge in Nineteenth-Century British Surgery
(/isis/citation/CBB250007062/)
Article
Wallis, Jennifer;
(2013)
The Bones of the Insane
(/isis/citation/CBB001320330/)
Article
Hock, Lisabeth;
(2011)
Women and Melancholy in Nineteenth-Century German Psychiatry
(/isis/citation/CBB001232203/)
Article
Brock, Claire;
(2013)
Risk, Responsibility and Surgery in the 1890s and Early 1900s
(/isis/citation/CBB001320593/)
Article
Kragh, Jesper Vaczy;
(2010)
Malaria Fever Therapy for General Paralysis of the Insane in Denmark
(/isis/citation/CBB001232235/)
Thesis
Carpenter, D T;
(cited 2010)
Above All a Patient Should Never Be Terrified: An Examination of Mental Health Care and Treatment in Hampshire 1845--1914
(/isis/citation/CBB001567243/)
Article
Laws, Jennifer;
(2010)
Crackpots and Basket-Cases: A History of Therapeutic Work and Occupation
(/isis/citation/CBB001035606/)
Article
Hunting, Penelope;
(2012)
Charles Dickens (1812--70): “The longer I live the more I doubt the doctors”
(/isis/citation/CBB001200788/)
Article
Bonnichon, Philippe;
Charbit, Lionel;
Proye, Charles;
(2006)
Histoire de la chirurgie des glandes parathyroïdes
(/isis/citation/CBB000931802/)
Article
Tomoko Komagamine;
Norito Kokubun;
Koichi Hirata;
(2020)
Battey’s operation as a treatment for hysteria: a review of a series of cases in the nineteenth century
(/isis/citation/CBB166598493/)
Article
Degeling, Chris;
(2009)
Fractured Hips: Surgical Authority, Futility and Innovation in Nineteenth Century Medicine
(/isis/citation/CBB000932661/)
Article
Carol, Anne;
(2008)
Une sanglante audace: les amputations du col de l'utérus au début du XIXe siècle en France
(/isis/citation/CBB000931582/)
Article
Chettiar, Teri;
(2012)
“Looking as Little Like Patients as Persons Well Could”: Hypnotism, Medicine and the Problem of the Suggestible Subject in Late Nineteenth-Century Britain
(/isis/citation/CBB001250962/)
Chapter
Coleborne, Catharine;
(2009)
Challenging Institutional Hegemony: Family Visitors to Hospitals for the Insane in Australia and New Zealand, 1880s--1910s
(/isis/citation/CBB001031545/)
Article
Lei, Sean Hsiang-lin;
(2003)
Fuzheren de yisheng yu youxinyang de binren: Zhongxiyi lunzheng yu yibinguanxi zai Mingguo shiqi de zhuangbian
(/isis/citation/CBB000350225/)
Article
Huisman, Frank;
(2002)
Patientenbeelden in een moderniserende samenleving: Nederland, 1880-1920
(/isis/citation/CBB000770561/)
Article
Worboys, Michael;
(2013)
Joseph Lister and the Performance of Antiseptic Surgery
(/isis/citation/CBB001320253/)
Article
Crowther, M. Anne;
(2013)
Lister at Home and Abroad: A Continuing Legacy
(/isis/citation/CBB001320258/)
Article
Gainty, Caitjan;
(2012)
“Going after the High-Brows”: Frank Gilbreth and the Surgical Subject, 1912--1917
(/isis/citation/CBB001320018/)
Be the first to comment!