Von der Dissoziation zum System. Das Konzept des Unbewussten als Abkömmling des Reflexparadigmas in der Theorie Freuds (2009)
Janssen, Sandra (Author)
Berichte zur Wissenschaftsgeschichte
Volume: 32
Pages: 36--52
Edition Details: Part of a special issue: The Circulation of Reflexes in Brain Research, Art and Technology
Language: German
From Dissociation to System: The Concept of the Unconscious as a Descendant of the Reflex Paradigm in Freud. The paper tries to situate Freud's theory historically by referring it to a paradigm of psychological theory that Marcel Gauchet describes as the Golden Age of psychophysics and reflex theory, and that he situates between 1870 and 1900. I will show that until 1900 Freud thinks, in fact, in categories that correspond to this type of thought. His texts On the Psychical Mechanism of Hysterical Phenomena (1893, with Josef Breuer) and A Project for a Scientific Psychology (1895) still follow the conception of a psychological subject on the basis of the stimulus and response model, which can be found in numerous contemporaneous authors. In this model, the psyche is just a place of transit open to the exterior, and its unity can only be a sum of elements of consciousness having a physiological substrate. Nevertheless, Freud's early texts - although appertaining to the reflex paradigm - already contain elements that serve to construct another basic model of the psychic apparatus, which is finally introduced by The Interpretation of Dreams. Those new elements are the separation between interior and exterior, the introduction of endogenous energy, which is linked to the importance of emotions instead of sensations, and the problem of the adaptation to outer reality that results from it. Nevertheless, once more Freud is not the only theorist in whose thought the new paradigm can be found; I again refer his new premises to other contemporary psychologists. The question that arises from Freud's passage from one paradigm to another is how he handles the continuity of his own thought. I describe the difficult compromise between contradictory concepts he finds in his Project for a Scientific Psychology; but certain concepts that derive from the reflex paradigm subsist even during the later development of psychoanalysis. This is especially the case for the concept of the unconscious itself: As I argue, this concept originates in the reflex paradigm, and, in contrast to contemporary psychology, Freud only maintains it longer than other authors do.
...MoreArticle Wübben, Yvonne; Vöhringer, Margarete (2009) Reflexe in Hirnforschung, Kunst und Technik. Einleitende Bemerkungen. Berichte zur Wissenschaftsgeschichte (p. 7).
Similar Citations
Article
Wübben, Yvonne;
(2010)
Transhumane Physiologie. Bilder und Praktiken des Reflexes (Thomas Willis, Robert Whytt, Marshall Hall)
(/isis/citation/CBB000932602/)
Article
Robinson, David K.;
(2010)
Gustav Fechner: 150 Years of Elemente der Psychophysik
(/isis/citation/CBB001033706/)
Article
Pind, Jörgen L.;
(2009)
A Tale of Two Psychologies: The Høffding-Lehmann Controversy and the Establishment of Experimental Psychology at the University of Copenhagen
(/isis/citation/CBB000930199/)
Article
Wegener, Mai;
(2009)
Der psychophysische Parallelismus. Zu einer Diskursfigur im Feld der wissenschaftlichen Umbrüche des ausgehenden 19. Jahrhunderts
(/isis/citation/CBB000933303/)
Article
Thomas Fuchs;
(2022)
Die Entwicklung des Menschen: Wilhelm Wundts (1832–1920) voluntaristische Anthropologie
(/isis/citation/CBB437342033/)
Article
Richard Staley;
(2021)
Sensory studies, or when physics was psychophysics: Ernst Mach and physics between physiology and psychology, 1860–71
(/isis/citation/CBB206423864/)
Article
Masin, Sergio Cesare;
Zudini, Verena;
Antonelli, Mauro;
(2009)
Early Alternative Derivations of Fechner's Law
(/isis/citation/CBB000930200/)
Article
Meischner-Metge, Anneros;
(2010)
Gustav Theodor Fechner: Life and Work in the Mirror of His Diary
(/isis/citation/CBB001033707/)
Book
David J. Murray;
Stephen W. Link;
(2020)
The Creation of Scientific Psychology
(/isis/citation/CBB845455295/)
Article
Joshua Bauchner;
(2021)
Fechner on a Walk: Everyday Investigations of the Mind-Body Relationship
(/isis/citation/CBB085736438/)
Article
Robinson, David K.;
(2010)
Fechner's “Inner Psychophysics”
(/isis/citation/CBB001033708/)
Article
Ratnapalan, L. M.;
Reggio, David;
(2012)
Erwin Straus and the Pathic
(/isis/citation/CBB001251913/)
Book
Canguilhem, Georges;
(2008)
Die Herausbildung des Reflexbegriffs im 17. und 18. Jahrhundert
(/isis/citation/CBB001022089/)
Book
Susan Sugarman;
(2016)
What Freud Really Meant: A Chronological Reconstruction of His Theory of the Mind
(/isis/citation/CBB231005528/)
Book
George Makari;
(2021)
Of Fear and Strangers: A History of Xenophobia
(/isis/citation/CBB975774620/)
Article
Cotti, Patricia;
(2008)
Freud and History before 1905: From Defending to Questioning the Theory of a Glorious Past
(/isis/citation/CBB001035698/)
Book
Lehrer, Ronald;
(1995)
Nietzsche's presence in Freud's life and thought: On the origins of a psychology of dynamic unconscious mental functioning
(/isis/citation/CBB000059647/)
Article
Esterson, Allen;
(2002)
Misconceptions about Freud's Seduction Theory: A Comment on Gleaves and Hernandez (1999)
(/isis/citation/CBB000201135/)
Book
Hagner, Michael;
(1999)
Ecce Cortex: Beiträge zur Geschichte des modernen Gehirns
(/isis/citation/CBB000110603/)
Book
Haynal, André;
Roazen, Paul;
Falzeder, Ernst;
(2005)
Dans les secrets de la psychanalyse et de son histoire
(/isis/citation/CBB000772833/)
Be the first to comment!