IsisCB Explore

Article ID: CBB000931154

Why Did Kant Reject Physiological Explanations in His Anthropology? (2008)

Studies in History and Philosophy of Science
Volume: 39
Pages: 495--505

Publication Date: 2008
Edition Details: Part of a special issue: “Kantian Philosophy and the Human Sciences”
Language: English

Outside Links

WorldCat

Google Scholar

JSTOR

Academia.edu

One of Kant's central tenets concerning the human sciences is the claim that one need not, and should not, use a physiological vocabulary if one studies human cognitions, feelings, desires, and actions from the point of view of his `pragmatic' anthropology. The claim is well known, but the arguments Kant advances for it have not been closely discussed. I argue against misguided interpretations of the claim, and I present his actual reasons in favor of it. Contemporary critics of a `physiological anthropology' reject physiological explanations of mental states as more or less epistemologically dubious. Kant does not favor such ignorance claims---and this is for the good, since none of these claims was sufficiently justified at that time. Instead, he develops an original irrelevance thesis concerning the empirical knowledge of the physiological basis of the mind. His arguments for this claim derive from his original and, up to now, little understood criticism of a certain conception of pragmatic history, related to his anthropological insights concerning our ability to create new rules of action, the social dynamics of human action, and the relative inconstancy of human nature. The irrelevance thesis also changes his views of the goal and methodology of anthropology. Kant thereby argues for a distinctive approach in quest for a general `science of man'.

...More

Included in

Article Cohen, Alix A. (2008) Kantian Philosophy and the Human Sciences. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science (p. 459). unapi

Citation URI

https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB000931154/

Citations Indexes

Similar Citations

Article Gray, Sally Hatch; (2012)
Kant's Race Theory, Forster's Counter, and the Metaphysics of Color (/isis/citation/CBB001201887/)

Article Claus Beisbart; (2022)
What Is the Spatiotemporal Extension of the Universe? Underdetermination according to Kant’s First Antinomy and in Present-Day Cosmology (/isis/citation/CBB854889177/)

Article Cohen, Alix A.; (2008)
Kantian Philosophy and the Human Sciences (/isis/citation/CBB000931150/)

Article Schmidt, Claudia M.; (2008)
Kant's Transcendental and Empirical Psychology of Cognition (/isis/citation/CBB000931151/)

Book Catherine Wilson; (2022)
Kant and the Naturalistic Turn of 18th Century Philosophy (/isis/citation/CBB775333088/)

Article Frierson, Patrick; (2008)
Empirical Psychology, Common Sense, and Kant's Empirical Markers for Moral Responsibility (/isis/citation/CBB000931152/)

Book Waxman, Wayne; (2014)
Kant's Anatomy of the Intelligent Mind (/isis/citation/CBB001421736/)

Article Verena Lehmbrock; (2016)
Zur Geschichte einer Metakategorie: Das ‚Empirische‘ in der deutschen Ökonomischen Aufklärung und frühen Agrarwissenschaft um 1800 (/isis/citation/CBB380540897/)

Article Gaukroger, Stephen W.; Dalia Nassar; (2016)
Introduction: Kant and the Empirical Sciences (/isis/citation/CBB037609114/)

Article Andrew Cooper; (2017)
Kant and Experimental Philosophy (/isis/citation/CBB741692479/)

Book Anja Jauernig; (2021)
The World According to Kant: Appearances and Things in Themselves in Critical Idealism (/isis/citation/CBB780921269/)

Article Guyer, Paul; (2008)
The Psychology of Kant's Aesthetics (/isis/citation/CBB000931153/)

Book Stephen Gaukroger; (2016)
The Natural and the Human: Science and the Shaping of Modernity 1739-1841 (/isis/citation/CBB648985887/)

Thesis Zumbach, Clark E.; (1980)
The lawlessness of living things: Kant's conception of organismic activity (/isis/citation/CBB001563384/)

Book Löw, Reinhard; (1980)
Philosophie des Lebendigen: Der Begriff des Organischen bei Kant, sein Grund und seine Aktualität (/isis/citation/CBB000006070/)

Chapter Pirillo, Nestore; (1994)
Fisiologia, cosmologia, pragmatico: Prime note per uno studio intorno a Kant e l'antropologia (/isis/citation/CBB000052869/)

Chapter Marino, Luigi; (1994)
Soemmerring, Kant and the organ of the soul (/isis/citation/CBB000057042/)

Book Sutter, Alex; (1988)
Göttliche Maschinen: Die Automaten für Lebendiges bei Descartes, Leibniz, La Mettrie und Kant (/isis/citation/CBB000057274/)

Article Debru, Claude; (1980)
L'introduction du concept d'organisme dans la philosophie Kantienne, 1790-1803 (/isis/citation/CBB000012411/)

Book Cohen, Alix; (2014)
Kant's Lectures on Anthropology (/isis/citation/CBB001551074/)

Comments

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}