Schabas, Margaret L. (Author)
Studies in History and Philosophy of Science
Volume: 39
Pages: 161--169
Abstract Contemporary economists deem virtually every piece of reasoning and argumentation in economics a model, forgetting that there may well be other conceptual tools at hand. This article demonstrates that David Hume used thought experiments to make some remarkable breakthroughs in monetary economics, and that this resolves a longstanding debate about an apparent inconsistency in Hume, between the neutrality and non-neutrality of money. In the actual world, money is never neutral for Hume; only in thought experiments does a sudden growth in the money stock result in an identical and hence neutral increase in the price level. Thought experiments isolate tendencies but do not lend themselves to direct confirmation. Moreover, Hume's dislike for the French model builders, Melon and Quesnay, captures an important juncture in mid eighteenth-century economic discourse regarding the warranted level of abstraction and of idealization. Keywords: David Hume; Thought experiments; Economic models; Enlightenment science; History and methodology of economics; Monetary theory
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Bochove, Christiaan van;
(2014)
Seafarers and Shopkeepers: Credit in Eighteenth-Century Amsterdam
(/isis/citation/CBB001550447/)
Book
Rebecca L. Spang;
(2015)
Stuff and Money in the Time of the French Revolution
(/isis/citation/CBB591578350/)
Book
Jeffrey Sklansky;
(2017)
Sovereign of the Market: The Money Question in Early America
(/isis/citation/CBB762518399/)
Article
Ryan Walter;
(2019)
The Bullion Controversy and the History of Political Thought: Experience, Innovation and Theory
(/isis/citation/CBB945573337/)
Thesis
Deringer, William Peter;
(2012)
Calculated Values: The Politics and Epistemology of Economic Numbers in Britain, 1688--1738
(/isis/citation/CBB001567371/)
Chapter
Stephen Gaukroger;
(2014)
Empiricism as a Development of Experimental Natural Philosophy
(/isis/citation/CBB971325669/)
Article
Erbs, Laurent;
(2013)
Échelles et territoires du salaire en Moselle au tournant des années 1944--1948
(/isis/citation/CBB001510208/)
Article
Carroll Pursell;
(2011)
The American Patent Agency: The Embedded 'Lone Inventor' in American History
(/isis/citation/CBB562500065/)
Book
Graeber, David;
(2011)
Debt: The First 5,000 Years
(/isis/citation/CBB001421563/)
Article
Carey, Daniel;
(2013)
Locke's Species: Money and Philosophy in the 1690s
(/isis/citation/CBB001320283/)
Article
Le Maux, Laurent;
(2012)
The Banking School and the Law of Reflux in General
(/isis/citation/CBB001451817/)
Book
Robert Skidelsky;
(2018)
Money and government: The past and future of economics
(/isis/citation/CBB841092967/)
Article
Jonathan Levy;
(2017)
Capital as Process and the History of Capitalism
(/isis/citation/CBB508309992/)
Book
Kean Birch;
Fabian Muniesa;
(2020)
Assetization: Turning Things into Assets in Technoscientific Capitalism
(/isis/citation/CBB729464018/)
Article
Chilosi, David;
(2014)
Risky Institutions: Political Regimes and the Cost of Public Borrowing in Early Modern Italy
(/isis/citation/CBB001552997/)
Article
Francesca Trivellato;
(2016)
Between Usury and the “Spirit of Commerce”: Images of Jews and Credit from Montesquieu to the Debate on Emancipation in Eighteenth-Century France
(/isis/citation/CBB338564937/)
Article
Margócsy, Dániel;
(2013)
The Fuzzy Metrics of Money: The Finances of Travel and the Reception of Curiosities in Early Modern Europe
(/isis/citation/CBB001320284/)
Article
François Claveau;
Melissa Vergara Fernández;
(2015)
Epistemic Contributions of Models: Conditions for Propositional Learning
(/isis/citation/CBB935723283/)
Article
Pollock, Stephen;
(2013)
Econometrics: An Historical Guide for the Uninitiated
(/isis/citation/CBB001201233/)
Article
Le Gall, Philippe;
(2002)
Les représentations du monde et les pensées analogiques des économètres: un siècle de modélisation en perspective
(/isis/citation/CBB000751011/)
Be the first to comment!