vThe place of Heinrich Hertz's The principles of mechanics in the history of the philosophy of science is disputed. Here I critically assess positivist interpretations, concluding that they are inadequate. There is a group of commentators who seek to align Hertz with positivism, or with specific positivists such as Ernst Mach, who were enormously influential at the time. Max Jammer is prominent among this group, the most recent member of which is Joseph Kockelmans. I begin by discussing what Hertz and Mach had to say about one another, and I specify certain respects in which their views are indeed similar. I then go on to detail their differences, looking at Hertz's attitude to the atomic theory, to the mechanical world-view, to simplicity, to unobservables and metaphysics, and his objections to Newtonian forces. I conclude that the positivist interpretation of Hertz's mechanics significantly overplays its similarities to Mach's views. Keywords: Ernst Mach; Heinrich Hertz; Mechanics; Positivism; Atomism; Force; Metaphysics
...MoreDescription Reevaluates claims that Hertz's mechanics was aligned with Machean positivism.
Similar Citations
Book
Boudri, J. Christian;
(2002)
What Was Mechanical about Mechanics: The Concept of Force between Metaphysics and Mechanics from Newton to Lagrange
(/isis/citation/CBB000201308/)
Chapter
Massimo Ferrari;
(2018)
“Uno strenuo difensore” di Mach: John Bernhard Stallo
(/isis/citation/CBB213065857/)
Article
Joshua Eisenthal;
(2021)
Hertz's Mechanics and a unitary notion of force
(/isis/citation/CBB462268539/)
Thesis
Kochiras, Hylarie;
(2008)
Force, Matter, and Metaphysics in Newton's Natural Philosophy
(/isis/citation/CBB001561168/)
Article
Alemañ Berenguer, Rafael Andres;
(2008)
Geometría y física: de Hertz a Einstein
(/isis/citation/CBB000933114/)
Chapter
Gereon Wolters;
(2018)
Mach e la relatività: una storia infinita ambientata a HOPOSia?
(/isis/citation/CBB146853924/)
Article
Giovanelli, Marco;
(2013)
Erich Kretschmann as a Proto-Logical-Empiricist: Adventures and Misadventures of the Point-Coincidence Argument
(/isis/citation/CBB001213352/)
Book
Blackmore, John T.;
Itagaki, Ryoichi;
Tanaka, Setsuko;
(2009)
Ernst Mach's Influence Spreads
(/isis/citation/CBB001023228/)
Chapter
Paolo Parrini;
(2018)
Ernst Mach and the Disenchantment of Metaphysics
(/isis/citation/CBB153044104/)
Article
Palmerino, Carla Rita;
(2011)
The Isomorphism of Space, Time and Matter in Seventeenth-Century Natural Philosophy
(/isis/citation/CBB001220180/)
Article
Katherine Brading;
Marius Stan;
(2021)
How Physics Flew the Philosophers' Nest
(/isis/citation/CBB008141627/)
Chapter
Marco Buzzoni;
(2018)
Ernst Mach interprete di Pierre Duhem. Valore e limiti della sperimentazione mentale
(/isis/citation/CBB306281511/)
Chapter
Erik C. Banks;
(2018)
The Case for Mach's Neutral Monism
(/isis/citation/CBB571671358/)
Chapter
Luca Guidetti;
(2018)
Il problema dell'analogia in Ernst Mach
(/isis/citation/CBB358140394/)
Book
Pietro Gori;
(2018)
Ernst Mach: tra scienza e filosofia
(/isis/citation/CBB991429309/)
Article
Hamilton, Kelly Ann;
(2002)
Darstellungen in The Principles of Mechanics and the Tractatus: The Representation of Objects in Relation in Hertz and Wittgenstein
(/isis/citation/CBB000502650/)
Book
Blackmore, John T.;
(2009)
Ernst Mach's Philosophy---Pro and Con---with Contributions by Brentano, Carnap, Einstein, Husserl, Lenin, Mach, Planck, Popper, and Others
(/isis/citation/CBB001024109/)
Article
Guzzardi, Luca;
(2005)
Masse, moti nascosti, etere e spazio nella mechanica hertziana
(/isis/citation/CBB000701077/)
Chapter
Pojman, Paul;
(2010)
From Mach to Carnap: A Tale of Confusion
(/isis/citation/CBB001033544/)
Article
Feest, Uljana;
(2007)
Science and Experience/Science of Experience: Gestalt Psychology and the Anti-Metaphysical Project of the Aufbau
(/isis/citation/CBB000720290/)
Perspectives on Science
Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part B: Studies in History and Philosophy of Modern Physics
Physis: Rivista Internazionale di Storia della Scienza
Llull: Revista de la Sociedad Española de Historia de las Ciencias y de las Técnicas
Early Science and Medicine: A Journal for the Study of Science, Technology and Medicine in the Pre-modern Period
Be the first to comment!