Two inter-linked theses are defended in this paper. One is the Duhemian theme that a rigid distinction between physical and chemical properties cannot be upheld. Duhem maintained this view not because the latter are reducible to the former, but because if physics is to remain consistent with chemistry it must prove possible to expand it to accommodate new features, and a rigid distinction would be a barrier to this process. The second theme is that naturally occurring isotopic variants of water are in fact distinct substances, and naturally occurring samples of water are mixtures of these substances. For most practical purposes it is convenient to treat protium oxide, deuterium oxide, and so on, as the same chemical substance, but to insist on this as a matter of principle would stand in conflict with the first thesis. Keywords: Water; Isotopes; Pierre Duhem; Physical property; Chemical property
...MoreDescription Explores the view held by Duhem “that a rigid distinction between physical and chemical properties cannot be upheld.” (from the abstract)
Similar Citations
Chapter
Klein, Martin J.;
(1990)
Duhem on Gibbs
(/isis/citation/CBB000045181/)
Chapter
Eric R. Scerri;
(2020)
The Many Questions Raised by the Dual Concept of “Element”
(/isis/citation/CBB802086327/)
Article
Photis Dais;
(2021)
Impact of Gibbs’ and Duhem’s approaches to thermodynamics on the development of chemical thermodynamics
(/isis/citation/CBB022163007/)
Article
Moore, Carl E.;
Smolinski, Alfred von;
Jaselskis, Bruno;
(2002)
The Ostwald-Gibbs Correspondence: An Interesting Component in the History of The Energy Concept
(/isis/citation/CBB000740541/)
Article
Lavis, D. A.;
(2005)
Boltzmann and Gibbs: An Attempted Reconciliation
(/isis/citation/CBB000771639/)
Article
Brakel, Jaap van;
(2013)
František Wald's Empiricism
(/isis/citation/CBB001320765/)
Article
Kenichi Natsume;
(2022)
Abstractive and Hypothetical Methodologies of Energetics: Physical Sciences between Mechanics and Chemistry in Victorian Britain
(/isis/citation/CBB843016617/)
Article
Paul Needham;
(2017)
Was Duhem Justified in not Distinguishing Between Physical and Chemical Atomism?
(/isis/citation/CBB592640735/)
Article
Alan J. Rocke;
(2017)
The “Indifferent Hypothesis” Redux: The Dilemmas of Pierre Duhem
(/isis/citation/CBB088934725/)
Article
Bordoni, Stafano;
(2013)
Routes Towards an Abstract Thermodynamics in the Late Nineteenth Century
(/isis/citation/CBB001320791/)
Article
Needham, Paul;
(2004)
Mixture and Chemical Combination and Related Essays: A Response to Robert Deltete and Anastasios Brenner
(/isis/citation/CBB000502836/)
Article
Bensaude-Vincent, Bernadette;
(2014)
Philosophy of Chemistry or Philosophy with Chemistry?
(/isis/citation/CBB001421611/)
Article
Zwier, Karen R.;
(2011)
Dalton's Chemical Atoms versus Duhem's Chemical Equivalents
(/isis/citation/CBB001230050/)
Book
Duhem, Pierre;
(2002)
Mixture and Chemical Combination: And Related Essays
(/isis/citation/CBB000201354/)
Book
Maria Teresa Monti;
(2023)
L'azoto, il fosforo e la chimica nuova. Storie di luce e combustione (1774-1799)
(/isis/citation/CBB965333832/)
Article
Restrepo, Guillermo;
Villaveces, José L.;
(2011)
Chemistry, a lingua philosophica
(/isis/citation/CBB001024704/)
Book
Didier Kahn;
(2016)
Le Fixe et le volatil. Chimie et alchimie de Paracelse à Lavoisier: Chimie et alchimie, de Paracelse à Lavoiser
(/isis/citation/CBB224806526/)
Book
Henry Guerlac;
(1990)
Lavoisier--The Crucial Year: The Background and Origin of His First Experiments on Combustion in 1772
(/isis/citation/CBB794408481/)
Book
Corinna Guerra;
(2017)
Lavoisier e Parthenope. Contributo ad una storia della chimica nel Regno di Napoli
(/isis/citation/CBB584026958/)
Article
Gregory S. Girolami;
(2019)
A Book Collector’s View of the Periodic Table: Before Mendeleev.
(/isis/citation/CBB300228576/)
Be the first to comment!