Vesel, Matjaž (Author)
Filozofski Vestnik
Volume: 28, no. 1
Issue: 1
Pages: 19-40
Edition Details: [Translated title: The Paris condemnation of 1277, potenita dei absoluta, and the birth of modern science] In Slovenian.
Language: Slovenian
Still present in the historiography of medieval and early modern science is the thesis, originally formulated by P. Duhem and advocated today by E. Grant in a more moderate form, according to which the Paris condemnation of 219 propositions in 1277 entails an affirmation of potentia dei absoluta, which led to a criticism of Aristotelism and, consequently, to the birth of modern science. The author argues that this thesis can not stand the test of critical examination. The discussion about the dialectics of God's powers (potentia dei absoluta -- potentia dei ordinata) began a good half century before the condemnation, which, on the other hand, does not represent the decisive factor in promoting this distinction. By comparing the discussion on the plurality of worlds before and after the condemnation, it can be shown that Aristotle's understanding of the unity of our world was, from the theological perspective (what God might have done), in fact brought into question before the condemnation, but that before and after the condemnation nobody believed that there in fact exists more than one world. The critique of Aristotle is epistemologically limited to considerations par esbatement or secundum imaginationem: what God with his potentia dei absoluta might have done. On the basis of Galileo's reflection on the epistemological status of the concept of potentia dei absoluta, the difference between medieval and modern, i.e. Galilean, science can be shown. According to Galileo, the task of science is not to explore what God might have done, but what God actually did.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Blair, Ann;
(2008)
Disciplinary Distinctions before the “Two Cultures”
(/isis/citation/CBB001030485/)
Book
Osler, Margaret J.;
(2010)
Reconfiguring the World: Nature, God, and Human Understanding from the Middle Ages to Early Modern Europe
(/isis/citation/CBB001020917/)
Book
Stuckrad, Kocku von;
(2010)
Locations of Knowledge in Medieval and Early Modern Europe: Esoteric Discourse and Western Identities
(/isis/citation/CBB001201627/)
Book
Osler, Margaret J.;
(2000)
Rethinking the scientific revolution
(/isis/citation/CBB000110137/)
Book
Pietro Daniel Omodeo;
Volkhard Wels;
(2019)
Natural Knowledge and Aristotelianism at Early Modern Protestant Universities
(/isis/citation/CBB325233371/)
Article
Germana Ernst;
(2017)
"Maculae Galilei me perplexum habent". Campanella, le macchie solari e la tentazione pitagorica
(/isis/citation/CBB065561241/)
Book
Blum, Paul Richard;
(2012)
Studies on Early Modern Aristotelianism
(/isis/citation/CBB001201594/)
Book
Bakker, Paul J. J. M.;
de Boer, Sander W.;
Leijenhorst, Radboud;
(2012)
Psychology and the Other Disciplines: A Case of Cross-Disciplinary Interaction (1250--1750)
(/isis/citation/CBB001214000/)
Book
Knight, David M.;
(2015)
Voyaging in Strange Seas: The Great Revolution in Science
(/isis/citation/CBB001551963/)
Book
Galilei, Galileo;
Bucciantini, Massimo;
Camerota, Michele;
(2009)
Scienza e religione: scritti copernicani
(/isis/citation/CBB001250871/)
Book
Stephan Heilen;
(2020)
Konjunktionsprognostik in der Frühen Neuzeit. 1. Band: Die Antichrist-Prognose des Johannes von Lübeck
(/isis/citation/CBB238530105/)
Thesis
Johnston, Eric M.;
(2008)
The Role of Aristotelian Biology in Thomas Aquinas's Theology of Marriage
(/isis/citation/CBB001561249/)
Book
Mandrella, Isabelle;
(2002)
Das Isaak-Opfer: Historisch-Systematische Untersuchung zu Rationalität und Wandelbarkeit des Naturrechts in der Mittelalterlichen Lehre vom Natürlichen Gesetz
(/isis/citation/CBB000201469/)
Book
Goodich, Michael;
(2007)
Miracles and Wonders: The Development of the Concept of Miracle, 1150--1350. Church, Faith, and Culture in the Medieval West
(/isis/citation/CBB001020346/)
Book
Maria Sorokina;
(2021)
Les sphères, les astres et les théologiens: L’influence céleste entre science et foi dans les commentaires des Sentences (v. 1220 - v. 1340)
(/isis/citation/CBB416019954/)
Article
Nicola Polloni;
(2020)
Early Robert Grosseteste on Matter
(/isis/citation/CBB750708755/)
Book
Bailey, Michael David;
(2013)
Fearful Spirits, Reasoned Follies: The Boundaries of Superstition in Late Medieval Europe
(/isis/citation/CBB001201732/)
Thesis
Mohammad Sadegh Ansari;
(2020)
Pythagoras in Baghdad: Ṣafī Al-Dīn Al-Urmawī and the Science of Music in the Medieval Islamic World
(/isis/citation/CBB756844660/)
Article
Biswas, Arun Kumar;
(2011)
Science in the Path of Syncretism
(/isis/citation/CBB001024484/)
Book
Wünsch, Thomas;
(2006)
Religion und Magie in Ostmitteleuropa: Spielräume theologischer Normierungsprozesse in Spätmittelalter und Früher Neuzeit
(/isis/citation/CBB001020453/)
Be the first to comment!