Lies, Damn Lies, and Manchester's Recruiting Statistics: Degeneration as an “Urban Legend” in Victorian and Edwardian Britain (2008)
Heggie, Vanessa (Author)
Journal of the History of Medicine and Allied Sciences
Volume: 63
Pages: 178--216
Few historians have attempted to discuss British medicine, health and welfare policies, or the biological sciences around 1900 without due reference to the concept of degeneration. Most tie public concern with degeneration to a specific set of military recruiting figures, which stated that of 11,000 would-be volunteers in Manchester, 8,000 had to be turned away due to physical defects. Further, most histories point out that these figures had a direct influence on the formation of the Inter-Departmental Committee on Physical Deterioration in 1904. With its absolute denial of hereditary decline, the 1904 Report acts as a dénouement of degenerationist fears in Britain. No historian has sought to contextualize these recruiting figures: Where did they come from? How did Manchester react? What role did that city play in the subsequent 1904 Report? Far from being the epitome of urban decay, the 1904 Report repeatedly hails Manchester as a glowing example of innovative urban reform. This article contextualizes the recruiting figures and explores how Manchester had been tackling the three key problems of Physical Deterioration---diet, exercise, and alcohol---for thirty years prior to the 1904 Report. By discussing Manchester, a new understanding of degeneration is outlined; as slogan, rhetorical tool, and urban legend, degeneration was largely feminized and domesticated. Military/masculine problems such as the recruiting figures were the exception, not the rule.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Platt, Harold L.;
(2004)
“Clever Microbes”: Bacteriology and Sanitary Technology in Manchester and Chicago During the Progressive Age
Thesis
Wood, James Anthony;
(cited 2012)
Natural Guardians of the Race: Heredity, Hygiene, Alcohol, and Degeneration in Scottish Psychiatry, c. 1860--1920
Book
Apalak Das;
(2024)
Empire and Leprosy in Colonial Bengal
Article
Lawrence, Christopher;
(2009)
Degeneration under the Microscope at the fin se siècle
Article
James J Harris;
(2020)
H1N1 in the ‘A1 Empire’: Pandemic Influenza, Military Medicine, and the British Transition from War to Peace, 1918–1920
Article
Changboo Kang;
(2020)
Between Mars and Eros: British Army's Fight Against Venereal Disease during the First World War
Article
Perry, M.;
(2000)
Academic general practice in Manchester under the early National Health Service: A failed experiment in social medicine
Thesis
Hogarth, S J;
(cited 2010)
Reluctant Patients: Health, Sickness and the Embodiment of Plebeian Masculinity in Nineteenth-Century Britain. Evidence from Working Men's Autobiographies
Article
Anders Sevelsted;
(2019)
Degeneration, Protestantism, and Social Democracy: The Case of Alcoholism and “Illiberal” Policies and Practices in Denmark 1900–43
Book
Heather Ellis;
(2017)
Masculinity and Science in Britain, 1831–1918
Article
Withey, Alun;
(2013)
Shaving and Masculinity in Eighteenth-Century Britain
Book
Paul R. Deslandes;
(2021)
The Culture of Male Beauty in Britain: From the First Photographs to David Beckham
Book
Espinosa, Mariola;
(2009)
Epidemic Invasions: Yellow Fever and the Limits of Cuban Independence, 1878--1930
Book
Sarah Handley- Cousins;
(2019)
Bodies in blue: Disability in the Civil War north
Article
Andrew Flack;
(2022)
Dark Degenerations: Life, Light, and Transformation beneath the Earth, 1840–circa 1900
Book
Quinlan, Sean M.;
(2007)
The Great Nation in Decline: Sex, Modernity and Health Crises in Revolutionary France c. 1750--1850
Book
Villiers, J. C. de;
(2008)
Healers, Helpers and Hospitals
Book
Anderson, Warwick;
(2006)
Colonial Pathologies: American Tropical Medicine, Race, and Hygiene in the Phillipines
Article
Lord, Alexandra M.;
(2003)
Models of Masculinity: Sex Education, the United States Public Health Service, and the YMCA, 1919--1924
Book
Kidd, Alan J.;
Wyke, Terry;
(2016)
Manchester: Making the modern city
Annals of Science: The History of Science and Technology
Isis: International Review Devoted to the History of Science and Its Cultural Influences
Journal for Eighteenth-Century Studies
Journal of the History of Medicine and Allied Sciences
Korean Journal of Medical History
Be the first to comment!