The 19th-century story of Phineas Gage is much quoted in neuroscientific literature as the first recorded case in which personality change (from polite and sociable to psychopathic) occurred after damage to the brain. In this article I contest this interpretation. From a close examination of the story of Gage I have come to conclude that first of all there was nothing psychopathic in Gage's behavior and that changes in his life are more coherently explained by seeing them as his way of dealing with disfigurement that he suffered after the accident. This is not just a matter of reinterpreting a case. The way Gage has been presented and discussed in neuroscientific literature suggests that the new paradigm of neuroscientifically oriented psychiatry may lead to an erosion of clinical knowledge.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Stone, James;
(2000)
Transcranial Brain Injuries Caused by Metal Rods or Pipes over the Past 150 Years
(/isis/citation/CBB000111196/)
Book
Peiffer, Jürgen;
(2004)
Hirnforschung in Deutschland 1849 bis 1974: Briefe zur Entwicklung von Psychiatrie und Neurowissenschaften sowie zum Einfluss des politischen Umfeldes auf Wissenschafter
(/isis/citation/CBB001033126/)
Article
Josef Hlade;
(2021)
Reconsidering “Brain mythology”
(/isis/citation/CBB117316646/)
Article
Droz Mendelzweig, Marion;
(2010)
La plasticité cérébrale de Cajal à Kandel: cheminement d'une notion constitutive du sujet cérébral
(/isis/citation/CBB001034701/)
Book
Hagner, Michael;
(1999)
Ecce Cortex: Beiträge zur Geschichte des modernen Gehirns
(/isis/citation/CBB000110603/)
Book
Jacyna, L. S.;
(2000)
Lost Words: Narratives of Language and the Brain, 1825-1926
(/isis/citation/CBB000110678/)
Book
Frank W. Stahnisch;
(2020)
A New Field in Mind: A History of Interdisciplinarity in the Early Brain Sciences
(/isis/citation/CBB376085655/)
Article
Hampe, Michael;
(2007)
Achilles' Brain: Philosophical Notes on Trauma
(/isis/citation/CBB000773674/)
Article
Macmillan, Malcolm;
(2000)
Commemorating the 150th Anniversary of Phineas Gage's Accident
(/isis/citation/CBB000111172/)
Book
Bennett, M. R.;
Hacker, P. M. S.;
(2008)
History of Cognitive Neuroscience
(/isis/citation/CBB001250189/)
Article
Ortega, Francisco;
(2009)
Elementos para uma história da neuroascese
(/isis/citation/CBB000932964/)
Book
LaPointe, Leonard L.;
(2012)
Paul Broca and the Origins of Language in the Brain
(/isis/citation/CBB001213879/)
Article
Wassmann, Claudia;
(2014)
“Picturesque Incisiveness”: Explaining the Celebrity of James's Theory of Emotion
(/isis/citation/CBB001420015/)
Article
Macmillan, Malcolm;
(2000)
Restoring Phineas Gage: A 150th Retrospective
(/isis/citation/CBB000111173/)
Thesis
Asaro, Peter M.;
(2006)
On the Origins of the Synthetic Mind: Working Models, Mechanisms, and Simulations
(/isis/citation/CBB001560562/)
Article
Eadie, Mervyn J.;
Bladin, Peter F.;
(2010)
The Idea of Epilepsy as a Disease Per Se
(/isis/citation/CBB001034926/)
Article
Pendleton, Courtney;
Zaidi, Hasan A.;
Chaichana, Kaisorn L.;
Raza, Shaan M.;
Carson, Benjamin S.;
Cohen-Gadol, Aaron A.;
Quinones-Hinojosa, Alfredo;
(2012)
Harvey Cushing's Contributions to Motor Mapping: 1902--1912
(/isis/citation/CBB001211985/)
Article
Maria Angela Veronese;
(2022)
Michelangelo Asson e Filippo Lussana: Un clinico ed un fisiologo tra i protagonisti del dibattito italiano sulla localizzazione cerebrale del linguaggio nella prima metà dell’Ottocento
(/isis/citation/CBB316528688/)
Book
Kreft, Gerald;
(2005)
Deutsch-jüdische Geschichte und Hirnforschung: Ludwig Edingers Neurologisches Institut in Frankfurt am Main
(/isis/citation/CBB001033123/)
Book
Sonja Boos;
(2021)
The Emergence of Neuroscience and the German Novel: Poetics of the Brain
(/isis/citation/CBB889443020/)
Be the first to comment!