This paper takes up the concept of `crisis' at both historical and historiographical levels. It proceeds through two examples of periods that have been described by historians of physics using a language of crisis. The first examines an incipient German theoretical-physics community around 1900 and the debates that concerned the so-called `failure' of the mechanical world view. It is argued, largely on the basis of what is now an extensive body of secondary literature, that there is little evidence for a widespread crisis in this period. Abandoning the term as both description and explanation, one comes to the far more intriguing suggestion that the conflict over foundations was not evidence of a divisive dissonance but rather of collective construction. What has been termed crisis was, in fact, the practice of theoretical physics in the fin de siècle. The second example is the period either side of the advent of quantum mechanics around 1925. Different subgroups within the theoretical-physics community viewed the state of the field in dramatically different ways. Those, such as members of the Sommerfeld school in Munich, who saw the task of the physicist as lying in the solution of particular problems, neither saw a crisis nor acknowledged its resolution. On the other hand those, such as several researchers associated with Niels Bohr's institute in Copenhagen, who focused on the creation and adaptation of new principles, openly advocated a crisis even before decisive anomalies arose. They then sought to conceptualize the development of quantum mechanics in terms of crises and the revolutions that followed. Thomas Kuhn's language of crisis, revolution and anomaly, it is concluded, arises from his focus on only one set of theoretical physicists. A closer look at intra-communal differences opens a new vista onto what he termed `normal' and `revolutionary' science.
...MoreDescription An exploration of Kuhnian ideas of change in science using examples from the theoretical physics community in two periods of apparent crisis: 1900 and 1925.
Similar Citations
Article
Dyson, Freeman J.;
(2012)
Is Science Mostly Driven by Ideas or by Tools?
(/isis/citation/CBB001320450/)
Article
Dongen, Jeroen van;
(2007)
Emil Rupp, Albert Einstein, and the Canal Ray Experiments on Wave-Particle Duality: Scientific Fraud and Theoretical Bias
(/isis/citation/CBB000850132/)
Article
Wennerholm, Staffan;
(2007)
I fysikforskningens utkant. Eva von Bahrs vetenskapliga gemenskaper, 1909--1914
(/isis/citation/CBB001220345/)
Thesis
Hanson, Todd Alan;
(2007)
Quantum Entanglements: Collaboration and Communication in a ScientificCommunity of Practice
(/isis/citation/CBB001560967/)
Chapter
Silvan S. Schweber;
(2016)
On Kuhnian and Hacking-Type Revolutions
(/isis/citation/CBB746468868/)
Article
Schroer, Bert;
(2013)
The Einstein-Jordan Conundrum and Its Relation to Ongoing Foundational Research in Local Quantum Physics
(/isis/citation/CBB001212075/)
Article
De Gregorio, Alberto;
Sebastiani, Fabio;
(2007)
Il debutto di Enrico Fermi come professore di fisica teorica
(/isis/citation/CBB001023756/)
Article
Miller, Sean;
(2011)
The Work of Imagining Subatomic Particles in Early Quantum Mechanics
(/isis/citation/CBB001252267/)
Article
Brown, Paul Tolliver;
(2009)
Relativity, Quantum Physics, and Consciousness in Virginia Woolf's “To the Lighthouse”
(/isis/citation/CBB001320696/)
Article
Giulio Peruzzi;
Alessio Rocci;
(2019)
Quantum Cultures during the Prehistory of Quantum Gravity: Léon Rosenfeld's Early Contributions to Quantum Gravity
(/isis/citation/CBB959398801/)
Chapter
Dolling, Lisa M.;
(2008)
Practical Arrangements and Fictitious Use: Bohr's Photon Box
(/isis/citation/CBB000953880/)
Book
Petkov, Vesselin;
(2010)
Minkowski Spacetime: A Hundred Years Later
(/isis/citation/CBB001032084/)
Article
Matthew Holmes;
(2019)
Imitating nature: Analogy and experiment in D'Arcy Thompson's Science of Form
(/isis/citation/CBB812197601/)
Article
Stöltzner, Michael;
(2009)
Gangarten des Rationalen. Zu den Zeitstrukturen der Quantenrevolution
(/isis/citation/CBB000932098/)
Article
Gingras, Yves;
(2010)
The Transformation of Physics from 1900 to 1945
(/isis/citation/CBB001036145/)
Article
Hon, Giora;
(2003)
From Propagation to Structure: The Experimental Technique of Bombardment as a Contributing Factor to the Emerging Quantum Physics
(/isis/citation/CBB000641707/)
Book
Badino, Massimiliano;
(2010)
Il professore e il suo demone: La lunga lotta di Max Planck contro la statistica (1896--1906)
(/isis/citation/CBB001252424/)
Article
Dongen, Jeroen van;
(2007)
Reactionaries and Einstein's Fame: “German Scientists for the Preservation of Pure Science,” Relativity, and the Bad Nauheim Meeting
(/isis/citation/CBB000780203/)
Chapter
Seth, Suman;
(2006)
Allgemeine Physik? Max Planck und die Gemeinschaft der theoretischen Physik, 1906--1914
(/isis/citation/CBB001021526/)
Essay Review
Jähnert, Martin;
(2012)
Revisiting the 1927 Solvay Conference and the Early Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics
(/isis/citation/CBB001566762/)
Be the first to comment!