“Hypotheses, everywhere only hypotheses!!”: On Some Contexts of Dilthey's Critique of Explanatory Psychology (2007)
Feest, Uljana (Author)
Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C: Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences
Volume: 38
Pages: 43--62
In 1894, Wilhelm Dilthey published an article in which he formulated a critique of what he called `explanatory psychology', contrasting it with his own conception of `descriptive psychology'. Dilthey's descriptive psychology, in turn, was to provide the basis for Dilthey's specific philosophy of the human sciences (Geisteswissenschaften). In this paper, I contextualize Dilthey's critique of explanatory psychology. I show that while this critique comes across as very broad and sweeping, he in fact had specific opponents in mind, namely, scholars who, like him, attempted to theorize about the relationship between the individual and society, between psychology and the other human sciences. Dilthey's critique of explanatory psychology is the flipside of his critique of sociology, which he had already formulated. He challenged both because he felt that they gave the wrong kind of answer to the task of overcoming metaphysics within the human sciences. In particular, I identify the founders of Völkerpsychologie, Moritz Lazarus and Heymann Steinthal, and (more importantly) their student, Georg Simmel, as Dilthey's targets. I provide textual and historical evidence for this thesis.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Riccardo Martinelli;
(2018)
Defining Human Sciences: Theodor Waitz’s Influence on Dilthey
(/isis/citation/CBB800260217/)
Article
Christian Damböck;
(2020)
What Is Descriptive Psychology? Ebbinghaus’s 1896 Criticism of Dilthey Revisited
(/isis/citation/CBB745855190/)
Article
Guillaume Fréchette;
(2020)
Descriptive Psychology: Brentano and Dilthey
(/isis/citation/CBB957672505/)
Article
Makkreel, Rudolf A.;
(2008)
Kant and the Development of the Human and Cultural Sciences
(/isis/citation/CBB000931160/)
Book
Canadelli, Elena;
(2013)
Più positivo dei positivisti: Antropologia, psicologia, evoluzionismo in Tito Vignoli
(/isis/citation/CBB001450137/)
Article
Lembeck, Karl-Heinz;
(1996)
Kantianismus oder Neukantianismus in Diltheys Psychologie?
(/isis/citation/CBB000072074/)
Article
Lessing, Hans-Ulrich;
(1985)
Briefe an Dilthey anlässlich der Veröffentlichung seiner Ideen über eine beschreibende und zergliedernde Psychologie
(/isis/citation/CBB000053014/)
Article
(1994/95)
Diltheys Psychologie
(/isis/citation/CBB000054675/)
Article
Bouterse, Jeroen;
Karstens, Bart;
(2015)
A Diversity of Divisions: Tracing the History of the Demarcation between the Sciences and the Humanities
(/isis/citation/CBB001551432/)
Article
Massimiliano Aragona;
(2019)
The influence of Max Weber on the concept of empathic understanding (Verstehen) in the psychopathology of Karl Jaspers
(/isis/citation/CBB625357803/)
Chapter
Teo, Thomas;
(2001)
Karl Marx and Wilhelm Dilthey on the Socio-Historical Conceptualization of the Mind
(/isis/citation/CBB000102780/)
Article
Nabeel Hamid;
(2016)
Dilthey on the Unity of Science
(/isis/citation/CBB876527354/)
Article
Kumazaki, Tsutomu;
(2013)
The Theoretical Root of Karl Jaspers' General Psychopathology. Part 1: Reconsidering the Influence of Phenomenology and Hermeneutics
(/isis/citation/CBB001320331/)
Book
Failla, Mariannina;
(1992)
Dilthey e la psicologia del suo tempo
(/isis/citation/CBB000063980/)
Book
Saunders, Barbara;
(2007)
The Debate about Colour Naming in 19th-Century German Philology
(/isis/citation/CBB000850388/)
Thesis
Pettit, Michael John;
(2006)
The Science of Deception: The Human Sciences, the Law, and Commercial Culture in America, 1860s--1920s
(/isis/citation/CBB001560609/)
Article
Morawski, Jill G.;
St. Martin, Jenna;
(2011)
The Evolving Vocabulary of the Social Sciences: The Case of “Socialization”
(/isis/citation/CBB001033711/)
Article
Zama, Rita;
(2006)
La questione antropologica in Antonio Rosmini
(/isis/citation/CBB000720007/)
Book
Beer, Daniel;
(2008)
Renovating Russia: The Human Sciences and the Fate of Liberal Modernity, 1880--1930
(/isis/citation/CBB000850348/)
Article
Makkreel, Rudolf A.;
(2003)
The Cognition-Knowledge Distinction in Kant and Dilthey and the Implications for Psychology and Self-Understanding
(/isis/citation/CBB000340875/)
Be the first to comment!