Bringing Physics to Bear on the Phenomenon of Life: The Divergent Positions of Bohr, Delbrück, and Schrödinger (2006)
Domondon, Andrew T. (Author)
Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C: Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences
Volume: 37
Pages: 433--458
The received view on the contributions of the physics community to the birth of molecular biology tends to present the physics community as sharing a basic level consensus on how physics should be brought to bear on biology. I argue, however, that a close examination of the views of three leading physicists involved in the birth of molecular biology, Bohr, Delbrück, and Schrödinger, suggests that there existed fundamental disagreements on how physics should be employed to solve problems in biology even within the physics community. In particular, I focus on how these three figures differed sharply in their assessment of the relevance of complementarity, the potential of chemical methods, and the relative importance of classical physics. In addition, I assess and develop Roll-Hansen's attempt to conceptualize this history in terms of models of scientific change advanced by Kuhn and Lakatos. Though neither model is fully successful in explaining the divergence of views among these three physicists, I argue that the extent and quality of difference in their views help elucidate and extend some themes that are left opaque in Kuhn's model.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Freire, Olival, Jr.;
Leyla Joaquim;
Charbel N. El-Hani;
(2015)
Quantum Explorers: Bohr, Jordan, and Delbrück Venturing into Biology
(/isis/citation/CBB446852324/)
Article
Sloan, Phillip R.;
(2012)
How Was Teleology Eliminated in Early Molecular Biology?
(/isis/citation/CBB001221597/)
Book
Jennifer Burwell;
(2018)
Quantum Language and the Migration of Scientific Concepts
(/isis/citation/CBB682085795/)
Article
Hilgevoord, Jan;
(2005)
Time in Quantum Mechanics: A Story of Confusion
(/isis/citation/CBB000501568/)
Article
Perovic, Slobodan;
(2006)
Schrödinger's Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics and the Relevance of Bohr's Experimental Critique
(/isis/citation/CBB000670174/)
Thesis
Diamond, Ethel;
(2006)
The Role of Philosophy in the Conceptual Development of Quantum Physics
(/isis/citation/CBB001560852/)
Book
Parkinson, Gavin;
(2008)
Surrealism, Art, and Modern Science Relativity, Quantum Mechanics, Epistemology
(/isis/citation/CBB001251160/)
Article
McKaughan, Daniel J.;
(2005)
The Influence of Niels Bohr on Max Delbrück: Revisiting the Hopes Inspired by “Light and Life”
(/isis/citation/CBB000650564/)
Book
Wenkel, Simone;
Deichmann, Ute;
(2007)
Max Delbrück and Cologne: An Early Chapter of German Molecular Biology
(/isis/citation/CBB000830131/)
Article
Deichmann, Ute;
(2008)
Different Methods and Metaphysics in Early Molecular Genetics -- A Case of Disparity of Research?
(/isis/citation/CBB000931566/)
Article
Sankaran, Neeraja;
(2008)
Stepping-Stones to One-Step Growth: Frank Macfarlane Burnet's Role in Elucidating the Viral Nature of the Bacteriophages
(/isis/citation/CBB000932000/)
Book
Plotnitsky, Arkady;
(2010)
Epistemology and Probability: Bohr, Heisenberg, Schrödinger and the Nature of Quantum-Theoretical Thinking
(/isis/citation/CBB001230453/)
Article
Rigden, John S.;
Stuewer, Roger H.;
(2012)
Understanding of Quantum Mechanics Eludes Physicists for Eighty-Six Years
(/isis/citation/CBB001221642/)
Article
A. E. Walsby;
M. J. S. Hodge;
(2017)
Schrödinger's code-script: not a genetic cipher but a code of development
(/isis/citation/CBB517377623/)
Article
Mawhin, Jean;
Ronveaux, André;
(2010)
Schrödinger and Dirac Equations for the Hydrogen Atom, and Laguerre Polynomials
(/isis/citation/CBB001022003/)
Article
Perovic, Slobodan;
(2008)
Why Were Matrix Mechanics and Wave Mechanics Considered Equivalent?
(/isis/citation/CBB000933672/)
Article
D'Agostino, Salvo;
(2009)
Il ‘gatto’ di Schroedinger in una lettura del testo originale del celebre saggio
(/isis/citation/CBB314642805/)
Article
D'Agostino, Salvo;
(2004)
The Bild Conception of Physical Theory: Helmholtz, Hertz, and Schrödinger
(/isis/citation/CBB000641781/)
Book
Gumbrecht, Hans Ulrich;
(2011)
What Is Life? The Intellectual Pertinence of Erwin Schrödinger
(/isis/citation/CBB001231937/)
Article
Joas, Christian;
Lehner, Christoph;
(2009)
The Classical Roots of Wave Mechanics: Schrödinger's Transformations of the Optical-Mechanical Analogy
(/isis/citation/CBB000933683/)
Physics in Perspective
Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C: Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences
Physis: Rivista Internazionale di Storia della Scienza
Isis: International Review Devoted to the History of Science and Its Cultural Influences
History and Philosophy of the Life Sciences
Be the first to comment!