This paper's main contention is that some basically methodological developments in science which are apparently distant and unrelated can be seen as part of a sequential story. Focusing on general inferential and epistemological matters, the paper links occurrences separated by both in time and space, by formal and representational issues rather than social or disciplinary links. It focuses on a few limited aspects of several cognitive practices in medical and biological contexts separated by geography, disciplines and decades, but connected by long term transdisciplinary representational and inferential structures and constraints. The paper intends to show a given set of knowledge claims based on organizing statistically empirical data can be seen to have been underpinned by a previous, more familiar, and probably more natural, narrative handling of similar evidence. To achieve that this paper moves from medicine in France in the late eighteenth and early nineteenth century to the second half of the nineteenth century in England among gentleman naturalists, following its subject: the shift from narrative depiction of hereditary transmission of physical peculiarities to posterior statistical articulations of the same phenomena. Some early defenders of heredity as an important (if not the most important) causal presence in the understanding of life adopted singular narratives, in the form of case stories from medical and natural history traditions, to flesh out a special kind of causality peculiar to heredity. This work tries to reconstruct historically the rationale that drove the use of such narratives. It then shows that when this rationale was methodologically challenged, its basic narrative and probabilistic underpinings were transferred to the statistical quantificational tools that took their place.
...MoreDescription Explores shift to a statistical explanation of hereditary phenomena by looking at 18th-century French medicine and 19th-century English natural history.
Thesis
Wynn, James;
(2006)
Life's Rich Pattern: The Role of Statistics and Probability in Nineteenth Century Argumentation for Theories of Evolution, Variation, and Heredity
(/isis/citation/CBB001561728/)
Article
Caponi, Gustavo;
(2011)
Los taxones como tipos: Buffon, Cuvier y Lamarck
(/isis/citation/CBB001420506/)
Article
Pilpel, Avital;
(2007)
Statistics Is Not Enough: Revisiting Ronald A. Fisher's Critique (1936) of Mendel's Experimental Results (1866)
(/isis/citation/CBB000830396/)
Chapter
Sober, Elliott;
(2007)
Sex Ratio Theory, Ancient and Modern: An Eighteenth-Century Debate about Intelligent Design and the Development of Models in Evolutionary Biology
(/isis/citation/CBB000774728/)
Thesis
Wynn, James;
(2005)
Life's Rich Pattern: The Role of Statistics and Probability in NineteenthCentury Argumentation for Theories of Evolution, Variation, and Heredity
(/isis/citation/CBB001561634/)
Article
Alborn, Timothy L.;
(2001)
Insurance against Germ Theory: Commerce and Conservatism in Late-Victorian Medicine
(/isis/citation/CBB000100879/)
Article
Camós, Agustí;
(2013)
Antoni de Martí i Franquès, la generación espontánea y la transformación de los organismos
(/isis/citation/CBB001450488/)
Chapter
Loison, Laurent;
(2011)
The Notions of Plasticity and Heredity among French Neo-Lamarckians (1880--1940): From Complementarity to Incompatibility
(/isis/citation/CBB001500086/)
Article
Vallejo, Mauro Sebastián;
(2012)
El problema de la consanguinidad en la medicina francesa (1850- 1880): cuando heredar demasiado era un riesgo y un deseo
(/isis/citation/CBB001450446/)
Article
López-Beltrán, Carlos;
(2004)
In the Cradle of Heredity; French Physicians and L'Hérédité Naturelle in the Early 19th Century
(/isis/citation/CBB000550858/)
Chapter
Corsi, Pietro;
(2011)
Jean-Baptiste Lamarck: from Myth to History
(/isis/citation/CBB001500081/)
Article
Vallejo, Mauro Sebastián;
(2013)
El problema de la herencia en la medicina francesa (1800--1846)
(/isis/citation/CBB001200196/)
Book
Le Guyader, Hervé;
(2004)
Étienne Geoffroy Saint-Hilaire, 1772--1844: A Visionary Naturalist
(/isis/citation/CBB000550942/)
Article
Xu, Chuansheng;
Qu, Anjing;
(2006)
A Study on Pierre Simon de Laplace's Théorie Analytiques des Probabilitiés
(/isis/citation/CBB001020782/)
Article
Snait B. Gissis;
(2023)
The Neo-Lamarckian Tools Deployed by the Young Durkheim: 1882–1892
(/isis/citation/CBB708515471/)
Thesis
Pierre-Etienne Stockland;
(2018)
Statecraft and Insect Oeconomies in the Global French Enlightenment (1670-1815)
(/isis/citation/CBB521958749/)
Article
Meusnier, Norbert;
(2006)
Sur l'histoire de l'enseignement des probabilités et des statistiques
(/isis/citation/CBB000931993/)
Book
Hahn, Roger;
(2013)
Correspondance de Pierre Simon Laplace (1749--1827)
(/isis/citation/CBB001211954/)
Book
Delange, Yves;
(2002)
Jean-Baptiste Lamarck: Biographie
(/isis/citation/CBB000201813/)
Article
Nicholas W. Gillham;
(2015)
The Battle Between the Biometricians and the Mendelians: How Sir Francis Galton’s Work Caused his Disciples to Reach Conflicting Conclusions About the Hereditary Mechanism
(/isis/citation/CBB738872407/)
Be the first to comment!