Nicolas Malebranche was the first Cartesian philosopher to challenge Descartes' claim that we are capable of possessing a clear and distinct understanding of the soul's nature. Other Cartesians, including Clauberg, La Forge, and Cordemoy, accepted without question the conclusion of the Second Meditation that the nature of the soul is better known than is the nature of body. After presenting an overview of Malebranche's argument, this note turns to the Cartesian philosopher Pierre-Sylvain Régis. Régis, like the Cartesians before Malebranche, sides with Descartes in this debate over the question of whether we can have knowledge of our soul's nature, but unlike his predecessors, he provides an original argument defending his position. This argument is, I argue, a direct response to the argument Malebranche had used in his case against Descartes.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Ott, Walter;
(2008)
Régis's Scholastic Mechanism
(/isis/citation/CBB000930744/)
Article
Raphaële Andrault;
(2018)
The Mind–Body Problem and the Role of Pain: Cross-Fire Between Leibniz and His Cartesian Readers
(/isis/citation/CBB247713160/)
Article
Marleen Rozemond;
(2016)
Descartes, Malebranche and Leibniz: Conceptions of Substance in Arguments for the Immateriality of the Soul
(/isis/citation/CBB117763212/)
Chapter
Smith, Justin E. H.;
(2008)
Spirit as Intermediary in Post-Cartesian Natural Philosophy
(/isis/citation/CBB000952947/)
Article
Blank, Andreas;
(2010)
Material Souls and Imagination in Late Aristotelian Embryology
(/isis/citation/CBB000954801/)
Article
Ablondi, Fred;
(1999)
Malebranche and Knowledge of the Soul
(/isis/citation/CBB000111462/)
Article
Schmaltz, Tad M.;
(2003)
Cartesian Causation: Body--Body Interaction, Motion, and Eternal Truths
(/isis/citation/CBB000340900/)
Chapter
Pécharman, Martine;
(2008)
Malebranche's Ontological Problem of the Perception of Bodies
(/isis/citation/CBB000800110/)
Book
Schmaltz, Tad M.;
(2002)
Radical Cartesianism: The French Reception of Descartes
(/isis/citation/CBB000302043/)
Article
Andrea Sangiacomo;
(2016)
From Secondary Causes to Artificial Instruments: Pierre-Sylvain Régis's Rethinking of Scholastic Accounts of Causation
(/isis/citation/CBB454034425/)
Book
Landucci, Sergio;
(2002)
La Mente in Cartesio
(/isis/citation/CBB000301858/)
Chapter
Clarke, Desmond;
(2007)
La théorie des passions selon Louis de la Forge
(/isis/citation/CBB001022504/)
Article
Leen Spruit;
(2017)
Sebastiano Bartoli on Life and the Soul
(/isis/citation/CBB245646731/)
Book
Bakker, Paul J. J. M.;
Thijssen, Johannes M. M. H.;
(2007)
Mind, Cognition and Representation: The Tradition of Commentaries on Aristotle's De anima
(/isis/citation/CBB001020173/)
Article
Sarah Hutton;
(2017)
Salving the Phenomena of Mind: Energy, Hegemonikon, and Sympathy in Cudworth
(/isis/citation/CBB731645284/)
Article
Sportelli, Silvano;
(2000)
Il misterioso “Malebranchiste” di Parigi del XVIII secolo e l'“egoismo” metafisico
(/isis/citation/CBB000640750/)
Book
Heinämaa, Sara;
Reuter, Martina;
(2008)
Psychology and Philosophy: Inquiries into the Soul from Late Scholasticism to Contemporary Thought
(/isis/citation/CBB001035170/)
Article
Christophe Schmit;
(2015)
Les dynamiques de Jean-Jacques Dortous de Mairan
(/isis/citation/CBB695462531/)
Article
Cimino, Guido;
(2015)
Il problema dell’«anima dei bruti» nell’opera di Alessandro Pascoli: da Cartesio al vitalismo
(/isis/citation/CBB077046394/)
Article
Sobol, Valeria;
(2006)
Nerves, Brain, or Heart? The Physiology of Emotions and the Mind-Body Problem in Russian Sentimentalism
(/isis/citation/CBB000660083/)
Be the first to comment!