This article discusses the predicament of historians becoming part of the history they are investigating and illustrates the issue in a particular case. The case is that of the randomized controlled trial (RCT) - more specifically, its use for testing the effects of providing heroin to severe heroin abusers. I counter the established view of the RCT as a matter of timeless logic and argue that this research design was developed in the context of administrative knowledge making under twentieth-century economic liberalism of which it epitomizes some central values. I also argue that the applicability of the RCT depends on the degree to which its advocates can define the issue to be studied according to its inherent values. Next, I demonstrate how advocates of an RCT with heroin provision in the Netherlands steered the political discussion on heroin provision and how the values of economic liberalism also shaped the results of the Dutch maintenance experiment. In addition, I relate how my analysis of this experiment became part of political debates in the Netherlands. Contrary to my intentions, adversaries of heroin maintenance used my critique on the heroin RCT as an argument against heroin maintenance. Such risks are inherent to historiography and sociology of science aiming at practical relevance while challenging treasured scientific beliefs. I conclude that it still seems better to expose arguments on unjustified certainties than to suppress them for strategic reasons.
...MoreDescription On “the randomized controlled trial (RCT) [and] its use for testing the effects of providing heroin to severe heroin abusers.” (from the abstract)
Article
Dehue, Trudy;
(2002)
A Dutch Treat: Randomized Controlled Experimentation and the Case of Heroin Maintenance in the Netherlands
(/isis/citation/CBB000400969/)
Article
Mold, Alex;
(2004)
The “British System” of Heroin Addiction Treatment and the Opening of Drug Dependence Units, 1965--1970
(/isis/citation/CBB000770532/)
Article
Dehue, Trudy;
(2002)
A Dutch Treat: Randomized Controlled Experimentation and the Case of Heroin-Maintenance in the Netherlands
(/isis/citation/CBB000200128/)
Article
Campbell, Nancy D.;
(2006)
“A New Deal for the Drug Addict”: The Addiction Research Center, Lexington, Kentucky
(/isis/citation/CBB000671026/)
Article
Kessel, Nils;
(2013)
“Doriden von Ciba: Sleeping Pills, Pharmaceutical Marketing, and Thalidomide, 1955--1963
(/isis/citation/CBB001320754/)
Article
Acker, Caroline Jean;
(2010)
How Crack Found a Niche in the American Ghetto: The Historical Epidemiology of Drug-Related Harm
(/isis/citation/CBB001036125/)
Thesis
Glenn, Jason Edwin;
(2005)
Medicalizing Addictions, Criminalizing Addicts: Race, Politics and Profit inNarratives of Addiction
(/isis/citation/CBB001561587/)
Article
Bennett, Cary;
(2011)
Methadone Maintenance Treatment: Disciplining the “Addict”
(/isis/citation/CBB001232068/)
Article
Yichen Rao;
(2019)
From Confucianism to Psychology: Rebooting Internet Addicts in China
(/isis/citation/CBB064888484/)
Article
Clark, Claire D.;
(2012)
Tough Love: A Brief Cultural History of the Addiction Intervention
(/isis/citation/CBB001260563/)
Article
Courtwright, David T.;
(2010)
The NIDA Brain Disease Paradigm: History, Resistance and Spinoffs
(/isis/citation/CBB001036126/)
Article
Holly M Karibo;
(2020)
‘The Only Trouble is the Dam’ Heroin’: Addiction, Treatment and Punishment at the Fort Worth Narcotic Farm
(/isis/citation/CBB129073964/)
Article
Hewitt, Kim;
(2011)
The “Feeling of Knowing”, the Psychedelic Sensorium, and Contemporary Neuroscience: Shifting Contexts for Noetic Insight
(/isis/citation/CBB001035706/)
Article
Emde Boas, Peter van;
(2013)
Evert Marie Bruins (1909--1990): intelligent, productief en controversieel
(/isis/citation/CBB001321105/)
Article
Alberts, Gerard;
Beckers, Danny;
(2013)
Dirk Jan Struik (1894--2000)
(/isis/citation/CBB001321100/)
Article
Homburg, Ernst;
(2013)
Robert James Forbes (1900--1973)---chemicus-archeoloog, techniekhistoricus, wetenschapshistoricus
(/isis/citation/CBB001321101/)
Article
Flipse, Ab;
(2013)
Reijer Hooykaas (1906--1994)
(/isis/citation/CBB001321103/)
Article
Huijnen, Pim;
(2013)
Evert Cornelis van Leersum (1862--1938): pionier van de geschiedenis van de geneeskunde
(/isis/citation/CBB001321090/)
Article
Knecht-Van Eekelen, Annemarie de;
(2013)
Daniël de Moulin (1919--2002)
(/isis/citation/CBB001321108/)
Article
Vermij, Rienk;
(2013)
H.A.M. (Harry) Snelders (*1930)
(/isis/citation/CBB001321110/)
Be the first to comment!