From Heresy to Dogma in Accounts of Opposition to Howard Temin's DNA Provirus Hypothesis (2002)
n 1964 the Wisconsin virologist Howard Temin proposed the DNA provirus hypothesis to explain the mechanism by which a cancer-producing virus containing only RNA infects and transforms cells. His hypothesis reversed the flow of genetic information, as ordained by the central dogma of molecular biology. Although there was initial opposition to his hypothesis it was widely accepted, after the discovery of reverse transcriptase in 1970. Most accounts of Temin's hypothesis after the discovery portray the hypothesis as heretical, because it challenged the central dogma. Temin himself in his Nobel Prize speech of 1975 narrates a similar story about its reception. But are these accounts warranted? I argue that members of the virology community opposed Temin's provirus hypothesis not simply because it was a counterexample to the central dogma, but more importantly because his experimental evidence for supporting it was inconclusive. Furthermore, I propose that these accounts of opposition to the DNA provirus hypothesis as heretical, written by Temin and others after the discovery of reverse transcriptase, played a significant role in establishing retrovirology as a specialized field.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Fisher, Susie;
(2010)
Not Beyond Reasonable Doubt: Howard Temin's Provirus Hypothesis Revisited
(/isis/citation/CBB001022393/)
Article
Alexander von Schwerin;
(2015)
Shaping Vulnerable Bodies at the Thin Boundary between Environment and Organism: Skin, DNA Repair, and a Genealogy of DNA Care Strategies
(/isis/citation/CBB878598043/)
Book
Gregory J. Morgan;
(2022)
Cancer Virus Hunters: A History of Tumor Virology
(/isis/citation/CBB284978916/)
Book
Wenkel, Simone;
Deichmann, Ute;
(2007)
Max Delbrück and Cologne: An Early Chapter of German Molecular Biology
(/isis/citation/CBB000830131/)
Thesis
Barker, Crispin Robert Claude;
(2008)
From Atom Bomb to the “Genetic Time Bomb”: Telomeres, Aging, and Cancer in the Era of Molecular Biology
(/isis/citation/CBB001561394/)
Book
Bernardino Fantini;
Fabrizio Rufo;
(2017)
Il codice della vita. Una storia della genetica tra scienza e bioetica
(/isis/citation/CBB297801530/)
Essay Review
Strauss, Bernard S.;
(2004)
Rosy and Jim: The Mystery of the Double Helix
(/isis/citation/CBB001566358/)
Book
Olby, Robert;
(2009)
Francis Crick: Hunter of Life's Secrets
(/isis/citation/CBB001021210/)
Book
Schwartz, James;
(2008)
In Pursuit of the Gene: From Darwin to DNA
(/isis/citation/CBB000774889/)
Article
Holliday, Robin;
(2003)
The Early Years of Molecular Biology: Personal Recollections
(/isis/citation/CBB000470292/)
Article
Lazcano, Antonio;
(2012)
The Biochemical Roots of the RNA World: from Zymonucleic Acid to Ribozymes
(/isis/citation/CBB001251465/)
Article
Enrique Wulff;
(2023)
Clinical Diagnosis and Cancer Probe: A History of Unity and Mass Migration
(/isis/citation/CBB743051605/)
Book
Ridley, Matt;
(2006)
Francis Crick: Discoverer of the Genetic Code
(/isis/citation/CBB000641605/)
Chapter
Roberto Taramelli;
(2016)
Una nuova visione del cancro attraverso le lenti della dinamica dei sistemi
(/isis/citation/CBB225293248/)
Chapter
Rheinberger, Hans-Jörg;
(2012)
Internationalism and the History of Molecular Biology
(/isis/citation/CBB001422700/)
Book
Neeraja Sankaran;
(2021)
A Tale of Two Viruses: Parallels in the Research Trajectories of Tumor and Bacterial Viruses
(/isis/citation/CBB280830487/)
Book
David Quammen;
(2019)
The Tangled Tree: A Radical New History of Life
(/isis/citation/CBB562530231/)
Article
Gladys Kostyrka;
Neeraja Sankaran;
(2020)
From Obstacle to Lynchpin: The Evolution of the Role of Bacteriophage Lysogeny in Defining and Understanding Viruses
(/isis/citation/CBB093953022/)
Book
Holmes, Frederic Lawrence;
Summers, William C.;
(2006)
Reconceiving the Gene: Seymour Benzer's Adventures in Phage Genetics
(/isis/citation/CBB000772243/)
Article
Darwin H. Stapleton;
(2012)
Oswald T. Avery and the Technological Basis for the Discovery of DNA at the Rockefeller Institute for Medical Research
(/isis/citation/CBB335328170/)
Be the first to comment!