Lalli, Roberto (Author)
In the 1930s the mathematical physicist Howard P. Robertson was the main referee of the journal Physical Review for papers concerning general relativity and related subjects. The rich correspondence between Robertson and the editors of the journal enables a historical investigation of the refereeing process of Physical Review at the time that it was becoming one of the most influential physics periodicals in the world. By focusing on this case study, the paper investigates two complementary aspects of the evolution of the refereeing process: first, the historical evolution of the refereeing practices in connection with broader contextual changes, and second, the attempts to define the activity of the referee, including the epistemic virtues required and the journal's functions according to the participants' categories. By exploring the tension between Robertson's idealized picture about how the referee should behave and the desire to promote his intellectual agenda, I show that the evaluation criteria that Robertson employed were contextually dependent and I argue that, in the 1930s, through his reports the referee had an enormous power in defining what direction future research should take.
...More
Article
Brush, Stephen G.;
(2002)
Peer Review Materials for Physical Review
(/isis/citation/CBB000340286/)
Article
Rekdal, Ole Bjørn;
(2014)
Academic Urban Legends
(/isis/citation/CBB001421187/)
Book
Franklin, Allan;
(2013)
Shifting Standards: Experiments in Particle Physics in the Twentieth Century
(/isis/citation/CBB001500041/)
Article
Zund, Joseph D.;
(2002)
George David Birkhoff and John von Neumann: A Question of Priority and the Ergodic Theorems, 1931--1932
(/isis/citation/CBB000200283/)
Article
Siegmund-Schultze, Reinhard;
(2007)
Einsteins Nachruf auf Emmy Noether in der New York Times, 1935
(/isis/citation/CBB001036207/)
Article
Saana Jukola;
(2017)
A Social Epistemological Inquiry into Biases in Journal Peer Review
(/isis/citation/CBB482680482/)
Article
Despeaux, Sloan Evans;
(2011)
Fit to Print? Referee Reports on Mathematics for the Nineteenth-Century Journals of the Royal Society of London
(/isis/citation/CBB001220419/)
Article
Redner, Sidney;
(2005)
Citation Statistics from 110 Years of Physical Review
(/isis/citation/CBB000540038/)
Article
Scheiding, Tom;
(2009)
Paying for Knowledge One Page at a Time: The Author Fee in Physics in Twentieth-Century America
(/isis/citation/CBB001022599/)
Article
Hirschauer, Stefan;
(2010)
Editorial Judgments: A Praxeology of “Voting” in Peer Review
(/isis/citation/CBB000953625/)
Article
Koen Vermier;
(2022)
Opening up the History of Science: A Perspective from Centaurus
(/isis/citation/CBB090865174/)
Article
Pierandrea Lo Nostro;
(2022)
To Print or Not to Print? Preprints and Publication: How the Covid-19 Pandemic Affected the Quality of Scientific Production
(/isis/citation/CBB191535930/)
Article
Benjamin Newman;
(2019)
Authorising geographical knowledge: The development of peer review in The Journal of the Royal Geographical Society, 1830–c.1880
(/isis/citation/CBB718234092/)
Article
Andersen, Hanne;
(2009)
Journals under Threat: A Joint Response from History of Science, Technology, and Medicine Editors
(/isis/citation/CBB000831767/)
Article
Sergio Sismondo;
(August 2016)
Editorial: Sorting on arXiv: Introduction to an ad hoc section
(/isis/citation/CBB354042804/)
Chapter
Buchwald, Jed Z.;
(2003)
The Scholar's Seeing Eye
(/isis/citation/CBB000330810/)
Chapter
Gläser, Jochen;
Lange, Stefan;
Laudel, Grit;
Schimank, Uwe;
(2010)
Informed Authority? The Limited Use of Research Evaluation Systems for Managerial Control in Universities
(/isis/citation/CBB001420859/)
Article
Hulme, Mike;
(2010)
Claiming and Adjudicating on Mt. Kilimanjaro's Shrinking Glaciers: Guy Callendar, Al Gore and Extended Peer Communities
(/isis/citation/CBB001034650/)
Book
Forsdyke, Donald Roy;
(2000)
Tomorrow's Cures Today? How to Reform the Health Research System
(/isis/citation/CBB000101426/)
Article
Baldwin, Melinda Clare;
(2015)
Credibility, Peer Review, and Nature, 1945--1990
(/isis/citation/CBB001552651/)
Be the first to comment!